I feel like the slow child in class who is only just starting to understand a subject whilst everyone else in the class has moved on.

Bad:
Jay

Very Likely Bad:
Curtis

Suspicious Of:
Patrick
thisisbad
Lamps
Wikey

Unsure of:
Zero
Chris
Timmah
vlady

Likely Town:
Boc
Sab
Ari
Herm?
Vernon?

I should look over the posts of the people I'm unsure of, namely vlady and Timmah. There's probably not much from Zero and I already know Chris' story.

Wikey @ 10/4/2016 10:38

I feel like the slow child in class who is only just starting to understand a subject whilst everyone else in the class has moved on.

Glad you could finally join us. :P

The only thing I can think of for Lamps being scum is this:

Lamps is either the poisoner or on the team with the poisoner. Lamps claimed to be poisoned so once there were two poison claims in him and Zilla, Zilla would die at the end of the day and Lamps would live. Then the obvious solution is that there's a town poison doctor who chose Lamps to save, because of course they would over the inactive Zilla (explains the motivation for poisoning Zilla of all people). Then Lamps now gets to claim that he's not mafia because they poisoned him. It's kind of a long con if true but not a particularly far fetched one at all and has benefits. The last several games in a row have included different plays like that

I've thought Lamps has been Town for awhile but the only reason I'm skeptical at this point is because of a town poison doctor. For Lamps to survive being poisoned, there has to be a town poison doctor who can save one of the two people by the end of the day. But if the poisoning was a one time thing which it definitely seems to be, WHY would there be a town role that exists just for this one moment

Again, ignore all of this if it's already been discussed, but:

I think Dr's fakeclaim of being cult with Jay might suggest that the other scum member on Zook's train was on her team.

Curtis (5/9) - Boc, Christian, Vernon, Ari, Lamps
Lamps (3/9) - thisisbad, Sabataged, vladykins
Boc (1/9) - Curtis
Christian (1/9) - Chris
Wikey (0/9) - Herm

Or the other team...

Fuck it, it's sunday afternoon and I'm drunk.

Don't judge. AT LEAST I'M TRYING

lol sadly I'm not sure any of this matters. I think scum definitely outnumbers town at this point, I was gonna post the same thing as you yesterday Christian that I felt we were two of very few townies left

34 started the game. Scum is usually 1/3rd, so let's say each mafia started with 5 people. Only 2 have died. One third party died and one Cult

16 Alive
4 Red mafia
4 Purple mafia
1 Cult
7 Town

Scum to Town is 9:7

gg (:

Idea:

All three of the current suspects from Canuck's list claim, if they haven't done so already.

This shit is taking up too much of our focus. We really aren't doing that well, only member from each mafia team has been lynched so far.

Shut up Curtis you cynic, we can still win.

Because I am here we will win.

Wikey @ 10/4/2016 10:51

Idea: All three of the current suspects from Canuck's list claim, if they haven't done so already. This shit is taking up too much of our focus. We really aren't doing that well, only member from each mafia team has been lynched so far.

I honestly don't think this would help anything or this would probably have happened already.

wouldn't help = wouldn't change people's minds

Wikey @ 10/4/2016 10:45

Again, ignore all of this if it's already been discussed, but: I think Dr's fakeclaim of being cult with Jay might suggest that the other scum member on Zook's train was on her team.

Remaining person is definitely on her team over Redster's I think

Angi was on the list and was killed N4 almost certainly by a mafia team. Rose was still on the list at the time as was one of Boc/Christian. There's no way that Rose's team would start to pick off the list people if two of them were still on it, they'd want as much wiggle room as they could get and would try to prolong two of their deaths