Next best role to take out, right? Exactly.

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:01

Also DS and Nav had more powerful roles. Definitely bigger targets than dumbass little me.

I figured DS was going to redirect actions from himself onto someone else. I didn't think scum would risk going after him and possibly killing themselves.

Josh @ 10/2/2018 16:02

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:01 Also DS and Nav had more powerful roles. Definitely bigger targets than dumbass little me. I figured DS was going to redirect actions from himself onto someone else. I didn't think scum would risk going after him and possibly killing themselves.

"Last song successfully used: “The Witch”- Choose two players. Whatever happens to the first one this night will happen to both."


Pretty sure DS couldn't pick himself. Farlig had the deflective role.


You killed DS because you didn't want to have a role in the game that could deflect a kill another night.

You guys Josh is obviously scum. This is ridiculous.

The Sebneet @ 10/2/2018 14:11

I think the fact that Josh only has 1 Watch result and it involves 2 Mafia makes him look real bad. I will go back and check if it's even possible Herm visited Canuck the night Josh said he did. If there were multiple dance deaths that night then Josh is basically caught scum.

I have more than one watch result.

I saw Herm visit Canuck.
I saw Maddie visit Zach.
I saw Farlig visit Buffy.

Josh @ 10/2/2018 16:04

The Sebneet @ 10/2/2018 14:11 I think the fact that Josh only has 1 Watch result and it involves 2 Mafia makes him look real bad. I will go back and check if it's even possible Herm visited Canuck the night Josh said he did. If there were multiple dance deaths that night then Josh is basically caught scum. I have more than one watch result. I saw Herm visit Canuck. I saw Maddie visit Zach. I saw Farlig visit Buffy.

No one is necessarily doubting that you're a watcher. I'm doubting that you're town watcher, at least.

Josh @ 10/2/2018 12:02

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:01 Also DS and Nav had more powerful roles. Definitely bigger targets than dumbass little me. I figured DS was going to redirect actions from himself onto someone else. I didn't think scum would risk going after him and possibly killing themselves.

Wait this is a good point. DS said the way he's been using his role was to pick himself and someone else. So how was he the only death last night.

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:04

Josh @ 10/2/2018 16:02 Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:01 Also DS and Nav had more powerful roles. Definitely bigger targets than dumbass little me. I figured DS was going to redirect actions from himself onto someone else. I didn't think scum would risk going after him and possibly killing themselves. "Last song successfully used: “The Witch”- Choose two players. Whatever happens to the first one this night will happen to both." Pretty sure DS couldn't pick himself. Farlig had the deflective role. You killed DS because you didn't want to have a role in the game that could deflect a kill another night.

Why do you think DS couldn't pick himself? That makes no sense. The whole reason he was after Farlig was because their roles were similar. Why would he be so adamant about them being the same if he couldn't use it on himself?

The Sebneet @ 10/2/2018 16:06

Josh @ 10/2/2018 12:02 Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:01 Also DS and Nav had more powerful roles. Definitely bigger targets than dumbass little me. I figured DS was going to redirect actions from himself onto someone else. I didn't think scum would risk going after him and possibly killing themselves. Wait this is a good point. DS said the way he's been using his role was to pick himself and someone else. So how was he the only death last night.

Maybe he couldn't pick himself more than once/on back to back nights?


Nav don't let him convince you. Josh is scum.

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:06

Josh @ 10/2/2018 16:04 The Sebneet @ 10/2/2018 14:11 I think the fact that Josh only has 1 Watch result and it involves 2 Mafia makes him look real bad. I will go back and check if it's even possible Herm visited Canuck the night Josh said he did. If there were multiple dance deaths that night then Josh is basically caught scum. I have more than one watch result. I saw Herm visit Canuck. I saw Maddie visit Zach. I saw Farlig visit Buffy. No one is necessarily doubting that you're a watcher. I'm doubting that you're town watcher, at least.

I was commenting on him saying I only have one watch result.

Regardless, watching me makes no fucking sense with both Nav and DS still in the game.

Another option: Josh is a godfather equivalent so DS made an attack on himself deflect to Josh, but Josh can't be killed at night so DS died.

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:08

Regardless, watching me makes no fucking sense with both Nav and DS still in the game.

Why not? I knew Nav would commute so I wouldn't get results.

DS had the chance to deflect actions off of himself onto someone else. I figured he couldn't use it on the same person two nights in a row because that is usually a stipulation with a role.

Josh why didn't you watch Ben, the claimed Princess, the night after he claimed?

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:09

Another option: Josh is a godfather equivalent so DS made an attack on himself deflect to Josh, but Josh can't be killed at night so DS died.

Wouldn't that mean this would have been a NK night? Why would me being a GF turn his role back on him?