Colby (2/6) - Panda, Rob, Patrick
Vic (1/6) - Panda
Panda (3/6) - Colby, Vic, Patrick, Animal, Paco
Rob (1/6) - Colby
Jeff (2/6) - Rob, Paco
Patrick (1/6) - Panda

im317 @ 26/12/2013 14:12

Justin, Paco, and Vic can any of you confirm that you were visited by Colby and told by Samm that he was town?

I can confirm this

Oh oops didn't see Colby was modkilled when I posted that

:|

Samm that's a bit cold blooded to do in someones first game.

Patrick @ 26/12/2013 16:54

so people should know that colby is town I am the sleepwalker. I visit at night, and do nothing.

who have you visited?

this is such a shit show

##Lynch Rob because I dont even know

Patrick @ 26/12/2013 14:39

Santa Smurf @ 26/12/2013 13:36 im317 @ 26/12/2013 13:21 wait, if it really is a SKer then why are we lynching Panda? the entire premise behind lynching Panda is that he is mafia. Hmm good point though at this stage with this wacky game who the hell knows. Then again I think the challenge role or whatever it's proper name is sounds more town than mafia ##unlynch perry Unless someone can remind me of another reason why others think he's mafia I think it was just because he forced the "challenge" and all of the mafia saved him. But like it has been said, if we think we're only searching for the SK then I guess it couldn't be Perry since he's shown his role.

I don't think we're "only" looking for an SK, unless I'm missing something, we don't actually know if the last standing if a mafia member or an SK. I just think it's fishy that all of the mafia members jumped to his rescue to save him…

also can't tell if Patrick asking Colby to out himself was a ploy to modkill another townie in order to get the game closer to being over for a scum victory, or if I'm over thinking at this point

*sigh* shitshow is an understatement. I'm staying on Jeff as my last suspect regarding the inactive SK theory.

And I've caved at this point regarding Rob. I guess the whole resurrect as scum would fit too.

##lynch Rob again

im317 @ 26/12/2013 17:29

Samm that's a bit cold blooded to do in someones first game. Patrick @ 26/12/2013 16:54 so people should know that colby is town I am the sleepwalker. I visit at night, and do nothing. who have you visited?

It is random. I have no clue.

Santa Smurf @ 26/12/2013 17:41

*sigh* shitshow is an understatement. I'm staying on Jeff as my last suspect regarding the inactive SK theory. And I've caved at this point regarding Rob. I guess the whole resurrect as scum would fit too. ##lynch Rob again

there were 2 kills night 2, Rob wasn't killed and resurrected until day 3.

##lynch Nobert/Jeff

nothing special about him but i have narrowed it down to 3 possibles and im conflicted between the other 2 and want to wait before using my other vote

im317 @ 26/12/2013 18:13

Santa Smurf @ 26/12/2013 17:41 *sigh* shitshow is an understatement. I'm staying on Jeff as my last suspect regarding the inactive SK theory. And I've caved at this point regarding Rob. I guess the whole resurrect as scum would fit too. ##lynch Rob again there were 2 kills night 2, Rob wasn't killed and resurrected until day 3. ##lynch Nobert/Jeff nothing special about him but i have narrowed it down to 3 possibles and im conflicted between the other 2 and want to wait before using my other vote

Who are the other two?

im317 @ 26/12/2013 19:13

Santa Smurf @ 26/12/2013 17:41 *sigh* shitshow is an understatement. I'm staying on Jeff as my last suspect regarding the inactive SK theory. And I've caved at this point regarding Rob. I guess the whole resurrect as scum would fit too. ##lynch Rob again there were 2 kills night 2, Rob wasn't killed and resurrected until day 3. ##lynch Nobert/Jeff nothing special about him but i have narrowed it down to 3 possibles and im conflicted between the other 2 and want to wait before using my other vote

good catch, didn't notice the 2 kills on night 2. I didn't really think he was mac/scum anyway but that helps me narrow it down between Jeff/Rob (my first suspect is still Perry)

##Lynch Nobert

maf/scum****

stupid. mac. autocorrect.

Patrick @ 26/12/2013 18:27

im317 @ 26/12/2013 18:13 Santa Smurf @ 26/12/2013 17:41 *sigh* shitshow is an understatement. I'm staying on Jeff as my last suspect regarding the inactive SK theory. And I've caved at this point regarding Rob. I guess the whole resurrect as scum would fit too. ##lynch Rob again there were 2 kills night 2, Rob wasn't killed and resurrected until day 3. ##lynch Nobert/Jeff nothing special about him but i have narrowed it down to 3 possibles and im conflicted between the other 2 and want to wait before using my other vote Who are the other two?

i will say at the end of the day, want to see how they react first

Colby (2/6) - Panda, Rob, Patrick
Vic (0/6) - Panda
Panda (2/6) - Colby, Vic, Patrick, Animal, Paco
Rob (2/6) - Colby, Vic, Paco
Jeff (4/6) - Rob, Paco, Animal, im317
Patrick (1/6) - Panda

^ I think this is updated. I think Perry unlynched Vic but IDK for sure.

I really think Perry/Jeff are the right choices right now, especially with what im317 said about Rob (Admittedly, I started doubting Rob when everyone who FOS'd him wound up dead), but there were 2 kills in night 2, and if that's still unexplained, then we prob have an SKer on our hands. That wouldn't explain why the mafia all saved Perry, BUT if we have 1 more mafia member AND an SKer then I think Perry is our mafia member and the lesser-active yet still apparently SKer could be Nobert.

Rob was town when there were 2 kills in night 2, so he can't be SK.

(That is, IF that kill is still unaccounted for. Gonna go back and check it out.)

#MyTwoCents