Buffy claimed she had a one-time idol yesterday, arguing that it fit the flavor. Today, she has a permanent idol, which doesn't fit the flavor at all. She's essentially claiming BP, which was kimmy's role. She has been proven to lie, and while we've been light on kills, that doesn't excuse the possibility of another third party role.

I didn't think they (GENERIC THEY AS IN ANY PGO) would, but I (AS A PGO) was.

i know what you meant, it just was funny to me. no worries, baby!

Tricks @ 28/12/2014 22:05

Buffy claimed she had a one-time idol yesterday, arguing that it fit the flavor. Today, she has a permanent idol, which doesn't fit the flavor at all. She's essentially claiming BP, which was kimmy's role. She has been proven to lie, and while we've been light on kills, that doesn't excuse the possibility of another third party role.

So if Buffy is either SK or mafia what's with the lack of having BOTH an SK and mafia hit the last several days?

maybe my blocks have just been that amazing.

except for the time that i myself was blocked.

Brian who did you block perilous two nights? (I know you posted it but I am on my phone etc)

Alright, whatever. Lynch me if you want but I'm not a killer. Christian is, though. Here are some of the posts I reviewed of his:

Starting with Day 2:

Spoiler

+

Quote I feel a little responsible for im317 being lynched, since I was the first vote on him, but I didn't expect a train to build on him. I went with a quiet player yesterday...today I probably won't make the same kind of choice. Why say you voted someone but didn't expect a train to build? It sounds very scummy...like why vote someone if you don't want a train to build on them? Quote If I'm looking at suspects, the first person I'll be keeping one eye on is Herm. Something about the way he was going about trying to not put Craig at risk of being lynched. What does this even mean? You're going to keep an eye on him but not vote him, I guess. Then a few minutes later reverses it. Quote But then Herm did have a vote on Matt at one point, so maybe he was just voting for a quieter player like I did. Doesn't mean he wasn't still trying to protect Craig, who I'd be open to voting for today. And Aries voted for Matt, so that does that possibly at least clear Matt of being mafia? He also talks about Matt being cleared as town. Matt dies that night and then he keeps FOSing Animal for the kill (which I'll get to later).

Day 3:

Spoiler

+

Quote Animal, why was your vote on Matt yesterday when a few people suggested Aries being on his train at the end of Day 1 made him more than likely Town? Example of starting his FOS on Animal. Again, this is the one thing that kept bugging me about Animal being SK. But the way Christian keeps dropping these little hints but never votes him makes me think Christian could be SK and wants to keep Animal around as a suspect. Quote Is it odd that with both Moose and *kimmy in the hot seat yesterday and continuing into today, that there's not even been a hint of a claim from either? What should we make of that, if anything? This is a genuine question about their behaviour, I'm not fishing. Fishing but then making a point of saying he's not fishing. Quote I'm also looking at Animal right now for his Matt vote yesterday. But when I think about it, if he were scum, it wouldn't make sense for him to be on someone that a couple people, including myself, felt was likely Town. Would it? Another FOS about Animal possibly killing Matt but then backing off quickly. Just says enough to make people suspicious but he's not the one doing the lynching and being wrong.

Day 4:

Spoiler

+

Quote It takes 11 votes for majority, we're still a ways away from that. I led the train on Day 2, I want to make sure I get a seat on this one. ##Lynch Moose And I definitely have feelings about Animal being scum. Wants to get a seat to make sure he looks really town and also points out he led the train on Day 2. This points to possibly being Moose's scum buddy. Quote Also, I was disappointed that Brian didn't say much earlier, but he said I would be. Fishing for Brian's info. Quote After Moose, I've got my eye on Animal. There's that eye again.

Day 5:

Spoiler

+

Quote Well that's a relief. I was half-expecting to not be alive today. I'm thinking there had to be some of the mafia who were okay with losing Moose yesterday due to her having no special abilities... Animal, are you one of them? This really struck me because why does Christian think he's going to be attacked with all the people who have claimed/soft-claimed? It just looks like a way to say - "Hey, I'm town and I'm sure I'll be attacked, especially with my suspicion of Animal." Again, FOS of Animal but doesn't vote him. Quote It's kind of weird that there were 3 deaths the night before and 0 last night. Could be some were role-blocked? Does anyone know if someone survived an attack, would the flavour reveal that? Christian definitely knows if someone survived an attack it would be in the flavor. I think he was either blocked and or he something and is trying to find out who did it. Quote maybe someone has the ability to cancel all night actions? Or this. Maybe that's what happened and he knows because he tried to kill someone, and he's trying to find out who did it, obviously. Quote Hey Greenday, you were one of two votes yesterday not on Moose. Still thinking Vernon is scum? I'll admit, he looks a little suspect by lynching half the cast before he finally got around to lynching Moose. Subtly trying to get Vernon lynched even though he was going to "look at" Animal this day? Brian: Quote ##lynch greenday ignorance ain't cute Christian: Quote Does this have anything to do with the information you alluded to earlier? Fishing again. Quote Moose (11/11) - Rose, Buffy, Kiwi, Animal, Christian, Kat, Tony, Tricks, Vernon, Chris, Moose I'm not 100% certain, but I get Town reads from the first 3 people on this train, and I know I am. I got up out of bed to made sure I lynched Moose. If I were to guess, we might find scum among these people: Animal Kat Tony Tricks Vernon Chris Again making sure everyone knows he got out of bed to lynch Moose. Quote What if we cross reference the possible scum on the Day 4 Moose train with the possible scum on the Day 3 Kimmy train? Day 3 *kimmy (5/13) - Moose, dr, Animal, Vernon, Patrick, Buffy, Tony, Chris Day 4 Moose (11/11) - Rose, Buffy, Kiwi, Animal, Christian, Kat, Tony, Tricks, Vernon, Chris, Moose Let's knock Moose off the lists. That leaves Vernon, Tony and Chris on both of these trains. Could be one of these people wanted to try to save Moose on Day 3, and then on Day 4 realized Moose was too far gone to be saved, and jumped on her train to make themselves look good when she flipped mafia. Animal was on Kimmy's but unlynched to join Tony's train but the day ended as he was about to jump on. At least that's what he's told us. If that is true, then either Animal or Tony is scum, or they're both Town. Animal unlynching from kimmy whether he was going to lynch Tony or not, put Tony at risk because he had 3 votes at the time. So I don't know about Animal. It's the scumminess of his posts that I can't shake, but I'm willing to go a different route today. I believe Animal when he said he wasn't here in time to lynch Tony so this just looks like another attempt to make Animal look bad. Quote And I'm still suspicious about Animal as well. It's just a feeling I can't seem to shake. Sorry, Animal. Again, suspicion of Animal but doesn't vote him.

I'll get to Day 6 later.

Quote

Alright, whatever. Lynch me if you want but I'm not a killer.

interesting wording here

Guys, I don't even care that much if I'm lynched as long as you look hard at Christian before you do it. I'm lynching him, he's scum, and I think you should make him claim or at least question him. I won't even be around tomorrow until the last hour or so, so this is going to be a pointless day if no one even looks at anyone besides me.

Night 1: 3 deaths (including CL)
Night 2: 2 deaths (including Vig)
Night 3: 3 deaths
Night 4: No deaths, no survivals
Night 5: No deaths, 1 survival
Night 6: 1 death, 1 survival

So Night 1, I see a Vig death, a scum death, and likely Curtis recruiting incorrectly
Night 2 is a vig death and a scum death
Night 3, here I'm not sure since vig is now dead, perhaps Shadow shot the gun and a scum death, not sure about the third
Night 4, Lamps must've been sent for the kill, Brian blocked and thus no kills went through
Night 5, only one attack
Night 6 a PGO and scum attack

All signs point to no SK in the game due to only one scum attack nightly with day 3 being the only question

Patrick @ 28/12/2014 22:17

Quote Alright, whatever. Lynch me if you want but I'm not a killer. interesting wording here

Why Patrick? Who are your suspects, btw? You're someone who's been very utr, not really saying anything and I think it's impossible to get a read on you.

The Anti-Kiwifruit @ 28/12/2014 22:12

Brian who did you block perilous two nights? (I know you posted it but I am on my phone etc)

i didn't say who i tried to block when it didn't work, and dunno if i should..?

night 1: no one
night 2: herm
night 3: raptor
night 4: lamps
night 5: i was blocked
night 6: buffy

Christian is also scum. It's just a matter of who today and who tomorrow.

Tony and Samm are next on my suspect list.

itsbrianyay @ 28/12/2014 22:21

The Anti-Kiwifruit @ 28/12/2014 22:12 Brian who did you block perilous two nights? (I know you posted it but I am on my phone etc) i didn't say who i tried to block when it didn't work, and dunno if i should..?

This is the second time you've said this and I fail to see why this is the case.

Greensday @ 28/12/2014 22:18

Night 1: 3 deaths (including CL) Night 2: 2 deaths (including Vig) Night 3: 3 deaths Night 4: No deaths, no survivals Night 5: No deaths, 1 survival Night 6: 1 death, 1 survival So Night 1, I see a Vig death, a scum death, and likely Curtis recruiting incorrectly Night 2 is a vig death and a scum death Night 3, here I'm not sure since vig is now dead, perhaps Shadow shot the gun and a scum death, not sure about the third Night 4, Lamps must've been sent for the kill, Brian blocked and thus no kills went through Night 5, only one attack Night 6 a PGO and scum attack All signs point to no SK in the game due to only one scum attack nightly with day 3 being the only question

No it doesn't. Craig was killed Night 2 so one of those deaths can't be him. And you didn't include the day kill on Angi, instead you put it on Night 3 for some reason? With three kills, I'm sure at least 2 have to be from mafia/sk.