im317 @ 22/5/2017 23:41

Maddie @ 22/5/2017 22:28 im317 @ 22/5/2017 20:14 Stephen @ 22/5/2017 21:09 I don't see a combination of DS' role and this anonymous leaker role as overpowered as it is possible that the anonymous role outs people who are actually mafia whereas DS' role can cause the town to misinterpret, such as what happened D2 even with the lie detector actually getting random results? imo that would balance thing a lot, we just got lucky and actually caught scum with it. also someone (Patrick?) blocked me last night. and no i don't have any flavor reason for thinking its him, just his flip. nothing of note in my PM about the block. Hmmm unless there's a town roleblocker. So that means actions in this game will go through even if someone dies the same night? could also be Chaos Team

That's a great point, and actually with the little revealed about the setup, I think that it's most plausible, that Chaos Team sending messages to the town. However could Chaos team have roles that can determine player roles, such that Chaos Team would know Zachary is sided with the mafia?

Merc, you've jumped head first at all 3 "easy" lynches so far this game. You jumped quickly on DS' info and he was later proven to be full of shit (though accidentally "right"), jumped right onto mittens and that turned out to be wrong, and now jumped quickly onto Zach. One would think you'd be more careful at this point, though as I type this I think I'm talking myself out of seeing this is a scum thing to do.

Timmah @ 22/5/2017 21:08

Merc, you've jumped head first at all 3 "easy" lynches so far this game. You jumped quickly on DS' info and he was later proven to be full of shit (though accidentally "right"), jumped right onto mittens and that turned out to be wrong, and now jumped quickly onto Zach. One would think you'd be more careful at this point, though as I type this I think I'm talking myself out of seeing this is a scum thing to do.

Don't forget he jumped on me for having the audacity to make jokes as I play. ;)

I know I haven't been around near the deadlines so far this game, but there are some people that are seriously skating by without offering much, if anything, at all:

Rose
Boc
Sock
Nofo
Kiwi (lately moreseo that earlier it seems)
Brian

Gonna need you all to chime in here!

Timmah @ 22/5/2017 21:08

Merc, you've jumped head first at all 3 "easy" lynches so far this game. You jumped quickly on DS' info and he was later proven to be full of shit (though accidentally "right"), jumped right onto mittens and that turned out to be wrong, and now jumped quickly onto Zach. One would think you'd be more careful at this point, though as I type this I think I'm talking myself out of seeing this is a scum thing to do.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10czUKzpbgg&t=40s

ok, Walt.

Maddie @ 22/5/2017 21:10

Timmah @ 22/5/2017 21:08 Merc, you've jumped head first at all 3 "easy" lynches so far this game. You jumped quickly on DS' info and he was later proven to be full of shit (though accidentally "right"), jumped right onto mittens and that turned out to be wrong, and now jumped quickly onto Zach. One would think you'd be more careful at this point, though as I type this I think I'm talking myself out of seeing this is a scum thing to do. It was more about you evading the DS shit, felt super scummy. Don't forget he jumped on me for having the audacity to make jokes as I play. ;)

I failed and can't edit.

It's above your line lol

Alright, just caught myself up, including yesterday's threads. Here are some of my thoughts:

- I have no idea why the discussion about Mitten's Night 1 action was so heavily discussed in day 2. I got the impression it was a few townies getting sidetrack and tunneling on the subject, but there could be more to it. Scum could have been perpetuating it because for the most part, it was pretty pointless. But I do think there is some validity to the line of thought that mafia would probably be aware of the fact that Mittens was telling the truth and decided to try and gain town cred by defending him.

- Not seeing why people are rushing to call Merc scummy this game. To me it looks like he's actively scum hunting. This is the towniest read I think I've ever had on him.

- I think I believe Angi's claim, but interested to hear what Tib has to say about it.

- Herm feels scummy to me this game. That's true of almost every game, but I'm still going to make note of it.

- Brian and Rose have barely posted at all. Wouldn't mind seeing some pressure on them soon. Especially Brian, because he tends to show up when he's in danger.

- Unsure what to make of the Zach thing, but I think I'm leaning towards believing the Day thread message at the moment? Nothing he's doing seems particularly scummy, but it's too significant of a lead to ignore.

Quote

- I have no idea why the discussion about Mitten's Night 1 action was so heavily discussed in day 2. I got the impression it was a few townies getting sidetrack and tunneling on the subject, but there could be more to it. Scum could have been perpetuating it because for the most part, it was pretty pointless. But I do think there is some validity to the line of thought that mafia would probably be aware of the fact that Mittens was telling the truth and decided to try and gain town cred by defending him.

Sometimes I wish you could edit posts.

When I wrote this I was thinking of day 3, but wrote day 2 in the post by accident. Obviously there was plenty of reason to discuss it on day 2.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 22/5/2017 22:06

Alright, just caught myself up, including yesterday's threads. Here are some of my thoughts: - I have no idea why the discussion about Mitten's Night 1 action was so heavily discussed in day 2. I got the impression it was a few townies getting sidetrack and tunneling on the subject, but there could be more to it. Scum could have been perpetuating it because for the most part, it was pretty pointless. But I do think there is some validity to the line of thought that mafia would probably be aware of the fact that Mittens was telling the truth and decided to try and gain town cred by defending him. - Not seeing why people are rushing to call Merc scummy this game. To me it looks like he's actively scum hunting. This is the towniest read I think I've ever had on him. - I think I believe Angi's claim, but interested to hear what Tib has to say about it. - Herm feels scummy to me this game. That's true of almost every game, but I'm still going to make note of it. - Brian and Rose have barely posted at all. Wouldn't mind seeing some pressure on them soon. Especially Brian, because he tends to show up when he's in danger. - Unsure what to make of the Zach thing, but I think I'm leaning towards believing the Day thread message at the moment? Nothing he's doing seems particularly scummy, but it's too significant of a lead to ignore.

Point 1 and 2 tie together, TIB and a few others were trying to go for town cred and trying to lynch me at the same time, fairly obvious since he seems to refuse to acknowledge what I was saying about Mittens, repeatedly.

yeah, I was RB'd last night.

also; I'm impressed at how quickly you are getting a grasp of these games Stephen. I've played in a couple and you already know more than me. :p

Who's been the most vocal Merc-hater this game you guys believe?

I have a theory on how to approach this lynch but I just need that info real quick. I'm looking back at the other days and so on and at specific people's posts - but your guys' help would work as well!

Miko @ 23/5/2017 0:52

Who's been the most vocal Merc-hater this game you guys believe? I have a theory on how to approach this lynch but I just need that info real quick. I'm looking back at the other days and so on and at specific people's posts - but your guys' help would work as well!

I'd say Angi & Primate? Unless I'm wrong. I wouldn't say they're haters, but they've been the ones bringing his name up.

I'm feeling less sure about this info.