As helpful as the list is, I think we should also check Shadow's posts on day two. If he seemed definitive on anybody being scum, (or innocent for that matter), then we can probably assume that that's who he scanned.

Alright. Having re-checked, I think I'm leaning more towards Wikey than Nofo. While Nofo's posts don't generally tend to be helpful, it's more a case of him trying to be helpful and failing than anything, as far as I can tell.

Wikey, on the other hand, showed up one time, proclaimed that he'd figure out the scum later, and then disappeared for the rest of the phase. That reeks of a "hey guys, I'm still alive so don't think I'm UTR!" post, and those are a pretty generic scum tactic. He could just be busy, mind you, but it's hard to tell.

I won't be on tomorrow so going to lynch Nofo. I have had a feeling on him.

##lynch: nofo

Oh I totally missed the items thing in the rules til now lol. It would kinda make sense if there's one such 'santa' who is town aligned and one who is mafia aligned no? In that case, Rose isn't cleared at all imo.

I do think we should go for Nofo or Wikey though since at least one of them has to be town (unless Colby is giving us fake info or IM is somehow mafia aligned, but that's for later in case Nofo/Wikey both happen to be town). I have no read on either of them so waiting for them to say something...

Actually Samm's role says that at least one of the 5 is scum. That doesn't rule out two of them being scum.

Right, I meant at least one of them mafia lol.

Colby @ 5/1/2014 2:38

I haven't read everything in this thread, but I received Samm's letter last night. I didn't know what it was until he died. The names it contained were, Buffy, Curtis, im, Wikey, and nofo. Obviously Curtis and Buffy are dead, but one of the rest of those three are scum. I have a feeling Wikey is mafia so, ##Lynch Wikey.

Don't be a retard.

Rob @ 5/1/2014 8:06

Alright. Having re-checked, I think I'm leaning more towards Wikey than Nofo. While Nofo's posts don't generally tend to be helpful, it's more a case of him trying to be helpful and failing than anything, as far as I can tell. Wikey, on the other hand, showed up one time, proclaimed that he'd figure out the scum later, and then disappeared for the rest of the phase. That reeks of a "hey guys, I'm still alive so don't think I'm UTR!" post, and those are a pretty generic scum tactic. He could just be busy, mind you, but it's hard to tell.

Kind of important detail I might have missed out on day 2. I made that post after roughly 24 hours without any sleep, whilst ill. I wasn't hanging around or in a state to do much of anything!

I have been shit this game so far. I am going to do a bit of reading now. Don't expect miracles from me though.

Scum do not care who they lynch today if they have six members by the way.

They will be hoping to get a quick lynch in now. If my calculations are correct that is. Say they have 6, and there is 15 of us left.

All they have to hope for is a town lynch today, and two town kills over the night. Bear in mind they may have an unstoppable kill to ensure this happens regardless of what the SK does.

So...back to reading. No hasty moves though!

##Lynch : Nofo

Of 317, Wikey and him, I find him to be the scummiest.

My initial calling out of scum team:

Greenday
Kiwi
Nofo
Patrick
Rob
Lamps

No, I don't have a superman role. Unlike DD, I actually had to put effort into this!

So, I am calling out the top three in particular. It is just a vibe I am getting. Kiwi has been quite defensive of Greenday since the start. He definitely cannot be ruled out as scum because he was a late addition. He could have easily tipped the balance enough to be put on scum's team.

Actually, all this seemed much clearer until I got up to day 3. Now everything has gotten confusing, what with the item shit!

So, all we really can go on is the names that Colby received for now.

im, Wikey, and nofo.

I was hoping to see Kiwi and Greenday go for me, but they have not. It is what I would have been expecting since I think mafia just need one more town lynch to almost assure victory. And I have been shit enough to warrant a lynch. Instead, Kiwi declared he found Nofo more suspicious and lynched him.

Actually, looking at it.

Kiwi jumped through several suspects today. He started off by saying he had bad vibes from Vic and Nofo, and DR. Then when the note was revealed he said I would make a good bet for lynching. Then he decided to lynch Nofo instead! It looks odd. Not enough to commit to a lynch though. Fheh.

The im317 thing is confusing too. He claims to have given DR the vest but not the gun.

Let's look at this as if DR and im317 are scum.

So, Vic comes out with info that he has seen DR with a bulletproof vest and a gun. DR, looking so fucking scummy now, needs a way out. Her buddy im317 swoops in to save the day, by claiming he gave her the vest, but NOT the gun. Obviously, he couldn't say he had given her the gun too, or it would make both of them look bad. So, this stops anyone from looking at im317 on Colby's list too.

im317 has not cleared himself at all with this latest info. Going back to my original suspects, I am not even sure anymore tbh. I have just been writing a wall of text as I read through the events of day 2 and today. DR and im317 could easily be scum too.

And I reiterate, scum are close to victory now, and could even win if they lynch town today. So, let's not screw up.

I actually wouldn't be against DR using her gun...on Nofo.

Think about it:

DR kills Nofo, showing us whether he is town or scum, and based on that, we know where we stand with im317.

Sure, you could say that it still leaves me as a suspect, but seriously, fuck off before any of you say that again. I am not scum.

HEY, LIE DETECTOR. I AM NOT SCUM.

If we have a lie detector, that is. If we don't, just take my word for it!

How about if DR kills Greenday?

Wait, so because a person was defending me that makes me scum? Is this game seriously about to go full-retard right now?

Just for the record, since we're getting this close to the end of the game I'll say this: my role is passive and if I'm lynched today it helps the mafia to absurd amounts. If I'm lynched the town goes dark and all votes are anonymous. That boosts the mafia's chances like crazy. Having said this, anyone lynching me today should then be viewed mafia.