Helios Garabandia @ 4/1/2018 23:17

Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:49 Primate @ 4/1/2018 22:48 Why would you protect the scummy looking inactive? I was protecting the inactive, I was RBing the inactive. I was thinking scum might be likely to send one of the inactives out for the kill. Forgive me if this was said already and I missed it, but.... 1) Your Jailkeeper lets you choose to protect or roleblock, not both? 2) You only blocked Rose, not protected her?

No it basically does both simultaneously. I prevent the person I jail from using their night action while also preventing them from being killed.


When I jailed Christian I had to check with the mods and they said my action didn’t work because he was hider and that came first in order of ops/hider can’t be jailed, apparently.

Snowflake poker @ 5/1/2018 4:18

Herm @ 4/1/2018 22:15 Farlig, I don't understand why you're making an either Rose/Maddie claim. If they are both town, then? Please explain how I am making the claimed jailkeeper (maddie) claim.

You said if one ain't scum, the other is, or something to that effect.

Snowflake poker @ 4/1/2018 22:20

Herm @ 4/1/2018 22:15 Farlig, I don't understand why you're making an either Rose/Maddie claim. If they are both town, then? And where am I saying rose should claim? And why are you defending an active so aggressively?

Inactive

I wish I had jailed DS last night instead, even if it had meant we’d get one less investigative result from him.

Yeah jailer normally does both.

Herm @ 4/1/2018 22:21

Snowflake poker @ 5/1/2018 4:18 Herm @ 4/1/2018 22:15 Farlig, I don't understand why you're making an either Rose/Maddie claim. If they are both town, then? Please explain how I am making the claimed jailkeeper (maddie) claim. You said if one ain't scum, the other is, or something to that effect.

Um, no? They could easily both be town, both be scum, or one be scum and one town.

Ds' investigations weren't very fruitful anyway. Glad he wasn't vig 😁

Mads @ 4/1/2018 22:21

Helios Garabandia @ 4/1/2018 23:17 Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:49 Primate @ 4/1/2018 22:48 Why would you protect the scummy looking inactive? I was protecting the inactive, I was RBing the inactive. I was thinking scum might be likely to send one of the inactives out for the kill. Forgive me if this was said already and I missed it, but.... 1) Your Jailkeeper lets you choose to protect or roleblock, not both? 2) You only blocked Rose, not protected her? No it basically does both simultaneously. I prevent the person I jail from using their night action while also preventing them from being killed.

....but wait, what about what you said earlier?

Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:50

My role is really fucking hard because every night I have to decide whether to protect or whether to block.

Impossible to know if someone's scum if they're not here.

All I know about Rose is that she in a way gave us Lamps, not sure scum would have thought to bring that onto the table. She Could Be Kids Table but not In-Law.

Helios Garabandia @ 4/1/2018 23:25

Mads @ 4/1/2018 22:21 Helios Garabandia @ 4/1/2018 23:17 Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:49 Primate @ 4/1/2018 22:48 Why would you protect the scummy looking inactive? I was protecting the inactive, I was RBing the inactive. I was thinking scum might be likely to send one of the inactives out for the kill. Forgive me if this was said already and I missed it, but.... 1) Your Jailkeeper lets you choose to protect or roleblock, not both? 2) You only blocked Rose, not protected her? No it basically does both simultaneously. I prevent the person I jail from using their night action while also preventing them from being killed. ....but wait, what about what you said earlier? Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:50 My role is really fucking hard because every night I have to decide whether to protect or whether to block.

About having to choose? I meant I have to choose how I want to use the role—-to protect a townie but sacrifice their, or to roleblock scum.

Herm @ 4/1/2018 23:26

Impossible to know if someone's scum if they're not here. All I know about Rose is that she in a way gave us Lamps, not sure scum would have thought to bring that onto the table. She Could Be Kids Table but not In-Law.

Wasn’t TIB in-law godmother? Rose could be kid’s table GF.

Mads @ 4/1/2018 23:27

Helios Garabandia @ 4/1/2018 23:25 Mads @ 4/1/2018 22:21 Helios Garabandia @ 4/1/2018 23:17 Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:49 Primate @ 4/1/2018 22:48 Why would you protect the scummy looking inactive? I was protecting the inactive, I was RBing the inactive. I was thinking scum might be likely to send one of the inactives out for the kill. Forgive me if this was said already and I missed it, but.... 1) Your Jailkeeper lets you choose to protect or roleblock, not both? 2) You only blocked Rose, not protected her? No it basically does both simultaneously. I prevent the person I jail from using their night action while also preventing them from being killed. ....but wait, what about what you said earlier? Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:50 My role is really fucking hard because every night I have to decide whether to protect or whether to block. About having to choose? I meant I have to choose how I want to use the role—-to protect a townie but sacrifice their, or to roleblock scum.

Sorry sacrifice their action**


I’m on mobile right now.

My role is like the dual-use dilemma in nuclear security.

I like that role. It's versatile.

It is—-it’s a little more interesting than a plain roleblocking role.