Top 5 in no order

Kim
Earl
Jeremy
Denise
Parvati

I think Kim is at the top of the list. I don't think anyone played a better winning game than she did

Yeah I agree. I don't think anyone was ever in as much control in a season as she was in her's. Others have played really well too but her name was never brought up a single time. I wanna go back and watch that season just to see it all unfold again, haven't watched it since it aired

Honestly I think the next closest dominant performance was probably Boston Rob in RI. He absolutely crushed that game and controlled his crew easily

It's not a coincidence that both One World and Redemption Island have possibly the two dumbest collective casts I can think of. I wonder if they all just look stupid because Kim/Rob crushed them so handily or if Kim/Rob crushed them so handily because they were stupid. Probably both

Curtis @ 7/4/2017 16:12

Honestly I think the next closest dominant performance was probably Boston Rob in RI. He absolutely crushed that game and controlled his crew easily It's not a coincidence that both One World and Redemption Island have possibly the two dumbest collective casts I can think of. I wonder if they all just look stupid because Kim/Rob crushed them so handily or if Kim/Rob crushed them so handily because they were stupid. Probably both

Don't forget Cochran, I would put him in that category too probably. But once again, awfully dumb cast

The problem with Cochran is that he was cast with his friends so it made things much easier

To throwboack to worst moves:


1. Erik giving up Immunity
2. JT's letter to Russell with idol that eventually sent him packing where he otherwise may have been in the finale
3. Lex and Kathy keeping Amber for Rob in All Stars
4. Tyson voting himself out
5. Brandon voting out Kelly instead of Lex in Africa

1. Kim
2. Rob - If you just watched the season and did not know the history it is easy to see that he's the bomb.
3. Earl
4. Cochran - I hate to do this but Vic makes a good point.
5. Hatch

Honorable Mentions:
Yul - got helped out quite a bit by the twist. But used it very well.
Tina - Mario Lanza (the funny 115) makes a great point about how Tina used the "Strategy is of the devil" strategy perfectly.
Jeremy, PI Sandra, and Natalie A were p. good too. Look at that I did a top 10!

Top 5 winners:

Kim
Yul
JT
Todd
and I guess I would put Jeremy here?

Worst Moves: I tried to do this based on if they hadn't made this move they would have won the game.

1. Colby chooses Tina. Morals aside this was a $900,000 decision.
2. Erik gives up immunity. Erik could have won the last couple challenges and probably been a millionaire.
3. Woo chooses Tony. Not sure if Kass would have been able to lawyer him out of the million bucks, but he had a good shot.
4. Rupert and Colby don't listen to Sandra. Sandra had an idol at F6 and wanted to go with Colby and Rupert. Had they gone with her, one of those 2 would have won the game.
5. James gets voted out with 2 idols in China. It was the Final 7. Yes had he survived he would have been guaranteed Final 4, but with his challenge strength he could have easily won a challenge or two.

Honorable Mentions:
I don't recall a lot of the bad moves in older seasons. A few come to mind.
- The Brandon one that Bryce mentioned.
- The coconut chop in Marquesas. The rotu 4 would have likely been the final 4.
- Penner for declining the alliance in Phillipines.

Jeremy is for sure top five to me. I have no idea how people let him get to the end. Tasha and Spencer are fairly worthy FTC opponents too (maybe the most well rounded FTC f3 ever?) and for him to get all 10 votes against them is super impressive

Curtis @ 7/4/2017 16:33

Jeremy is for sure top five to me. I have no idea how people let him get to the end. Tasha and Spencer are fairly worthy FTC opponents too (maybe the most well rounded FTC f3 ever?) and for him to get all 10 votes against them is super impressive

Ya fuck Cochran. Jeremy is fourth now.

Dylan @ 7/4/2017 16:31

5. James gets voted out with 2 idols in China. It was the Final 7. Yes had he survived he would have been guaranteed Final 4, but with his challenge strength he could have easily won a challenge or two.

I was gonna say nearly this same thing, but James has surprisingly never won an individual challenge once (:

Courtney has won more immunities than James

Well still. Getting voted out with two idols at F7 is DUMB!

1. Kim
2. Jeremy
3. Boston Rob
4. Tom
5. Hatch

Man this one is TOUGH. My top three are solidly in that order I think. The bottom two I could switch out for several people, like Todd or Denise or maybe even Natalie A or Tyson. I haven't seen Earl's season but I feel like I might include him if I ever watch it

My FAVORITES are Tony and Chris, who I could probably make arguments for including in the top five all day but my criteria seems to keep coming back to like..squeaky clean control of the game. Hence Kim/Jeremy/Rob