I am thinking ill lynch Vernon or Jeff. I quite like Curtis's argument for Jeff. The chances mafia/sk/vig attacked a one time BP who was quiet is very low. But it is also odd that was the only attack of the night (that wasn't blocked).

Although something is definitely up with Drr I am just not sure what.

Also isn't it odd Rob wasn't attacked?

AND what are the arguments against Mal?

(actually I suppose the Mafia may of thought he would be and obvious protection target)

Actually its pretty common not to openly attack an ousted cop immediately because they are very likelyto be protected. Instead they get sabotaged in other ways or left alone until the mafia is sure they can get a hit in.

The odds of mafia hitting BP are the same odds as the mafia hitting any random target. They decide there was enough day 1 chaos between biggest players, so they kill someone no one will miss that will give us little information when flipped, so they attack Jeff, who for some reason does not die. It's worth keeping an eye on, and if he doesnt start posting ideas soon I'm going to give up beating the dead horse, but I don't think survival alone is worth lynching over.

The fact that he's made 4 posts all game and one is "hello to all of my friends" and the other 3 are brushing off the attack thing.... That's a little fishier. But I still feel like Vernon is the shadier one here and the fact that a few people have stood up for him and claimed that he's proven himself trustworthy by lynching greenday at random then unlynching when shit got serious makes me feel even more confident that something is wrong there.

Kiwi @ 18/2/2013 21:50

(actually I suppose the Mafia may of thought he would be and obvious protection target)

Oh, I missed this while i was typing. Yeah that's my take on things

Kiwi @ 19/2/2013 2:44

Also isn't it odd Rob wasn't attacked?

Eh. When I was godfather a while back, we purposely let outed roles live a while longer, to minimize the chances that they'd get saved. I wouldn't doubt I'll be a victim eventually, but I think it's probably better than getting lynched and having the town lose a scanner that early in the game.

Hopefully I'll be able to out a few more of them by the time that happens, though.

So what did you find out last night?

##unlynch Ari

I mean unlynch Malion

Kiwi @ 18/2/2013 22:40

So what did you find out last night?

Presumably he didn't find scum or uncover the innocence of someone being wrongly accused at this moment, which is all we really need to know right now. Unless he was blocked, in which case, that means there is a mafia roleblocker.

Him being blocked is the most likely scenario

Whatever he did he surely would of done on Drr. If she isn't scum would they really block him?

That's an interesting point. Though I can't see any sane mafia knowing that there was Rob's role out there and neglecting to block him

Kiwi @ 18/2/2013 22:59

Whatever he did he surely would of done on Drr. If she isn't scum would they really block him?

Wait, explain that to me

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 19/2/2013 4:08

Kiwi @ 18/2/2013 22:59 Whatever he did he surely would of done on Drr. If she isn't scum would they really block him? Wait, explain that to me

Why Rob would use his role on you? From yesterday it seemed very obvious you were the one he thought was most likely to be scum from the remaining people.

But regardless of that, scum would probably block him as they at least know his role compared to randomly blocking someone else.