Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:57

Helios Garabandia @ 9/4/2017 16:56 Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:51 Basically the PM I got just restated that I watched Herm and then said I returned to find my reports burned. That was the order. Maybe Herm was watching you watching him? So my reports burned? I don't know what sense that would make. Wouldn't I just get a PM that said "you saw Herm visit you?"

Wouldn't that be Tracker? Or am I getting Watcher and Tracker confused again?

Herm @ 9/4/2017 9:44

I don't think my role would cause that. It helps against certain scum actions, which is why I targeted her.

Herm @ 9/4/2017 9:44

It's a protective role.

Doesn't outright say he protects from kills, so what else is there?

Herm @ 9/4/2017 10:25

CherryBerry @ 9/4/2017 15:47 Herm @ 9/4/2017 10:44 I don't think my role would cause that. It helps against certain scum actions, which is why I targeted her. Can you confirm with Brian or Tom? I could, but both my actions are submitted so the information is all here. If I had targeted someone else, I'm not sure Maddie's condition would change. If someone else hadn't messed with her she should've been able to see me visit her.

Both actions?

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:51

Basically the PM I got just restated that I watched Herm and then said I returned to find my reports burned. That was the order.

Watched or tracked?

farlig @ 9/4/2017 17:00

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:51 Basically the PM I got just restated that I watched Herm and then said I returned to find my reports burned. That was the order. Watched or tracked?

Sorry tracked**

Helios Garabandia @ 9/4/2017 16:58

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:57 Helios Garabandia @ 9/4/2017 16:56 Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:51 Basically the PM I got just restated that I watched Herm and then said I returned to find my reports burned. That was the order. Maybe Herm was watching you watching him? So my reports burned? I don't know what sense that would make. Wouldn't I just get a PM that said "you saw Herm visit you?" Wouldn't that be Tracker? Or am I getting Watcher and Tracker confused again?

No you're right I meant tracked--made that mistake twice.

Aries @ 9/4/2017 18:49

I asked Timmah the other day why he survived... don't think he ever answered me though. Besides a soft BP claim, nothing else came of it.

so is there anyone you find suspicious?

Last person that confused the two was...

Skipped 7 pages, gonna take some time to catch up.

Helios still lynch leader?

I think maybe Herm bussed Maddie with someone?

So he was protecting her by redirecting actions towards her onto someone else. Hence two actions and hence helping against scum roles

##Unlynch

##Lynch Aries

Going back to my roots.

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 17:02

I think maybe Herm bussed Maddie with someone? So he was protecting her by redirecting actions towards her onto someone else. Hence two actions and hence helping against scum roles

This theory explains a lot, actually.

Timmah (4) - Vic, Chris, Vlady, Nofo, Curtis, Zersch
Helios (3) - Lamps, Maddie, Cherry
Aries (2) - Christian, Zersch, Zersch
Spin (1) - DS
Vic (1) - Spin
TIB (1) - Jamie
Herm (0) - Angi
Christian (0) - Angi, Spin

Day 2 Sock voters not voting today:
Merc, Herm, Helios, farlig, Primate, Timmah, Aries, im317

farlig @ 9/4/2017 17:02

Last person that confused the two was...

To be honest I am still confused what the different between tracker and watcher is. I'm pretty new to mafia still.

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 17:05

farlig @ 9/4/2017 17:02 Last person that confused the two was... To be honest I am still confused what the different between tracker and watcher is. I'm pretty new to mafia still.

I'm assuming watcher sees who visits them? Tracker sees who they visit? Nvm answers my own Q.

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 19:02

I think maybe Herm bussed Maddie with someone? So he was protecting her by redirecting actions towards her onto someone else. Hence two actions and hence helping against scum roles

But would bussing really be protective?