Did ahoda claim

I think i lean towards Jaimie but I'm not sure

rager Ꞧ¿Ø»Ȿ„Ǝ—drrr @ 20/7/2023 23:33

Did ahoda claim I think i lean towards Jaimie but I'm not sure

i think he claimed targets for the first 3 nights? including an oddity with picking the same person on consecutive nights. it would have been day 4

Day 6 Vote count:
Jamie (2/5) - Shadow, im317,
Stargate (1/5) - Ahoda

Day 6 KEVIN Count:

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to hammer. Deadline for the Day 6 vote is Friday (7/21) at 8.00 PM EST.

I have to agree with Stargate about the danger of the cult and I also have to agree with the logic that cult would've been very unlikely to vote for Farlig. With Rose basically guaranteed town, that leaves us with Ahoda, Jamie, Stargate, or me.

If it's Stargate, I think they've been breaking the maxim, "Never interrupt your enemy when they are making a mistake". I just don't think they were cult when they started those arguments, which would rule them out as recruiter. If they are, then good game, well played. I guess it's worth mentioning that we know Stargate was blocked one night, which would reduce maximum cult size by 1. If Stargate is recruiter we wouldn't immediately lose on a mis-lynch (although we could lose overnight).

That leaves Ahoda, Jamie or me.

For me:
I don't think anybody is doubting I have nexus power at this point. A few people have suggested that Nav might combine nexus with cult recruiter. To me, that strikes me as a ridiculously overpowered combination of powers. A cult recruiter that cannot be killed at night, cannot be blocked and can't even be investigated because everything bounces off of them and goes somewhere else? I'm sure you could come up with ways to weaken it (like you have to choose between cult or nexus), but you kind of have to stretch to make it work. If someone says they can't totally eliminate me as a suspect, I get that, but to suggest I'm the most likely candidate doesn't really make sense to me. I'm the one suspect that we have guaranteed has a power other than recruiting.

Ahoda:
Ahoda is a weird one. They've been rather vague about their actual powers, but also in a genuine way. One thing that is a bit strange is that they chose to reveal their night visits when they had visited Curtis on n2. I would think they would worry about getting falsely accused of something and ultimately this piece of info is what led to Farlig suggesting Shadow as a suspect. But, if they were in cahoots, there would be no need to do that. Farlig could have just omitted Ahoda's visit and nobody would be any the wiser. Also, Ahoda immediately undermined that information, so like, what in the world are Ahoda and Farlig trying to accomplish if they were both cult? I do have in my notes that Jamie, Stargate and I all argued with Rodney pretty clearly and don't have that for Ahoda. I don't think that's conclusive at all though, cult recruiter could easily stage an argument.

That leaves Jamie:
First, the obvious elephant in the room. JJ, as speaker for the mafia, has pinned it on Jamie. Now, obviously the mafia could be lying or have bad info. But, it's pretty clear that the mafia's biggest threat to winning is the cult, so they would have a vested interest in taking down the cult recruiter. Weigh that as you will, but it's the same reason why I thought Farlig was likely telling the truth about JJ. It did make sense for JJ to reveal the best name they have.

Jamie's claimed role (of commuter) is interesting. On the one hand, it would explain the lack of information they can provide. But on the other hand, it would be a rather convenient role for the cult recruiter to claim. Basically, "Don't try to kill me at night, because you can't". (Yes, I realize you could make a similar argument about Nexus, but I'm actually verified to have Nexus power.)

Finally, we have to consider Stargate's argument about not piling on votes too early because scum could use that to win. I'll just point out that Jaime already has 2 votes on them. The fact that cult hasn't piled enough votes on them to hammer suggests either:

A.) Jaime is cult OR
B.) Cult doesn't have enough votes to pile on because:
B1.) The votes for Jaime are already from cult members (but Shadow and im317 voted for Farlig) OR
B2.) The cult is small

If I have to choose (and I suppose I will have to), I choose Jaime.

Also, just wanted to raise this from before:

Kat @ 20/7/2023 06:18

I was smoked last night. Did we ever find out who does that? I am too tired to look through previous days if there information was revealed.

im317 and Rose both claimed to have blocked JJ. Not necessarily suspicious because of Herm's role though.

My role is called Beguiler

3 times during the game I can pick someone and if I'm attacked/killed that person will die instead.

Hence my claim siy info was out there. Like I said, there's a chance curtis was scum and mafia janitored themselves

I also haven't been culled but I can't prove that. It's painfully obvious that I have been culted through D4 though.

##unvoted


Do think stargtaae has said enough to make me think he's not recruiter though.

Jamie or jed

I'll have to rethink qhere to go.

Commuter vs nexus claim

Day 6 Vote count:
Jamie (2/5) - Shadow, im317,
Stargate (0/5) - Ahoda

Day 6 KEVIN Count:

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to hammer. Deadline for the Day 6 vote is Friday (7/21) at 8.00 PM EST.

I’ll reiterate, everyone thinks it’s me and that should tell you cult has a large enough size that they can pin this on me to get a mislynch and then win shortly after. Mafia also thinks it’s me so at this point idk what I can do. Lamps reloader role is in the game for a reason and I was one of those reasons, I’m only an x-shot.

##vote Jed

Anyone else notice stargates little scum slip? or was that just me

jamie @ 21/7/2023 6:04

Anyone else notice stargates little scum slip? or was that just me

which

rager Ꞧ¿Ø»Ȿ„Ǝ—drrr @ 21/7/2023 10:21

jamie @ 21/7/2023 6:04 Anyone else notice stargates little scum slip? or was that just me which

mobile is too hard to quote and erase his novels so here is a copy paste

Quote

But if you think I'm the recruiter, how do my actions on D1 and D2 track with me recruiting Rodney when he was one of my top scumspects (lol when he was still town

we don’t know when rodney was town vs cult but stargate seems to know when he was town

??

I was talking about how I suspected him of being scum d1, Jamie. A day he couldn't have been recruited.

##kevin stargate
##vote jamie