dan foleys social game

christy telling rob c she wasn't sure what she wanted to do which leads to herself getting voted out
colby taking tina to f2
lex & kathy keeping amber in allstars
penner flipping and then flipping back in cook islands
fincher flipping on galu only to get voted out next tribal

Will telling everyone last season that he wanted to make a big move because he felt he hadn't done enough to win was one of the weirdest/dumbest things I've ever seen someone say to people

- JT gives Russell an Idol and gets voted out with it
- JT gets Malcolm Idol'd out
- JT doesn't bring his Idol and gets voted out

Alex telling Rob that he would go against him at F4 once their alliance makes it there. What a MORON. Then Rob just goes to the three outsiders and flips it on him. Duh

Christie's moment the next episode was a good nom too

Malcolm turning down Denise's offer to force a tie at final 4 should be somewhere on the list. I love him, but that was big.

Penner rejecting the F5 alliance in Philippines

Outlast @ 2/4/2017 20:48

Penner rejecting the F5 alliance in Philippines

Completely agree. He basically turned down $1,000,000 with that decision.

Also Penner not voting the right person leading to Kent getting voted out

Production casting Melissa McNulty

Dumbest Moves:

1. Erik giving up Immunity
2. Brandon giving up Immunity
3. Alex telling Rob he's siding with the girls at 4
4. Jay tells Kim that Troy is playing an Idol
5. Manono deciding to go to Tribal

Honestly these are all interchangeable and I could easily swap a dozen other things in and out of here, like Cochran's flip and lack of plan afterwards or JT not bringing/playing his idol last week. Or Colby taking Tina or Woo taking Tony

WEEK #3: Top Five Best Winners

Not favorite, best. Let's try to be objective as possible and debate who played the best single winning season, taking nothing from future or previous seasons into account

ALSO, what qualities make a good winner in your opinion?

To me a good winner is someone who showed self awareness, had the ability to adapt in the game. They didn't have to be in total control of the season but show some strategic game. Big or flashy moves aren't always needed. In terms of a good winner I'd rather smart gameplay over flashy gameplay.

Top 5, no order.

Sandra
Todd
Kim
Earl
Richard

Which season Sandra?

that's hard I think she's a great winner in both but maybe PI