what's the stand? and how much time is left? need some schrauben up in here

Herm @ 14/10/2015 1:11

I know we can't always go with flavor, but I get the feeling there's things to read into with this game. Night 1: Kidnapper (Brian), Dogs - failed (Redster) Night 2: Kidnapper (Buffy), Axe death (Curtis), Dogs - failed (Redster) Night 3: Axe death (Timmah), Dogs (Ari), Eaten (Canuck) Without reading into flavor, it seems like Mafia attacked Redster Night 1, Curtis Night 2 and Timmah Night 3. The only thing out of place is Canuck's death. Someone hungry for some canadian Thanksgiving?

So, according to Herm, mafia has attacked using Dogs on N1 (Redster), and then switched it up to using an axe on N2 and N3 (Curtis then Timmah), while someone else completely different used Dogs N2 and N3 (Redster and Ari). And people are buying this?

It's painfully obvious the dog-killer is separate from the axe-killer. Looks like the Dogs are either 3rd party or Town, as I can't see Mafia killing their own in Ari on N3 (Redirector already killed). That makes the Axe killer likely mafia, but I have no idea why it didn't happen N1 (maybe they also targeted Redster?).

I only buy a SKIT type role if that's the "Eaten" death. Our SK was the kidnapper/jailer/eat-1-leave-1 person. Wouldn't a SKIT also follow in their masters line of work? Could the Eaten just be a one-time off kill? Skitzo?

In the end, I think Herm is trying to distract the town with bad theories that make no sense.

## Lynch Herm

I think we got something like 9-10 hours left. No rush.

I still think Sugar made a good point yesterday about Beaver.

I can't think of many roles that can't be blocked, and only one of them is town.

Beaver's super scummy "yay team" post makes me think he is scum and trying too hard.


The only thing that is holding me up from a beaver vote is the fact that Sugar didn't just RB him again to see if Beaver is a hider or really worth pursuing.(Hider is the only town role that comes to mind, and normally an every other night deal)

primate @ 14/10/2015 11:33

I still think Sugar made a good point yesterday about Beaver. I can't think of many roles that can't be blocked, and only one of them is town. Beaver's super scummy "yay team" post makes me think he is scum and trying too hard. The only thing that is holding me up from a beaver vote is the fact that Sugar didn't just RB him again to see if Beaver is a hider or really worth pursuing.(Hider is the only town role that comes to mind, and normally an every other night deal)

Primate, did you steal my vote?

It seems like Herm may be a little too eager to chase flavor and add confusion to the game. I'm not sure if that's just how he plays or if he's scum trying to guide the masses.

FREE CANDY @ 14/10/2015 10:36

primate @ 14/10/2015 11:33 I still think Sugar made a good point yesterday about Beaver. I can't think of many roles that can't be blocked, and only one of them is town. Beaver's super scummy "yay team" post makes me think he is scum and trying too hard. The only thing that is holding me up from a beaver vote is the fact that Sugar didn't just RB him again to see if Beaver is a hider or really worth pursuing.(Hider is the only town role that comes to mind, and normally an every other night deal) Primate, did you steal my vote?

No.

Henry 42 is a real puzzle, and probably who you should be looking at as the thief of votes.

Yesfo @ 14/10/2015 9:27

Henry is soft-claiming back-up Cop so I'd lean to JC out of those four since I know my own role.

I'm not seeing that at all. It looks more to me like he is soft claiming vote thief. Referring to himself as a gang.

primate @ 14/10/2015 12:33

I still think Sugar made a good point yesterday about Beaver. I can't think of many roles that can't be blocked, and only one of them is town. Beaver's super scummy "yay team" post makes me think he is scum and trying too hard. The only thing that is holding me up from a beaver vote is the fact that Sugar didn't just RB him again to see if Beaver is a hider or really worth pursuing.(Hider is the only town role that comes to mind, and normally an every other night deal)

i have never seen hider not be an every night ability, are you thinking of commuter?

primate @ 14/10/2015 11:33

I still think Sugar made a good point yesterday about Beaver. I can't think of many roles that can't be blocked, and only one of them is town. Beaver's super scummy "yay team" post makes me think he is scum and trying too hard. The only thing that is holding me up from a beaver vote is the fact that Sugar didn't just RB him again to see if Beaver is a hider or really worth pursuing.(Hider is the only town role that comes to mind, and normally an every other night deal)

With Canuck turning up Mafia Ninja, I doubt the mafia would have a 2nd person that can evade night actions. While this doesn't clear Beaver, it does lend some credence to his Hider claim.

im317 @ 14/10/2015 10:51

primate @ 14/10/2015 12:33 I still think Sugar made a good point yesterday about Beaver. I can't think of many roles that can't be blocked, and only one of them is town. Beaver's super scummy "yay team" post makes me think he is scum and trying too hard. The only thing that is holding me up from a beaver vote is the fact that Sugar didn't just RB him again to see if Beaver is a hider or really worth pursuing.(Hider is the only town role that comes to mind, and normally an every other night deal) i have never seen hider not be an every night ability, are you thinking of commuter?

Yeah commuter, where they leave town every other night.

It is kind of coming down to the Herm vs Henry thing for me, but I can't help but think that some of the less active folks need to do some more talking and not be allowed to sit back and watch everyone pick each opther apart.

JC @ 14/10/2015 18:04

Fine, you guys want to lynch me, go ahead. I was trying this new strategy, called "the Curtis", where I don't post for like 4 days, and skate through to the end. Apparently it isn't working.

Legit lol'd @ that.

Sorry deadline is the typical 10 PM tonight.