Wikey @ 4/11/2015 10:15

...wall of text... wah...why didn't i get the gun...

Ok, I get it. You want me to shoot you instead. That could probably be done.

Timmah @ 4/11/2015 10:18

Also, Curtis seems to have gone into hiding on us. No posts yesterday that I can recall, liking a post or 2 already today, but no posts.

Hi

Busy last night when the day went up and at work right now til later. Not silenced. I'll be around later

Wikey @ 4/11/2015 10:18

Just so we are all on the same page, in most games here, if the mafia have an additional killing role (like a one time unstoppable killer) it can be used the same night as the normal attack. Sometimes there will be a clause, like the unstoppable killer can't go out for both kills, but that's about it. Also, hello Dadd, is this entertaining or wut? :)

The proper greeting is FU Dadd!

You asked everybody's opinion, then immediately threatened the person to give you theirs...

See, this is why I'm suspicious of the motivations of the gun giver. They had several near confirmed townies to choose from, but they chose you.

Timmah @ 4/11/2015 10:21

The proper greeting is FU Dadd!

You forgot to bold it.

Wikey @ 4/11/2015 10:23

You asked everybody's opinion, then immediately threatened the person to give you theirs... See, this is why I'm suspicious of the motivations of the gun giver. They had several near confirmed townies to choose from, but they chose you.

You suggested that they give the gun to you, im317, or buffy. Let's think through those options, shall we?

im317 (claims town vig) - has taken credit for a number of kills (all town), yet has never been targeted by mafia/sk/3rd party/etc. Wouldn't scum want a town killer out of the way?

Buffy (town roleblocker) - Pretty obvious kill target. If the gun-giver is town, why risk wasting the gun on a likely mafia kill target?

You - As far as I recall, you haven't claimed or hinted at any role. Why would a gun-giver (if town) give a gun to an unknown player?

-----

If you believe I was silenced, it makes me very likely town. I've also not shared any info, so I don't appear to have a powerful town role, so I'm unlikely a kill target (plus, i look scummy as fuck and why wouldn't mafia leave me alive to take more heat?). If I had a gun to give out, I'd have given it to a player like myself - very likely town and very unlikely to be targeted for a kill.

I never suggested they give the gun to me!

And yes, it did occur to me that Buffy and im317 are likely night targets, but this is operating under the assumption that the gun giver wouldn't just get their gun back if their target died the same night. I see no reason why they wouldn't.

And even if they did, there wasn't only two confirmed townies to choose from. There was four going into last night.

im317, Buffy, Rose, Norbert.

Any of those four you could safely list as town last night. Not one of them was picked. Granted, three of them died in the space of one night, but who could have seen that coming?

All in all, I'm simply saying handle with caution!

Regarding im317 as scum, the only possibility I could see is that he is the SK and was blocked Night 1 by scum, and has been skating by with the vig claim since. I find it unlikely.

CanuckStud @ 4/11/2015 8:16

I've got to get some work done, but will check back in in a few hours. JC, please don't shoot me, as that won't help town (and I can prove it to you). I would like to know if there is anyone silenced today, or if anyone was poisoned last night. There are other possibilities for im317's kill not going through last night. I know he is holding back on his target, but it may be helpful to figure it out.

I don't see why he is holding back his target. Sounds like a scummy thing to do, so we won't be able to figure out exactly what happened. Seems like it would benefit us to know who he targeted. Or am I missing something?

Jayadamo, Redster, Henry and Canuck all have light evidence that they could be town, I'll go through what I think about them in a short moment.

There should be 2-3 mafia left which is why I'm not ruling out anyone who lynched Ari yesterday, except for Timmah and probably Curtis.

Oh and JC obviously.

Wikey @ 4/11/2015 8:36

All in all, I'm simply saying handle with caution!

You guys are so damn scared of using a gun around here. I don't get it. If I got a gun I would pull that trigger in a heartbeat. I still can't believe Curtis didn't shoot me last game. I would have shot me lol.

Right now I'm getting scum vibes from Wikey, Canuck, Dylan, and im317.

Granted, I have no fucking idea what is going on.

Day 5 Vote Count

Canuck (2/7) - Timmah, Redster

9 hours and 9 minutes left.

Redster @ 4/11/2015 11:46

Wikey @ 4/11/2015 8:36 All in all, I'm simply saying handle with caution! You guys are so damn scared of using a gun around here. I don't get it. If I got a gun I would pull that trigger in a heartbeat. I still can't believe Curtis didn't shoot me last game. I would have shot me lol.

This is a totally different situation!

Redster @ 4/11/2015 11:41

CanuckStud @ 4/11/2015 8:16 I've got to get some work done, but will check back in in a few hours. JC, please don't shoot me, as that won't help town (and I can prove it to you). I would like to know if there is anyone silenced today, or if anyone was poisoned last night. There are other possibilities for im317's kill not going through last night. I know he is holding back on his target, but it may be helpful to figure it out. I don't see why he is holding back his target. Sounds like a scummy thing to do, so we won't be able to figure out exactly what happened. Seems like it would benefit us to know who he targeted. Or am I missing something?

Yeah, it would also benefit scum to know who he targeted last night. He's doing the right thing by not saying anything, and I find it scummy you are calling for him to reveal a name.