Basically the PM I got just restated that I watched Herm and then said I returned to find my reports burned. That was the order.

Zersch @ 9/4/2017 18:51

Christian @ 9/4/2017 18:50 Aries @ 9/4/2017 18:45 Zersch @ 9/4/2017 19:41 But Aries... speak to us in a language we can hear, please. snakker dere norsk? why did you pass by my request but answered Zersch's? Christian actually Cena confirmed????

okay, even I don't get this reference! lol

What about Hermes?

Christian @ 9/4/2017 18:52

Zersch @ 9/4/2017 18:51 Christian @ 9/4/2017 18:50 Aries @ 9/4/2017 18:45 Zersch @ 9/4/2017 19:41 But Aries... speak to us in a language we can hear, please. snakker dere norsk? why did you pass by my request but answered Zersch's? Christian actually Cena confirmed???? okay, even I don't get this reference! lol

(She couldn't see you.)

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 18:51

Just re-read Timmah's D2 posts. They don't really strike me as scummy actually. His logic for who to focus on in terms of what they're doing regarding his survival is pretty sound, it all makes sense to me I'm sorta afraid he could just be Town Doc who protected himself N1 tbh I'm thinking it might be better to hold off since he isn't around. I don't feel solid ENOUGH to risk lynching him when he's not here and could be Doc, because really after re-reading I don't think he did anything necessarily sketchy other than survive the attack I know I just lynched him but ##Unlynch

I had the same thoughts. I think lynching him when he's not here is a bad idea.

Timmah said he knows why he was saved. If you take him for his word (which, I know, if he's scum then you shouldn't,) but if you take him for his word, it's more likely than not part of his role and therefore not something Herm was responsible for.

I have a gut feeling Timmah was the mafia target N1.

If we're assuming Timmah is town doc then that would mean Herm has to be evil right? Would town have two protective roles?

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:51

Basically the PM I got just restated that I watched Herm and then said I returned to find my reports burned. That was the order.

Maybe Herm was watching you watching him?

Vic @ 9/4/2017 15:55

If we're assuming Timmah is town doc then that would mean Herm has to be evil right? Would town have two protective roles?

Just want to note that NoFo also visited me and Zersch but has said that he doesnt have an investigative role.

Herm could be some sorta bodyguard. Protects the target but also blocks them

Did he say he had nothing to do with the burning up thing?

Helios Garabandia @ 9/4/2017 16:56

Maddie @ 9/4/2017 18:51 Basically the PM I got just restated that I watched Herm and then said I returned to find my reports burned. That was the order. Maybe Herm was watching you watching him?

So my reports burned? I don't know what sense that would make. Wouldn't I just get a PM that said "you saw Herm visit you?"

Herm also had that weird lone vote on Wikey on Day 1, which seemed like he didn't want his vote to actually make a difference. The next day he said he found others most scummy (after Mittens flipped) or something like that, I'll have to look back.

Vic @ 9/4/2017 18:55

If we're assuming Timmah is town doc then that would mean Herm has to be evil right? Would town have two protective roles?

More than one of the same town role is absolutely a thing, so I don't see it as impossible that Timmah and Herm could both be town protective roles.

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 16:57

Herm could be some sorta bodyguard. Protects the target but also blocks them Did he say he had nothing to do with the burning up thing?

Yeah he said his role has nothing to do with fire or burning.

He said he didn't know what happened with it being burned up

He said he has a protective role but I still think a bodyguard and doctor is unlikely