Ari @ 10/9/2012 10:25

Captain Canada = Jeff Something DR said on phase 1 made me think she was scum but im not sure about now. Curtis has been quiet. Bryce, Waka and Dylan have been giving me some vibes.

I've been around, but not much due to busy weekends to fully read everything

I do think we should stick together, as its safer. I'll put a left in my journal as I may not be back by the end of the phase.

No idea if ill be able to go on the internetz before the deadline so im just going to go left

Some people have already exited left so why not follow ?

Same here, I will be exiting left. I have class until 8 EST but will provide an excellent rebuttal to Rose's suspicions at some point after that. (Or possibly during class if it's boring.)

Ari @ 10/9/2012 11:39

@Dr: Just a metagaming vibe my dear! @Waka: Its just a feeling! Ive actually had Rob pretty middle - low on my list Bottom is Natalie, Henry, Patrick, FF0 and Dutchiee Boc is moving up the list ;) Rest are middle

Why?

And Ari I think you should use your ability pretty soon. We don't know if the scum have any kills in this game so it'd be better to use it early than not use it at all

Tom Brady @ 10/9/2012 11:52

Boc Most suspicous

lol wut. You're not sure what to make of me, so I'm the most suspicious?

And yeah I know I haven't been very active, but like Curtis I've been busier than usual with college starting back up

##exit left

btw I've had Jeffrey squarely on top of my list each round so far. I don't even remember what for tbh, but I remember him saying something pretty suspicious on D1 about Natalie that seemed possibly scumbuddyish

And Henry's been at the bottom each round

Boc @ 10/9/2012 16:35

Tom Brady @ 10/9/2012 11:52 Boc Most suspicous lol wut. You're not sure what to make of me, so I'm the most suspicious? And yeah I know I haven't been very active, but like Curtis I've been busier than usual with college starting back up

I definitely wouldn't say most suspicious, but I will admit you were bottom of my list day one. Because of that, in the past 24-48 hours I've been watching more for your reaction to different things and haven't seen much from you so it's tough to trust you as much as I did day 1.

Boc @ 10/9/2012 16:38

btw I've had Jeffrey squarely on top of my list each round so far. I don't even remember what for tbh, but I remember him saying something pretty suspicious on D1 about Natalie that seemed possibly scumbuddyish And Henry's been at the bottom each round

uhhh I never said anything about Natalie on day 1 @ all.

Leaffan20 @ 10/9/2012 15:42

Boc @ 10/9/2012 16:38 btw I've had Jeffrey squarely on top of my list each round so far. I don't even remember what for tbh, but I remember him saying something pretty suspicious on D1 about Natalie that seemed possibly scumbuddyish And Henry's been at the bottom each round uhhh I never said anything about Natalie on day 1 @ all.

Yes you did. You bandwagoned your vote on Natalie and justified it by saying she was "the only option that made sense" or something along those lines. At first I thought it was scumbuddyish and had you AND Natalie near the top of my list, but lately Natalie's slid down to around the middle of my list because she's been acting pretty town-like. I now think it was either you coming up with a shitty, nonsensical reason for bandwagoning on the vote to make it LOOK like you weren't bandwagoning (which scum would want to do to avoid accusations) or you just said something really, really stupid. Which... tbh it was PROBABLY the latter but I haven't seen anyone do any overtly scummy things since then to make them knock you off the top (although Drrrr laid out some pretty convincing reasoning to vote for Rob earlier which he interestingly ignored, so he's risen from near the bottom to near the top).

NICE TRY JEFF

Tom Brady @ 10/9/2012 12:52

Ari - Volunteered for bus driver on phase 2. He has a decent one shot role which can be used to our advantage. I am thinking town at the moment. Boc - Boc is usually more active then this when town, with plenty of solid contributions to make. He is usually active if he is scum too, so I aren't sure what to make of him. Bryce - Quick to announce he had a shard of code yesterday. I am thinking town. Curtis - Curtis hasn't been available to be fully active, as he has just announced, and he was also quick to reveal his letter yesterday. Not on my radar at the moment. DR - Claims she was blocked. If she is telling the truth, she is pretty much confirmed town. Rob - Unsure what to make of him so far. Dutchiee - Again, very little to go on either way. FF0 - First to reveal he had a shard of code yesterday I think. He isn't looking too suspicious at all right now. Helios - Disappeared just as I put in the order to give him my shard of code last night. Could have been innocent, but I also recall him pointing fingers at Ari for volunteering to be bus driver phase 1. Unsure of what to make of him at the moment. Henry - Claims to have had a shard of code yesterday but didn't even bother telling us what it said. Henry could well be cbf town, but I am getting scum vibes from him. Natalie - I would rank her very low on my list. TLG - Not worth mentioning. Patrick - Lurking like fuck, not contributing much at all. Very hard to read as a result. Vespis - Not very talkative, but watching all the same. Nothing suspicious so far. Waka - One of the few people who were enthusiastic about trying to solve the shard puzzle yesterday. I am thinking town at the moment.

Similar to what I have been noticing as well. One question for you. I keep moving those "little to go on" people higher and higher on my list. What's your thought on those people? Guess it just seems the perfect way to float along, not help or cause doubt and end up surviving.

Boc @ 10/9/2012 20:57

(although Drrrr laid out some pretty convincing reasoning to vote for Rob earlier which he interestingly ignored, so he's risen from near the bottom to near the top).

Um, are you kidding me?

Not only did I NOT ignore that, I have posted TWICE that I will answer those accusations after I'm done the eight consecutive hours of classes that I have today. Since I'm pretty interested in not dying, I'd kinda like to answer them in a useful way, as opposed to slamming out an explanation in the middle of a lecture and raising more suspicions.

Missed that. That's what I get for skimming I guess! I still can revise my list if I buy your defense though.

Boc @ 10/9/2012 16:57

Leaffan20 @ 10/9/2012 15:42 Boc @ 10/9/2012 16:38 btw I've had Jeffrey squarely on top of my list each round so far. I don't even remember what for tbh, but I remember him saying something pretty suspicious on D1 about Natalie that seemed possibly scumbuddyish And Henry's been at the bottom each round uhhh I never said anything about Natalie on day 1 @ all. Yes you did. You bandwagoned your vote on Natalie and justified it by saying she was "the only option that made sense" or something along those lines. At first I thought it was scumbuddyish and had you AND Natalie near the top of my list, but lately Natalie's slid down to around the middle of my list because she's been acting pretty town-like. I now think it was either you coming up with a shitty, nonsensical reason for bandwagoning on the vote to make it LOOK like you weren't bandwagoning (which scum would want to do to avoid accusations) or you just said something really, really stupid. Which... tbh it was PROBABLY the latter but I haven't seen anyone do any overtly scummy things since then to make them knock you off the top (although Drrrr laid out some pretty convincing reasoning to vote for Rob earlier which he interestingly ignored, so he's risen from near the bottom to near the top). NICE TRY JEFF

So if you think its the latter of the two that still makes me scummy in your books? That's just as bad which makes you look scummy in my eyes. If you genuinely thought it was scummy then I'd understand your claim but if you think its me being stupid then there's no reason to think I'm scummy. Yeah I never thought out my answer before putting the Natalie vote, I was merely just getting her the votes needed so we'd have a majority.

So Wikey has Boc at the top of his list and I have Boc at the bottom of mine. We really need a better plan for these lists. -_- Can we maybe get a list posted here that most agree on so we can vote similarly?

For anyone showing up later in the day and not reading everything, make sure to post your exit.

I believe we pretty much decided to stay together and exit Left.