Just went back and looked and Brian's first two posts on D2 were him arguing that Miko couldn't be scum after Titan lynched him at the start of the day. I totally forgot that. I'm on my phone so I can't properly quote but if anyone wants to go look it's his first two posts on D2. Hmmmmmm

Curtis @ 20/1/2016 13:14

Y me Ariel??

Not much on your trackrecord supports you being town. Not much to gain from your d1&2 activity.

You have been trying to figure stuff out but you usually play well as scum.

If its any consolation id put jay, brian, timmah and im317 above you as scum.

Not feeling your Badger tunneling yet. Ill have a better look when im home.

@curt

Didnt talk at all about Miko or Dadd before there were nails in their coffins (if i remember correctly)

Hmm tbh im317 lynched miko day 2 to avoid a tie. Putting him in dont want to lynch.

@ Vic and Ari. To answer your questions.

1. My vote on Herm was made right as I was going to bed. I am in Germany and wanted to post before going to sleep.

2. Scum:

A: Herm: I don't buy the Miller claim. The only thing that makes me even consider it is true is that he was elected leader. In my experience the leader is a hot target for a Cop. If I was a Miller I definitely would not want to be leader. He was elected and he was checked and scanned as scum. What are the odds? Odds are he is not a Miller imo.

B JC: I have been tunnelled on Herm's claim but Timmah has caught my eye with his observations of JC.

C: Vic: I think lynching of Herm will tell us a lot about Vic.

D: Would be Vernon because he buys the Miller claim imo. The fact he said he had his vote stolen makes him the least likely of this list.

Wake up sleepy heads. I am around and can play!

I have a hard time not buying the Miller claim because it happened to me last game. I want really badly to believe Herm. But I suck at scum finding so he probably is scum and pulling the wool over my eyes. I also agree with the cult theory, Zombie Sophie is probably going to bite everyone lol

Sophia

Ari @ 20/1/2016 6:29

@curt Didnt talk at all about Miko or Dadd before there were nails in their coffins (if i remember correctly)

Well I missed D2 entirely and that was when Miko got heat and Dadd as a result. When was I supposed to point them out, D1? (:

317 avoiding the tie and lynching Miko is a good catch. I think we need a timeline of that Miko/Titan lynch. I still haven't even read it

Just saying nothing points toward you being town yet Curt, doesnt mean you are not :)

Jay why would scum Herm claim miller without knowing what info patrick had? Could have easily been something else than a scan

Scum JC would have been more diplomatic in his kill imo

Ari @ 20/1/2016 13:26

Just saying nothing points toward you being town yet Curt, doesnt mean you are not :) Jay why would scum Herm claim miller without knowing what info patrick had? Could have easily been something else than a scan

Wait. I thought the claim was after he was called out. Let me go back and look.

On my phone but I think Pat said something like 'negative' results? Don't think he sad scan until later

Yeah Pat pussyfooted around a Cop claim, just said he had info on them. GRANTED a scan seemed most likely but Herm was very confident and would've been fucked if he was wrong