Helios Garabandia @ 11/2/2017 20:17

Darren Sanders @ 11/2/2017 23:15 Oops, didnt see the last post. Writeup makes it sound like TIB is a whistle blower Okay, Whistleblower is a role I've never heard of. How does it work?

Well the actual role is called Townie with a Loud Whistle and its slightly different than what I was thinking

Townie with a Loud Whistle - This person can watch one person each night. If someone tries to break into the target's house, the Towniewith a Loud Whistle blows the whistle. The sound is so loud that the person then must either leave or must turn around and look at the source of the whistle. If the person leaves, then they don't accomplish what they set out to do. If they look at the whistle-blower, then the Townie with a Loud Whistle can see who was trying to break in.



Thats how its usually played - though I have been in a few games where its basically treated like a PGO that doesnt kill but reveals the visit. Which is what it seems like here

im317 @ 10/2/2017 13:41

since today seems to be list day 1. farlig - no read, post more. (i know im being a hypocrite) 2. Spin - leaning heavy town 3. im317 - town town town 5. Brian - leaning town, would scum give Mittens an extra ability? Mittens had been on the chopping block all game. 6. Darren Sanders - town imo 7. Curt - undecided 11. Merc - if i had to pick i would say scum, but not sure. 12. Dylan - leaning town, could also be very smart scum 14. Ahoda - leaning town 15. Buffy - dying town 16. Timmah - 3rd party that has to die sooner or later 17. drrrrrr - not sure. not a high priority imo 19. Badger - leaning town based on being blocked. could be lying? 20. Helios - not sure. i never get a good read on him. 21. Chris - probably town, but could be scum using Timmah's claim to avoid having to do anything but attack Timmah. 28. Primate - undecided 30. Thisisbad - almost forgot he was playing.

That's im317's list from yesterday. The TIB part helps his claim. It would be a smart set up if he really was carrying out the mafia kill, it's a likely Vig kill but a very strange mafia kill

I think I believe him

I do think it's a little weird that you didn't kill Mittens since you went after him in the day so much. You would've saved Buffy!!!

But I think the mafia deciding to kill TIB last night is a little more weird. I'm not sure I buy that

Also, he definitely did believe my claim on day three. I remember him saying that. Scum would've pushed me as SK

Only way I'm not believing im3 is if someone cc's

tib now should claim his role otherwise im leaning toward that being a godfather kill miss

Curtis @ 11/2/2017 23:29

I do think it's a little weird that you didn't kill Mittens since you went after him in the day so much. You would've saved Buffy!!! But I think the mafia deciding to kill TIB last night is a little more weird. I'm not sure I buy that

Mittens was just to easy to lynch. i wanted to take out people more difficult to lynch due to lack of participation. plus we learn the most when we lynch scum, who pushed for or against them is useful. had no way of knowing Mittens could poison.

ROSE

SURPRISE

WE ARE LEAST EXPECTING IT NOW I PROMISE

Darren Sanders @ 11/2/2017 23:36

tib now should claim his role otherwise im leaning toward that being a godfather kill miss

wat

Even though he's been way too quiet I do think this makes me think Tib is town


And I do believe im's claim

Darren Sanders @ 11/2/2017 22:36

tib now should claim his role otherwise im leaning toward that being a godfather kill miss

That doesn't even make sense

Curtis @ 11/2/2017 20:39

Darren Sanders @ 11/2/2017 23:36 tib now should claim his role otherwise im leaning toward that being a godfather kill miss wat

my posts are sorta stream of consciousness sometimes and I didnt really think that one through

Usually kill misses that are shown in the opening writeups are due to godfather, bulletproof, whistleblower, etc - so what is tib?

kinda neglected to think about im3 being revealed due to it, which a godfather miss kill wouldnt do

Darren Sanders @ 11/2/2017 23:43

kinda neglected to think about im3 being revealed due to it, which a godfather miss kill wouldnt do

Wait, why wouldn't it? Godfather is a perfectly rational reason why someone survives a night attack.

(oh wait, you're talking about the attempt even being revealed...i'm an idiot, carry on)

Darren Sanders @ 11/2/2017 23:39

ROSE SURPRISE WE ARE LEAST EXPECTING IT NOW I PROMISE

NOPE SORRY. NOT YET.