I’ve definitely been confused trying to match Jamie’s explanation to the role PM as well. The phrasing is, to be fair, the family members WILL know who each other are. Which maybe fits with the theory that the baby can be recruited and all family members will know each other then? But when I first read it I definitely thought there were already multiple family members.

Idt it makes since for Jaime to come out with this and lie though

If baby was already family they would have claimed by now. It sounds like they are recruited into the family from town which is bad especially if they are taken away when the win.

Theory: baby is not a role but a tag. Tags can be moved around and changed so anybody can be baby which explains Christian's ability to always be town

Timmah,

Please fully claim. I think there is some confusion on what exactly you are doing with your role. At least for me, I feel it could go a couple different ways

Timmah we need a full claim, your last 4 of your social security and your mother’s maiden name

Rodney @ 20/8/2020 12:52

Lamps @ 20/8/2020 13:00 Rodney @ 20/8/2020 17:59 After hearing from all my suspects they all said something I like enough to have second thoughts so my remaining lynch list is 317 Nav Buffy Lamps With a wildcard on Stargate. That's someone I've been overlooking for a bit Lol you have me on your list and not Timmah ok... (: Meanwhile the next post as well as my full color coded analysis made it very clear that I suspect Timmah and then I lynched him but you take this post our of context and buffy likes it despite knowing you did. Timmah has a claim and is scummy. The list I posted is unknown people with likely scum among them. You know thats what it meant but I'll spell it out since you want to twist my very clearly stated reads

I liked Lamps post because it was a good post. Despite your color-coded list (where you put me in the bottom soley because of the part of my role description you can see without knowing anything else and despite the fact I've been very towny and present and aiding discussion all game and then put some clearly scummy people up above lol) you've labeled this as your "lynch list" which means you're willing to lynch those four over others, despite your color-coded list so it clearly takes precedence. Also, I like a lot of Lamps posts this game.

The only one I really agree with on your list as maybe a good lynch candidate for today is 317 but I still think there are much better candidates for today which are not on your list.

ZacharyB @ 20/8/2020 9:33

JJ @ 20/8/2020 13:18 ZacharyB @ 20/8/2020 12:10 I could see Buffy being similarly opportunistic since she kept on mentioning my “fixation” (: For the record, I would lynch Timmah too at this point (if I could lynch), but you two are probably my top two right now. A lot of my reasoning for you comes down to process of elimination as to who I really feel good about as town, or in Jamie's case imo, non-threats to town. I understand being busy but at some point you have to look at the overall content and contribution toward discussion and, for me, it's just not there with you. The fact you were pretty focused on Kyle, which seems like an easy person to focus on since he was so inactive until yesterday, is actually a more correct example of "opportunistic" in my book at least. I haven't really seen you give much else. That's why I suspect you. But I still love you so much. Love u2, and i of course still love my eternal frenemy Nav It’s just frustrating! Again trying to do better today though :)

i dont love u but i think ur ok here and there in small doses

I’ll take what I can get scumneet

Buffy maybe you should re-read my color post and then your know that lamps' post is in fact not good but completely and probably intentionally misleading

I didn't make a scum tier. I separated all the people with evidence to believe they are town then among the rest I split them into 2 groups. The top have information out or have at least been interrogated a bit. The leftover group is not a list of scum, it's exactly what it is, the leftovers. You happen to be among the unclaimed, no info given, non-interrogated group. I'm not calling you scum specifically. I have no idea, you are just among the shrinking pool where scum is almost certainly hiding. You should be able to admit that this is your current scenario, you haven't given us anything information-wise which lands you in that group. Is that not completely fair??

boobs is clearly omitting a lot of info from his role. he's not mafia tho so can be left alone for now

Matt @ 20/8/2020 13:20

I also don’t fully buy it’s a family of two given that the wording of Wikey’s role seems to imply at least three, but maybe that was included in case the baby gets recruited. I want to trust Boobs but I’m gay for a reason!!

I don't believe they need to recruit their baby. They already knew who they all are. It's right in Wikey's role description, isn't it?

Rodney @ 20/8/2020 13:07

Buffy maybe you should re-read my color post and then your know that lamps' post is in fact not good but completely and probably intentionally misleading I didn't make a scum tier. I separated all the people with evidence to believe they are town then among the rest I split them into 2 groups. The top have information out or have at least been interrogated a bit. The leftover group is not a list of scum, it's exactly what it is, the leftovers. You happen to be among the unclaimed, no info given, non-interrogated group. I'm not calling you scum specifically. I have no idea, you are just among the shrinking pool where scum is almost certainly hiding. You should be able to admit that this is your current scenario, you haven't given us anything information-wise which lands you in that group. Is that not completely fair??

Yep, I'm in an unknown group as far as not having claimed a role or as far as no clear evidence I'm town. That is fair.

Can you understand why that's not a great lynch list?

Christian @ 20/8/2020 13:12

Matt @ 20/8/2020 13:20 I also don’t fully buy it’s a family of two given that the wording of Wikey’s role seems to imply at least three, but maybe that was included in case the baby gets recruited. I want to trust Boobs but I’m gay for a reason!! I don't believe they need to recruit their baby. They already knew who they all are. It's right in Wikey's role description, isn't it?

Jamie says he doesn't know.

Although you don’t have a private forum to communicate on, the family members will all know who each other are


Actually Christian, based on this I think we have confirmation that baby is not in the family yet. If they were then they'd know who they are and Jamie doesn't.

Maybe the baby's not family yet.

boobs @ 20/8/2020 13:26

Matt @ 20/8/2020 13:20 I also don’t fully buy it’s a family of two given that the wording of Wikey’s role seems to imply at least three, but maybe that was included in case the baby gets recruited. I want to trust Boobs but I’m gay for a reason!! But for real, Wikey and I were the only members of the family I am aware of. It’s possible if I find the baby turns 3rd party so they win with wikey/I but other than that I don’t think any recruiting goes on. I’ve tried to ask Brian if the baby knows I’m out there or if they are 3rd party also but he wouldn’t say so I’m assuming baby does not know about me and they also aren’t 3rd party. If anyone wants to admit they are 3rd party I can check them to see if they are my child lol

you're lying about not knowing who your baby is. It's right in Wikey's role description that all the Family members know who they are. So what else are you lying about?