I'm going to add rewatches to this too as a lot of these movies are very blurry for me and I want to eventually have a list similar to Curtis' with rankings. My favorite animated movie growing up was Toy Story, which I have not seen in over 15 years (jeeeez....) so I rewatched that earlier today. It still holds up as a classic. I would honestly say it's still my favorite out of all these.

Commencing UP now, which I remember nothing about except the very emotional opening sequence.

https://letterboxd.com/tommyhero/list/disney-rankings/

Starting my list on letterboxd now that I have 10 movies under my belt. I will not be rating movies I already watched until I rewatch them. I've upped my ratings for all three Toy Story movies. I haven't seen the second one since I was a kid and forgot how good it was, I originally rated it as a 3 and bumped it to a 4. And I cannot put into words how great Toy Story 3 is. I really, really liked it when I saw it when it first came out. But after binging the entire series in one go, which I definitely have never done before... what a ride! That last sequence is still so powerful.

I fell asleep during Up (: I was exhausted. I'll watch it again sometime today.

I'm... still not 100% sure how far I'm going to go with this!

No old school Disney movies?

Which one is the one with the evil cockroaches?

A Bug's Life or Antz?

Herm @ 12/3/2019 11:55

No old school Disney movies?

This... is what I'm debating. I had just about every classic Disney movie on VHS when I was a kid and seen them all. Most of the princess ones are cheesy and I feel like would be a huge chore getting through. For right now I think I'll try to get through every computer animated movie from Disney and then go from there if I want to do all the classic ones too. It's gonna take awhile either way.

Up was good but I don't think it's one of the best of all time as it's usually rated. Unpopular opinion maybe but if it wasn't for that first 10 minutes to set everything up, I don't think it would have been as memorable. It was still great and higher on the list than most, but doesn't break Top 5 for me. Russell and Carl had fun chemistry and I liked the side characters.

Herm @ 12/3/2019 10:56

Which one is the one with the evil cockroaches? A Bug's Life or Antz?

Antz had termites IIRC

If you don’t cry at the beginning of Up you don’t have a soul

Does anyone else not really cry at movies, or am I the only soulless asshole here?

Curtis laughs during sad movies

KC @ 12/3/2019 16:06

Curtis laughs during sad movies

tru

I don't cry during movies at all no

I only cry during certain sad/emotional scenes in movies.

95% of the time.

I never got emotional during movies at all when I was younger but I do now. A lot.

Only because of animals or if it's animated, the two might be related.

Ever since I had kids I cry a ton more during movies. But nothing like Big Fish. Man that movie gets me every time