Boc @ 9/10/2012 0:06

Helios Garabandia @ 8/10/2012 23:03 For about a half a second, when reading the closing flavor, I thought that there was gonna be some reveal of Rob and Natalie with some kind of Lover-esque roles! Which would've been one hell of a twist, since those two are the only two that I never truly suspected as Scum at any point in this game. lol with all the emphasis the flavor seemed to have on Rob, I expected there to be a Keyser Soze reveal with him being the head scum the whole time

You and me both!!! I even questioned him a few times about it. :ermm:

I was reading thinking the same thing about rob or Nat...which is why I debated scanning one of them...

I even said i thought we got all scum, but I wanted to scan the person that wasn't confirmed that I felt most sketchy about and that was Ari.

Helios....how did you ever think I was scum???

Bryce @ 8/10/2012 22:52

That scum board is full of suck....and Waka.

I'd say thanks, but our team was disbanded pretty easily. So yeah, all scum of us have to take responsability for us...

How did Vernon found out I was scum though?

As for the ending, I can't say much of it... I have to update myself with the story to get most of what happened there...

Well my internet is out, so I probably blew my entire month's worth of phone internet refreshing this board all day.

While I do agree that the Henry win is incredibly dissatisfying I was always prepared for something along those lines, so it's not so bad.

I had a phenomenal time, and I don't think the end result changes that at all.

Also I came to realise right before doing the final showdown that I made a fairly serious administrative error. Not something that would've helped the town though. I doubt it would have helped scum either so probably no difference at all. Given that scum were basically all dead by Phase 12, it didn't matter.

But Jeff did put in a final phase action to silence Rob, something I forgot to instigate. So I apologise profusely for that. It sucks when I skip something fairly substantial.

I honestly gave up about halfway through this game. We got wrecked and I lost all inibition to continue playing.

Alright guys, thanks for the positive words. You're the best. Makes me feel a lot better about what I perceived to be a very disastrous finish.

Experiencing chest pains which is my body's way of demanding I sleep. I'll post up the rest of the threads plus the epilogues tomorrow.

I intended for the "ending" to come a little later in the plotted narrative but I think it's better I just write some epilogue flavour separately. Better to do on sleep too since I have the whole thing in my head but getting it out in text form requires a bit of concentration.

Helios Garabandia @ 8/10/2012 23:47

Oh yeah, that reminds me. To clear up something from way earlier in the game, I'm the one who claimed Natalie's guns way back when. I posted in my journal to snatch them. I didn't mention it back then because I didn't want to draw the attention of the scum. While I knew I wouldn't die if they came after me, I didn't want to survive a kill and have to claim that early. I never shot anyone.

Glad to know where they went and that they were in good hands ;)

I considered pressing the issue, but hoped if town had picked them up it would be better to just let it be forgotten.

Natalie @ 9/10/2012 4:17

Boc @ 9/10/2012 0:06 Helios Garabandia @ 8/10/2012 23:03 For about a half a second, when reading the closing flavor, I thought that there was gonna be some reveal of Rob and Natalie with some kind of Lover-esque roles! Which would've been one hell of a twist, since those two are the only two that I never truly suspected as Scum at any point in this game. lol with all the emphasis the flavor seemed to have on Rob, I expected there to be a Keyser Soze reveal with him being the head scum the whole time You and me both!!! I even questioned him a few times about it. :ermm:

Given how the sheer amount of sneaking around I did and how many of the important items I acquired, the town would have been hurtin'.

I actually had a moment of panic in phase thirteen when SK accusations started, because my actions actually coincided perfectly with how I would have played the game as the serial killer.

Incidentally, what confirmed Dutchiee as scum was the fact that he didn't share the safe combination for the bank. I gave it to him immediately after I used it and waited to see what he'd do. The fact that he kept it quiet was a pretty serious red flag. But I couldn't say that without revealing that I had given it to him, and since Rito screwed up everything by revealing that I went to the bank instead of the park, they would know that I had taken whatever was inside and kill me as a result.

In all honesty Paul, if anything, this was just a much better and cooler way to explain mid dialogue and plot before Lab 3. This was much better than reading a wall of text that had no interactions whatsoever....I wouldn't have read it hahaha

It was like an interactive cutscene! (:

Well well well this wouldn't be a very bito finale without the main bito himself, et al Rito!!!!!

Henry wins? Oh men... that doesn't make me happy! LOL! I think I was the first to suggest there may have been 3rd party in the game, but shit, why would I think to suspect the dead? Let alone, why would I fear the dead 3rd party could even still win the game? Anyway, it happened. So congrats to Henrick I suppose!

Waka. How did I know you're scum? I just suspected you using my bito methods. You seemed to be hiding something, and I had already been voting for you since Round1. So I just did it, and killed you. Rob happened to not even log on and see the kill so I just went with it, and got crazier and crazier each week haha. Then when I found Waka's journal which he had told no one about, I thought it was maybe more of a scum weapon than a town one, so I told everyone that I knew he was 100% scum and went with it.

I'm happy I killed Vespis and that me being a bomb did some good :) I was trying to get him killed all game so it works for me.

Jeff I didn't actually suspect until the end of the game. He was the only possible person that I thought could have stole from me. @ Nat, I knew no one stole my box. Paul clarified it to me that week, but I just made it seem like more had been stolen from me.

IndeX was just a lot of fun. I had NO plans whatsoever with him other than trying to scare the mafia and getting them to slip up. I just wanted to cause some havoc and I think I accomplished that.

Trying to kill Helios actually did some good. That trap I set up way back way did some good. By the way, Rob did NOT know I set it up. Not sure why he says he knew I did? I made that a private action in my journal, and this is one of the main reasons I slightly suspected him as a ringleader mafia at the end of the game. But him giving me his wallet made me think completely otherwise. BTW - I used the potion on Rob several weeks ago. I told no one this.

Dutchiee was an obvious scummy. And then the scan thing just nailed it.

All the inactives really messed up the dynamics of the game. If at least one of FF, Curtis, Tayvie, etc. wasn't inactive then I dont think Henry would be the victor. Town really deserved it, and I'm truly shocked not one of Rob or Natalie or Ari happened to be scum in disguise. I thought it was too good to be true that all of them were townies.

My votelist all game was actually pretty awesome. Pretty cool to see!

Bryce and Dylan you two were confusing me all game. I had no idea what ya'll were doin lol. Bryce, as for our adventure. I just wanted to have fun. So I told everyone you were a werewolf and to kill you lol.

Who gave me body armor to save my life? And then Ari using his kill saved me AGAIN. So awesome!

Anyway, those are the bito thoughts! (:

Vernon... the option to set a trap was in the flavour text. You asked me whether we should set the trap. I said "Yes, let's do that."

That's how I knew.

Wait, duh.

The reason I killed Waka was because I figured one of the 3 of us (me, rob, waka) HAD to be scum hunting for weapons or items.

Rob seems VERY town to me and I had already been voting Waka all game based on low-key scummy actions. I asked Rob what he thought of Waka and he gave me an answer that he could possibly be scum. So that was enough - I killed him.

Rob @ 8/10/2012 23:13

Vernon... the option to set a trap was in the flavour text. You asked me whether we should set the trap. I said "Yes, let's do that." That's how I knew.

rly? ok
:merc: