Mike @ 21/10/2018 19:17

I have a theory...the person who killed Primate is not on our side

Likely. I think general consensus was he was town so he'd be a safe target for scum.

I'm gonna go ahead and ##Lynch: Sock

Really not buying that claim. Sounds horribly clumped together.

farlig @ 21/10/2018 19:19

JJ @ 21/10/2018 18:15 farlig @ 21/10/2018 19:11 JJ @ 21/10/2018 18:08 farlig @ 21/10/2018 19:07 JJ @ 21/10/2018 18:05 I don't think Herm making the post about possibly being the one who was attacked/survived is a big deal. Herm speculates wildly all the time and it doesn't have to mean anything so I think that's being nitpicky to read something into it. KC will probably not show up and it'll be his weapon. ##lynch Helios Reading into something he should have been told if that actually happen? Sure. Keep telling yourself that. He should've been told what? That he survived? That he was attacked? Where are you reading this is how it works? Also, why would he assume this? You're being ridiculous. The only way he doesn’t know he was attacked/survived is if people aren’t told they are attacked/survived unless it’s important to their role (1-time BP, etc.). The rules only address what we will be told in the public thread. Being ridiculous? Go have another glass of wine and take the edge off. Where does it indicate if he drew someone's role and caused himself to survive an attack he would be told? I can see other reasons to suspect Herm but not that one. I can totally see Herm speculating about something like that if he's telling the truth about his role. Where does it say he wouldn’t? So it’s okay for Herm to speculate but not me? Thanks for teaching me how to mafia.

Well, it has nothing to do with teaching you how to play mafia but sorry you feel offended. It has to do with not thinking it would work that way in a game where we're not even told who survived an attack and not thinking it's scummy for Herm to speculate - however wild a conclusion that is.

So sock claimed town haunt or something, somewhere in the 250 or so posts I haven’t caught up on?

I saw that primate died, but we still haven’t found the weapon that kills have we?

Timmah @ 21/10/2018 19:26

So sock claimed town haunt or something, somewhere in the 250 or so posts I haven’t caught up on? I saw that primate died, but we still haven’t found the weapon that kills have we?

Nada. One of three possibles now. It's either Vic, farlig or KC who will likely be the one who puts it in his own face.

Seems horribly unlikely that the seed just happened to pick the last three people. It's possible, probability is wierd, just seems odd. Maybe it's just the last person to strike?

JJ @ 21/10/2018 18:26

farlig @ 21/10/2018 19:19 JJ @ 21/10/2018 18:15 farlig @ 21/10/2018 19:11 JJ @ 21/10/2018 18:08 farlig @ 21/10/2018 19:07 JJ @ 21/10/2018 18:05 I don't think Herm making the post about possibly being the one who was attacked/survived is a big deal. Herm speculates wildly all the time and it doesn't have to mean anything so I think that's being nitpicky to read something into it. KC will probably not show up and it'll be his weapon. ##lynch Helios Reading into something he should have been told if that actually happen? Sure. Keep telling yourself that. He should've been told what? That he survived? That he was attacked? Where are you reading this is how it works? Also, why would he assume this? You're being ridiculous. The only way he doesn’t know he was attacked/survived is if people aren’t told they are attacked/survived unless it’s important to their role (1-time BP, etc.). The rules only address what we will be told in the public thread. Being ridiculous? Go have another glass of wine and take the edge off. Where does it indicate if he drew someone's role and caused himself to survive an attack he would be told? I can see other reasons to suspect Herm but not that one. I can totally see Herm speculating about something like that if he's telling the truth about his role. Where does it say he wouldn’t? So it’s okay for Herm to speculate but not me? Thanks for teaching me how to mafia. Well, it has nothing to do with teaching you how to play mafia but sorry you feel offended. It has to do with not thinking it would work that way in a game where we're not even told who survived an attack and not thinking it's scummy for Herm to speculate - however wild a conclusion that is.

So if he targeted say a fruit giver would he not be told he received fruit?

I don't love the wall posts so I'm not going to quote but that's a completely different scenario. If someone is saved from an attack because they were protected or were BP, I really don't think they would be told. Especially here and with these hosts. If someone was given fruit, yes, I'm sure they would be told... that's not even close to the same situation.

I will probably take you up on that wine suggestion in a bit, though. ;)

I thought for sure when the thread locked, that Rose's weapon was about to kill Helios, but that would have killed the suspense.
I don't like knowing that any one of us could die at any time during this game, but that's very "fright night"-ish, isn't it?

That’s seems like you are picking and choosing how the role works based on the role targeted. It’s possible but just as possible as my train of thought.

Herm was the one who brought up the possibility that he thought he was the one who might survived the attack. He put the idea in people's heads at a time when people were confused about Herm and his intentions.

farlig @ 21/10/2018 19:37

That’s seems like you are picking and choosing how the role works based on the role targeted. It’s possible but just as possible as my train of thought.

I'm not picking or choosing anything. I'm going by experience in these games and I don't know of someone ever being told they survived an attack unless they put it together with other info - but not because a host told them they survived. Anyway, my whole point was that I don't think it's a reason to use to say Herm is scummy because he wondered about that.

this is so much better if you pretend that JJ and Farlig are mafia together.

Christian @ 21/10/2018 19:41

Herm was the one who brought up the possibility that he thought he was the one who might survived the attack. He put the idea in people's heads at a time when people were confused about Herm and his intentions.

I know that but I think he was just speculating. I could obviously be wrong and he was doing that to try to make us think that. I could also see him just thinking that because he always has lots of theories.

Christian @ 22/10/2018 1:41

Herm was the one who brought up the possibility that he thought he was the one who might survived the attack. He put the idea in people's heads at a time when people were confused about Herm and his intentions.

Clearly a mistake, but I wasn't thinking rationally at the time.

I was fighting for my life.

Day Three Lynch Count

Sock (5) - Spin, Farlig, Timmah, Henry, Jackie, Ahoda
Herm (4) - Shadow, Ari, Helios, Nav
Helios (2) - Herm, Buffy
Zach (1) - Shawn, Mike
Brian (1) - Kenny
Spin (1) - Darkus
Buffy (1) - Ahoda
Vern (1) - Mike

Deadline is tonight at 10:40PM.

Okay I've decided

##daykill Helios