also sry about lack of being here I was travelling to Florida ayyyyy

Sorry I wasn't super active at 4AM! I'm here now :P

Going back through the day 1 thread now.

dr @ 18/12/2014 11:25

Who do you find more scummy at the moment?

Again, my reads aren't great (they really never are though), but I'm thinking kimmy. As others have pointed out, she's really just parroting already established things much more than anything else. It might be her newness, but ever since Moose turned up mafia during her first game after repeatedly pointing out that she was new, I tend to take "learning the ropes" with a grain of salt

I'll go out and agree with what some others have said about Craig, in that he's probably town. He's being pretty candid with his thoughts which is the best you can ask for from town at this point.

As for scummiest? I would say Herm. He was the last vote to switch yesterday that saved Matt, and gave no reason. I know we were going for inactives then but he just simply unlynched and lynched.

##lynch Herm

Do you think Matt is scum? I got a town vibe from Craig, which is why I switched from Matt to im317.

Craig had the second most votes and he would've been the top lynch.

pretty sure Aries was the only mafia on my train. Lamps had an okay reason for picking me as a first vote and it's not exactly out there that Samm hopped on. I didn't like Angi's reasoning but obviously she was town. Not entirely sure about Herm so I would be okay for his lynching but I'm still eh about that. And Craig was on basically every train so there's not a lot to go on there!

Ayyyyyyy

I mean the main reason I went for you Wikey was because at the time you were inactive. Then you became active, and I tossed my vote aside. I didn't want to lynch a contributor day 1 and you became a contributor, and that's what caused my vote to change.

As for who mafia is...

honestly I mean, there's gonna be a few people who just straight up dont talk and I'd rather focus on them. At least, until we get some real information going. The people that talk are our biggest asset.

Also, I put up a point about 'what if Aries silenced someone'. That's big into my like, mindset, only because I've been thinking about lynching inactives but what if an active just cannot talk.

If you're silenced, like this post.

Anyways, uh yeah. Get a bad read on Kimmy because she got a little defensive however I do think the original reasoning was kinda crumby to go for her. I personally don't think herm is mafia. Why are there votes on DD?

Hermarajah @ 18/12/2014 13:07

Craig had the second most votes and he would've been the top lynch.

Um, no. Before you unlynched/relynched it was 4-Matt 3-im 2-Craig. If anything it would've been a no-lynch if you simply unlynched, which is also not good but regardless

I don't buy Herm as scum

Patrick's been around but hasn't posted. Was he silenced?

I believe I mentioned in the Day 1 thread that I haven't played mafia in a very long time and this is pretty much the first time that I'm actually playing with you guys and learning how you guys play. I used to play on a different forum a long time ago and we played it different from this.

If you're all going off by this whole "agreeing with someone" else thing then I could say that it's scummy that Ari, Herm and Samm are all defensive about Craig being scum and all "agreeing".

I don't think Kimmy is scum at the moment, but her getting really defensive could bite her in the butt. I wouldn't really lynch her for right now, but that would change. I still feel Herm could possibly be scum, but it's not much to go on, seeing as other people switched up their votes.

lol I remember, getting all defensive was usually my downfall in these games.

Anyways, I don't think Ari could be scum since he did vote to lynch Aries on Day 1, he could be the Vig or something OR, he could just threw a vote to Aries to throw us off because that random DD lynch looks scummy

Craig is unusually vocal on Day 1 so that makes me think he's town. If he was scum I doubt he'd jump from person to person so much. Scum would play things more cautiously.

I don't buy DD as scum either, it feels like a random lynch train that picked up randomally to get him to talk?

As for the deaths, the only one I'm curious about is Angi's death. It seems so out of the blue and in the middle of the day as well. I'm sure as hell ain't going out for a swim after that.