Shadow @ 12/10/2015 11:05

I was voting for you last round and I am voting for you this round. I have not lurked. This is the first time I logged on to see the day was posted since it wasn't last night. I saw page 1 and saw you survived again and immediately lynched you. It's gonna stay that way unless you claim because when someone constantly survives something they usually end up to be a bad role

9 total posts in the first 2 days and now you are up to 11 i think. That's borderline lurking. Especially since EVERY one of the day 2 posts was about me, trying to get me lynched. Have you absolutely no other thoughts or opinions in the game except for me? I'm flattered, but damn could you be more useless?

Man, as often as Redster has taken to saying that I am obviously scum, you'd think he'd be voting to lynch me

Beaver looking bad right now.

Timmah @ 12/10/2015 11:14

Man, as often as Redster has taken to saying that I am obviously scum, you'd think he'd be voting to lynch me

Nice try, I know that trick. The minute I vote you everything I say is null and void because it's just "omgus". It's early yet. I honestly can't decide yet. You seem scummy. Angi seems scummy. Herm seems scummy. Shadow seems scummy. Beaver I don't get a scum vibe from, but there is the roleblock issue that needs addressed at some point. And then there are still like 4 or 5 more lurkers yet to check-in. So I'm not in a rush to throw votes around.

Not at all. I go on facts not ~oh he posted funny using all caps therefore scummy~ it's been 2 days calm your tits

##lynch BadgerMcBeaver

I at least want to hear more about the roleblock issue.

The timmah/redster debate almost seems contrived to me, tbh.

primate @ 12/10/2015 13:27

The timmah/redster debate almost seems contrived to me, tbh.

so contrived

primate @ 12/10/2015 11:27

The timmah/redster debate almost seems contrived to me, tbh.

so contrived

Timmah @ 12/10/2015 11:32

primate @ 12/10/2015 13:27 The timmah/redster debate almost seems contrived to me, tbh. so contrived

Oh, shit. I thought we agreed I was gonna say it.

Redster @ 12/10/2015 13:35

Timmah @ 12/10/2015 11:32 primate @ 12/10/2015 13:27 The timmah/redster debate almost seems contrived to me, tbh. so contrived Oh, shit. I thought we agreed I was gonna say it.

DAMMIT!! I messed that up. My bad!

Ari @ 12/10/2015 13:29

Whats the argument for lynching Redster? Apart from survival? I dont really see it

SCUM ari in action...I can tell....it's like he has SCUM tattooed on his whitey white forehead...

##lynch redster

If you guys really want me to claim before the end of the day, then I am willing to claim because my role can explain why the role block had no effect on me. It would be unfortunate to have to do so because roleclaiming basically neutralizes my role. So before we jump straight to that, I think its worth looking at the other reasons that were brought up by Freecandy because none of them make any sense to me.

The first is that he brought up is that he thought these three posts looked interesting (not really sure what he meant by 'interesting' as its a very vague thing to say). The first two were speculation about things that were cleared up by the mods shortly after. And the third was me outlining why I think Daniel has been scummy as hell. I don't really see what about these three posts raised suspicion but I guess you guys can judge for yourselves.

Quote

I have no idea what a Kidnapper would do, and don't see anything about the role on either of the mafia wikis I just looked at. Both possibilities brought up by Timmah sound plausible, or maybe it could have been a role similar to silencer? I guess it doesn't really matter that much since he died before having a chance to use them. Also, I found it pretty funny that Nofo complained about Herm jumping on end-of-day lynch trains in the same post where he jumped on that same lynch train himself.

Quote

Quote Curtis @ 8/10/2015 21:44 Seems that two people are chosen by mafia/third party to get dragged away and then one is killed? If this interpretation is correct, town doc would have a 50/50 chance of saving the correct person each night so I think there has to be more to it than that.

Quote

I could be down for voting Gmaj or JC but right now I'm leaning towards Daniel. I agree that he isn't really contributing anything at the moment. He called Curt definite scum a few times yesterday based on very little, and I also feel he was really quick to point the finger at Redster earlier on in this day phase: Quote Daniel @ 9/10/2015 3:08 I'd also vote Redster. Even if he comes up with some explanation it is probably bs. This came off as really scummy to me. I'm not sure what to make of Redster at the moment, but generally I think its a good practice to hear someone out before jumping to a conclusion like this. I also find it weird that he would FOS Buffy at the beginning of today (for what I thought was a pretty reasonable post) and then get defensive and make the claim that she is always after him ever mafia game when she throws a little shade in his direction. This last bit is purely speculation so take it with a grain of salt, but its worth noting that he is the one person who voted for Curtis that wasn't kidnapped... If he was the jailer and was trying to set up a Curtis lynch the following day then kidnapping the two other people that voted for Curt kinda takes the heat off himself a little bit. It would have been a decent strategy, especially considering the jailer probably had no idea that that Vern was going to flip mafia. I'm still open to other options but for now ##lynch Daniel.

Free Candy's other reason for lynching me is that he thinks that this was an attempt to draw me out with a response, but frankly I don't see what it has to do with me at all or why he would expect me in particular to respond to it:

Quote

Also, do you find it odd that we will hear "a couple of screams and see two people being dragged off to a cave" prior to N1, in the D1 write up. I'm assuming could possibly be a SK that is unblockable? SK picks the two victims then chooses which dies N1?

I really don't get what this post has to do with me *shrug*.

I do get the concern about the role block, and like I said I will be ready to explain that if this train continues to maintain steam closer to deadline. But the other stuff makes about zero sense as reasons to lynch me, and I think there are better people to lynch here.

you see if ari wasn't protecting his boss here, and he just does so because it's looking really bad for redster, legitimately, I might not have recognized, that early at least, that's he's made a deal with the dark side, the scum side, the GET FUCKED side....well he sided with the wrong gang....and once redster is gone he's the next in line....to GET FUCKED...meltdown-time....snow-men gonna cry!

everyone not voting redster, though voicing suspicion and making allegations against him, well you're about to GET FUCKED too.....now if you don't want that you better place your vote where it belongs!

Henry_42 @ 12/10/2015 11:51

everyone not voting redster, though voicing suspicion and making allegations against him, well you're about to GET FUCKED too.....now if you don't want that you better place your vote where it belongs!

Are you on drugs

What do you guys think Redster is?

For him to be mafia either
1. Mafia was blocked night 2 and Redster was attacked by town/another third party
2. Mafia attacked their own member, Redster, somehow.

Doesnt seem very likely to me that he is mafia, unless I am missing something here?

For him to be town he would have to have been saved by two different people on consecutive nights, which also seem very unlikely.

Could very well be third party BP and plainly lying to us. My guess at the moment.


What do you think Badger is?

Free Candy cant block him? So what? He could easily be something like a hider, which cant be targeted. Am I missing something here? Are we assuming the jailor cant be targeted at night?

Redster @ 12/10/2015 21:07

Henry_42 @ 12/10/2015 11:51 everyone not voting redster, though voicing suspicion and making allegations against him, well you're about to GET FUCKED too.....now if you don't want that you better place your vote where it belongs! Are you on drugs

Very likely.

Rose is the jailer

Redster, claim.