Darren Sanders @ 9/4/2017 19:03

If Herm is telling the truth = Maddie should have information If Maddie is telling the truth = Herm is lying

Unless maddie or herm were redirected.

Herm @ 9/4/2017 17:05

Darren Sanders @ 10/4/2017 2:03 If Herm is telling the truth = Maddie should have information If Maddie is telling the truth = Herm is lying This is incorrect. Did you read my role claim?

You said you protect the person against roleblockers and redirectors, correct?

Darren Sanders @ 9/4/2017 20:05

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 17:03 Maddie being Ahoda's cult buddy and using this whole plan just to get Sock lynched would be the dumbest move possible for her Then she's an outed Tracker who just got mafia lynched aka the highest priority mafia kill target in the game on day TWO. Makes absolutely no sense She gave us scum. Most likely person to be protected or watched.

Someone who gift wraps scum on day 2 will not last til day 5

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 20:06

Darren Sanders @ 9/4/2017 20:05 Curtis @ 9/4/2017 17:03 Maddie being Ahoda's cult buddy and using this whole plan just to get Sock lynched would be the dumbest move possible for her Then she's an outed Tracker who just got mafia lynched aka the highest priority mafia kill target in the game on day TWO. Makes absolutely no sense She gave us scum. Most likely person to be protected or watched. Someone who gift wraps scum on day 2 will not last til day 5

Unless people like you are constantly suspicious of that person so mafia decides to keep them alive so you keep diving head first down that rabbit hole *

##lynch herm

Darren Sanders @ 9/4/2017 20:03

If Herm is telling the truth = Maddie should have information If Maddie is telling the truth = Herm is lying

What if they're both telling the truth? Based on the conveniently narrow claim Herm made, there's a way that they could both be telling the truth.

Whoever said that if DS is town then he's mafia's biggest was so right.

I unlynched because I was going to throw my vote on Herm, but I'm thinking of just putting it back on Aries.

Is there a vote count somewhere?

Vic @ 9/4/2017 17:55

So does no one want to lynch Timmah?

I want to

Christian @ 10/4/2017 2:00

Darren Sanders @ 9/4/2017 19:59 CherryBerry @ 9/4/2017 16:58 If Herm targeted Christian N1, would that have prevented Christian from receiving a note? Not if herm is telling the truth about his role. It only works on roleblockers and redirectors oh yeah. hahah well still, it should be Herm or Maddie, but Herm over Maddie.

Me and Maddie are obviously both town.

This be sus.

So the only evidence of redirection is from an item that Zersch got, not a redirector role

Makes Herm look a little bit worse again I guess, but there can easily be a redirector out there. There's only been two nights, it's not farfetched that we wouldn't see redirection somewhere yet. I'm torn

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:08

Whoever said that if DS is town then he's mafia's biggest was so right.

biggest weapon*

Herm I feel like it's us against the world right now.

this is starting to give me a headache. i have to go with the person who dripped info and basically changed what they were claiming. Herm went from protect to protect from non kills to protect from just 2 things. this would have been so much easier if Curtis and Zersch were not backing up the re-director claim, but then Zersch makes it sound like i was the result of a 1 time gift...

fuck it. ##lynch Herm