thisisbad @ 19/5/2017 3:17

Sock @ 18/5/2017 21:01 Sock's Theorycraft Vol. 1: How dey done did the thing that done got did Darren Scamders sees his role and (given his penchant for outing as much info as possible) realizes his role is best suited to being targeted by scum. Therefore he sacrifices spin upon the altar of verisimilitude. Knowing that he will likely out at least 1 role (likely scum if he guesses right). Possibly more if he happened to target town. Either way, he likely felt he had D2 to explain himself and it would get the CLAIM TRAIN rolling. in the spirit of DS, I'm mafia GF. I don't have a night action until Mittens, Angi, Patrick, Primate and Curtis are dead. I feel like we should lynch Sock just to be sure

You announcing the whole mafia team on day 2 just to see if we believe would be amazing


also a game this size with only one death night 1 is scary

Sock @ 18/5/2017 21:34

thisisbad @ 19/5/2017 3:27 I guess i'm wondering why he would be stopped, announced, and then still get through. But again, i agree he has to claim, and I still think he's up to no good. I'm not arguing he was stopped. In fact I'm arguing he wasn't stopped due to the strongman ability. Given DS' role flip that's the only way I can see an attacker getting through. Ninja kill would have been blocked but not seen, normal kill whether it be mafia/3p/vig would have been blocked AND seen.

I can't argue with this, and I know I'll likely be lynched.

However, I know I am watcher, and once I flip everyone else will also. There must be a unique role in play - or at least a special ability.

Sock @ 18/5/2017 22:34

I'm not arguing he was stopped. In fact I'm arguing he wasn't stopped due to the strongman ability. Given DS' role flip that's the only way I can see an attacker getting through. Ninja kill would have been blocked but not seen, normal kill whether it be mafia/3p/vig would have been blocked AND seen.

This. Based on DS' role, the only thing that could've successfully killed him is a Strongman. Which makes sense to use, since Mafia would've assumed DS was, you know, actually what he said he was...

Mittens @ 18/5/2017 22:32

My role is watcher. I stated I should have taken DS' advice, since he said doc and watcher shouldn't visit him. I already explained I believe it was some sort of ninja who killed DS since I was blocked and nobody else was seen there.

yeah no

##lynch mittens

So without reading anything except the opening post, literally everything I posted about DS was correct. He was full of shit, and had no info on spin. I guess he "spins" it that he was trying to get scum to target him so he "was playing to his win condition"?

Basically we just got lucky that he did not actually cause a town JOAT to be lynched because he had no fucking clue.

Thank you to whomever killed him.

thisisbad @ 18/5/2017 20:37

I guess that's where we disagree. I think announced = stopped

I'll quote myself.

Mercator @ 18/5/2017 19:55

thisisbad @ 18/5/2017 19:39 The role flip says they would be stopped in their tracks and it would be announced who TRIED to visit. That's what makes me slightly believe mittens. Are you saying that people that manage to visit don't try to visit?

Either Mittens killed him or the wording is wrong, "tries" implies that everyone that both were blocked and weren't would be announced.

If I try to do something and succeed, I still tried it.

Timmah @ 19/5/2017 4:13

So without reading anything except the opening post, literally everything I posted about DS was correct. He was full of shit, and had no info on spin. I guess he "spins" it that he was trying to get scum to target him so he "was playing to his win condition"? Basically we just got lucky that he did not actually cause a town JOAT to be lynched because he had no fucking clue. Thank you to whomever killed him.

You haven't read sock's theorycraft Vol. 1

I agree the lynch for today is Mittens. I do not think we should hammer until people have had a good chance to check in though.

Sock's advanced theorycraft Vol. 2: what had happened that we had not seen't happened

So with a game this size and there only being 1 kill N1.

The following may have occurred:

another kill was blocked.
cult recruited
cult recruitment was blocked

and in the spirit of DS, I am cult recruiter, I can recruit every night and I recruited Dr on N1 and I am going to target im317 on N2

Sock @ 18/5/2017 23:16

Timmah @ 19/5/2017 4:13 So without reading anything except the opening post, literally everything I posted about DS was correct. He was full of shit, and had no info on spin. I guess he "spins" it that he was trying to get scum to target him so he "was playing to his win condition"? Basically we just got lucky that he did not actually cause a town JOAT to be lynched because he had no fucking clue. Thank you to whomever killed him. You haven't read sock's theorycraft Vol. 1

No I have now and don't see many options that don't end with mittens having killed DS. I almost want to give him a 1 day pass for doing us a favor though. And part of me is thinking "it's DS, it's almost guaranteed he fucked this up and we actually lose town watcher too", but it looks like mittens needs to swim with the fishes.

Is it weird that I think one of sock's "scum claims" is going to prove to be true?

At the risk of sounding like I am 2nd mafia, how did we come to think there are 2 mafias? Spin's flip literally says "third party"

hey everyone, curtis here

I think we should lynch mittens and vlady in that order

ttfn

thank u curtis