Reaper Of The Dead @ 7/5/2023 18:39

And how did your list get doubt in it? Who did you doubt in that list?

i mean way too many people sounded town and thats just wrong

we hadnt seen a single scum flip yet so i was starting to panic

Thisisbourbon @ 8/5/2023 2:50

BadgerMcBeaver @ 7/5/2023 20:48 Thisisbourbon @ 7/5/2023 21:24 BadgerMcBeaver @ 7/5/2023 20:21 jamie @ 7/5/2023 21:07 BadgerMcBeaver @ 7/5/2023 21:03 jamie @ 7/5/2023 20:35 is badger the vote shenaniganator I told you yesterday that I'm not. what scum actions did you get with your item Honestly my role isn't really that strong but it is town aligned. Why are you tunneling so hard on me? You listened to Nav. No, I listened to JJ because watcher is usually a town role in my experience. And the fact that she was being accused of being scum because her forum was loading slow didn't make sense to me. It was stupid a f for me to agree to Maddie because I also had a townish read on her. But JJ's role was out in the open and those were the two options that seemed plausible at the last minute, so I sided with person who had already claimed. I should have just voted with Jamie on Tib. He was prolly laughing his ass off at the whole situation. She watched Maddie go to IM and do…

IM was probably Mafia's kill attempt N2, and if I understand her role correctly, she possibly saved his life. Which is why they lynched her yesterday.

TheNavneet @ 8/5/2023 3:37

Reaper Of The Dead @ 7/5/2023 18:36 Sorry Nav. What was your reason for actually choosing Maddie? Of all the people in the game? Why didn’t you pick someone from your own scum list? At least then it would have made more sense. i was starting to doubt my reads so i went with a wildcard pick who no one was suspecting and genuinely thought i hit the jackpot

Someone dropped you this thing in your box N2 supposedly?

Herm @ 7/5/2023 18:49

TheNavneet @ 8/5/2023 3:37 Reaper Of The Dead @ 7/5/2023 18:36 Sorry Nav. What was your reason for actually choosing Maddie? Of all the people in the game? Why didn’t you pick someone from your own scum list? At least then it would have made more sense. i was starting to doubt my reads so i went with a wildcard pick who no one was suspecting and genuinely thought i hit the jackpot Someone dropped you this thing in your box N2 supposedly?

yeah yeah yeah

and i was a dumbass and didnt check lol

@jamie the notification goes away if you actually open the inbox page without opening the message. i did that at the day start and something came up and i just totally forgot

TheNavneet @ 8/5/2023 3:40

Reaper Of The Dead @ 7/5/2023 18:39 And how did your list get doubt in it? Who did you doubt in that list? i mean way too many people sounded town and thats just wrong we hadnt seen a single scum flip yet so i was starting to panic

That's what the stress ball is for lol.

Anyway, gonna get my reads out here before I forget!

TOWNIEST TOWN to have TOWNED
Herm
Farlig
Curt
Reaper
Jamie
Ahoda
Timmah
Badger
JJ
Nav
SCUMNIEST SCUM to have SCUMMED

That last vote swing effort felt super scummy to me, but we'll see how things develop I guess.

All four of those voters are scum guys lol, don’t overthink it too hard. It was 11:59am on a Saturday (:

They would’ve been close to majority today already if a townie died instead of TiB. And they’ve been able to use the vote cancel to change 2/3 of our lynches so they might’ve been (might still be) banking on using that to flip today’s vote to clinch the win

BadgerMcBeaver @ 8/5/2023 0:52

I think yesterday's vote was classic town vs town. Scum was prolly laughing their asses off at us.

Let's pretend we fucked up yesterday bc we haven't played for a while and forgot how to Mafia.

Game started with 19

4 mafia?
2 third party lynchers?
maybe SK?

6/7 scum
13/12 town

Nav-JJ-Badger lynch order imo

Curtis @ 8/5/2023 4:09

All four of those voters are scum guys lol, don’t overthink it too hard. It was 11:59am on a Saturday (: They would’ve been close to majority today already if a townie died instead of TiB. And they’ve been able to use the vote cancel to change 2/3 of our lynches so they might’ve been (might still be) banking on using that to flip today’s vote to clinch the win

If there is a vote thief, I am pretty sure it's Badger.

I still hate lists. But last time I said I wouldn’t do a list, I think I was lynched. So I’m doing a list.

From least scummy to most scummy.

Reaper
Farlig
Jamie
Herm
Curtis
Ahoda
Timmah
JJ
Badger
Nav

Curtis @ 8/5/2023 4:11

Game started with 19 4 mafia? 2 third party lynchers? maybe SK? 6/7 scum 13/12 town Nav-JJ-Badger lynch order imo

I don't necessarily think vote thief and Nav are aligned.

Although the Vote Thief role seems to have a randomized element to it, but I admit I don't understand why it can cancel so many votes??

I almost think we should switch to Badger. Depends on you guys.

As of right now, I’m staying with Nav.

Not saying that Badger is clear in my eyes, as I gave an explanation of why I think he is scummy. He may just be a 3P.

Herm @ 7/5/2023 22:26

Curtis @ 8/5/2023 4:11 Game started with 19 4 mafia? 2 third party lynchers? maybe SK? 6/7 scum 13/12 town Nav-JJ-Badger lynch order imo I don't necessarily think vote thief and Nav are aligned. Although the Vote Thief role seems to have a randomized element to it, but I admit I don't understand why it can cancel so many votes?? I almost think we should switch to Badger. Depends on you guys.

Vote thief is 100% mafia with Nav, it was all coordinated with the four of them dropping their votes at once yesterday. The cancelled votes were me/farlig/317

Curtis @ 8/5/2023 4:29

Herm @ 7/5/2023 22:26 Curtis @ 8/5/2023 4:11 Game started with 19 4 mafia? 2 third party lynchers? maybe SK? 6/7 scum 13/12 town Nav-JJ-Badger lynch order imo I don't necessarily think vote thief and Nav are aligned. Although the Vote Thief role seems to have a randomized element to it, but I admit I don't understand why it can cancel so many votes?? I almost think we should switch to Badger. Depends on you guys. Vote thief is 100% mafia with Nav, it was all coordinated with the four of them dropping their votes at once yesterday. The cancelled votes were me/farlig/317

Farlig, Kat, Maddie D2.

Herm @ 7/5/2023 22:28

JJ @ 8/5/2023 0:19 I KNEW TIB was scum! We should’ve voted him instead of Maddie. JJ, you town or scum? Any result from last night?

Herm, I'm 100% Town!

I'm not sure whether to share. Still deciding whether it's beneficial.