I was writing that very manual on the wiki!!!

Then I stopped. But it has some useful stuff on there. I'll update it sometime

Also ##Lynch Ari for pressure

I'm at work on my phone so won't be able to read/post. Lot until I'm home but...

A - I have not been told anything on any of the three nights I submitted an action except to be told my action was noted.

B - I think the rules are fine but nothing is really set, it's ip to the host. We did start a mafia wiki somewhere but when new hosts show up and Use their own rules (ahimsa/schrauben) it's going to make any "general rule book" we have inaccurate anyway. That being said I don't remember finding the rules so outlandish when I started playing here and I just adapted to not always knowing every aspect of every role as I went along. I think it's more fun when you aren't spoon-fed everything anyway.

C - has im317 been seen viewing? Maybe he was silenced if that's a real thing. so far jc is the only one to say he was silenced.

Again, if you are silenced, vote to lynch me.

You should be able to post a lynch vote, as long as you don't go crazy like I did (sorry about that).

Hermlappen @ 2/11/2015 20:29

1. This game does not have a Vig and im317 claimed that and got lucky, mafia has since then targeted Vig like targets to try and make us think im317 is really a Vig. There's a reason why I think this game does not necessarily have to have a Vig.

My crazy theory: im317 kept staring at my member title and rank and then compared it to Badger's role and that is when they realized that there was probably a chance that this game had no Vigilante.

Maybe this game is to 1966 for Vigilantes?

Anyway, these are the individuals I'm tempted to lynch right now.

Ari
im317
Jayadamo
Schrauben
Henry

Redster did say he was roleblocked night 1, maybe he would say that if he was scum and maybe he wouldn't. I'm not sure.

Worst case scenario, we do what JC suggested and lynch Brian.

Maybe see if there's more than one kill Night 4 lol?

JC I believe we are waiting for im317 to show up so he can confirm or deny whether he killed Chris. Ari is our best lead today, and it depends on im's verdict whether we lynch him or not. We can't do much until he shows.

Buffy, who did you block Night 1?

Wikey @ 2/11/2015 13:48

JC I believe we are waiting for im317 to show up so he can confirm or deny whether he killed Chris. Ari is our best lead today, and it depends on im's verdict whether we lynch him or not. We can't do much until he shows. Buffy, who did you block Night 1?

And if in317 is the mafia's killer, I'm sure he'll jump right on the opportunity to come out and claim who he killed, right?

Oh wait nevermind, I see she blocked Redster. Herm does make a kind of interesting point about 317. It occurred to me that if anyone was going to be the vigilante in this game, you'd have thought it would be Batman. But that's not exactly hard evidence!

Also, lynching Brian is the equivalent of a no lynch, bad idea!

Wikey @ 2/11/2015 13:56

Also, lynching Brian is the equivalent of a no lynch, bad idea!

You're right. Sitting around and waiting all day for someone to jump on and make a fake claim, while then piling on someone at random (i.e. Primate) as the deadline approaches and losing two townies is a much better idea.

JC @ 2/11/2015 14:55

Wikey @ 2/11/2015 13:48 JC I believe we are waiting for im317 to show up so he can confirm or deny whether he killed Chris. Ari is our best lead today, and it depends on im's verdict whether we lynch him or not. We can't do much until he shows. Buffy, who did you block Night 1? And if in317 is the mafia's killer, I'm sure he'll jump right on the opportunity to come out and claim who he killed, right?

Not entirely sure what you mean...

The idea here is that im317 is the vigilante like he claims, and that Ari is the mafia's killer.

Wikey @ 2/11/2015 13:58

JC @ 2/11/2015 14:55 Wikey @ 2/11/2015 13:48 JC I believe we are waiting for im317 to show up so he can confirm or deny whether he killed Chris. Ari is our best lead today, and it depends on im's verdict whether we lynch him or not. We can't do much until he shows. Buffy, who did you block Night 1? And if in317 is the mafia's killer, I'm sure he'll jump right on the opportunity to come out and claim who he killed, right? Not entirely sure what you mean... The idea here is that im317 is the vigilante like he claims, and that Ari is the mafia's killer.

So, why can't im317 be the mafia killer? Because he claimed Vig?

And why can't Buffy be the mafia roleblocker?

It's seems a little short-sighted to be taking all these claims out of nowhere so early in the game at face value, especially when the info doesn't seem to line up.

JC @ 2/11/2015 15:01

So, why can't im317 be the mafia killer? Because he claimed Vig?

I don't think anybody is saying he can't be. In fact some of us are disputing this very thing! However right now I'd say most of us believe his claim.

JC @ 2/11/2015 15:01

And why can't Buffy be the mafia roleblocker?

We have confirmation from Brian that another roleblocker is active and blocked him last night. If this roleblocker is town, why haven't they called Buffy out?

##lynch jc just so he'll stfu

##unlynch

Sorry I couldn't help it!

I have the day off work today, so I'm able to post more. Obviously this is a bad thing. Maybe I'll take a queue from Schrauben and Redster, and just go missing for 3-4 days.