Primate @ 10/8/2019 15:36

Cavin @ 10/8/2019 14:34 Primate @ 10/8/2019 15:32 Switching to an inactive over caught scum is a terrible move imo Im not caught scum though. You would know this if you submitted last night. How convenient for you that I didn't

It is actually incredibly inconvenient.

Herm @ 10/8/2019 14:35

Cavin @ 10/8/2019 21:33 I dont really understand Herm unvoting if he thinks Josh is scum? If people think I'm scum, they are going to hesitate to be on the same lynch train as me lol.

To me it just reads as you wanted credit for being on the josh train without actually voting him towards a lynch.

Day 4 Lynch Count:

Cavin (6/8) - Penner, Primate, Nav, Josh, Cody, Lamps
Josh (2/8) - Wikey, Cavin, Herm
TIB (1/8) - Mittens
Herm (0/8) - Lamps
Cody (0/8) - Nav
Nav (0/8) - Cody

Day ends today 7:30pm EST.

Primate @ 10/8/2019 15:35

With nexus and all the failed actions, I think a scum redirect is a crazy longshot.

So why arent we missing a kill on N1 when Penner saw me go nowhere?

Cavin @ 10/8/2019 15:39

Primate @ 10/8/2019 15:35 With nexus and all the failed actions, I think a scum redirect is a crazy longshot. So why arent we missing a kill on N1 when Penner saw me go nowhere?

Because you are mafia and your team didn’t send you out for the kill?

Like if you actually piece together the information we have - multiple unsuccessful claims (to which I was the first to report that), the mafia joat not having any redirectional abilities etc it makes sense for Mafia to have a redirector.

Fuck this is frustrating. I'm trying really hard. I know I submitted on Farlig last night.

Timmah @ 10/8/2019 15:41

Cavin @ 10/8/2019 15:39 Primate @ 10/8/2019 15:35 With nexus and all the failed actions, I think a scum redirect is a crazy longshot. So why arent we missing a kill on N1 when Penner saw me go nowhere? Because you are mafia and your team didn’t send you out for the kill?

I'm not mafia. I totally called Buffy out on her slip yesterday which led to the hard push there by Cody.

I think I believe Cavin? But it’s so hard to tell.

I kind of think lynching Cavin gives us the most info though. If he’s town then we surely know there’s a redirector. And then that nav is scum :)

If he’s scum then. We know there ISNT a redirector.

Except we haven’t seen any evidence of a redirector have we? We saw the nexus get used, and some unsuccessful actions. None of that says redirector. Now you’re seen at the scene of the crime and suddenly there’s a redirector instead of the more likely explanation that you’re scum?

Day ends at 7:30pm tonight.

I may have been saying 7pm in some of the vote counts.

Cavin @ 10/8/2019 22:38

Herm @ 10/8/2019 14:35 Cavin @ 10/8/2019 21:33 I dont really understand Herm unvoting if he thinks Josh is scum? If people think I'm scum, they are going to hesitate to be on the same lynch train as me lol. To me it just reads as you wanted credit for being on the josh train without actually voting him towards a lynch.

If a join a lynch, then no one else will jump on. The disadvantage of being read as scum by most of the players is that your lynch vote becomes very ineffective lol.

It probably reads a certain way, but we can't get Josh lynched with me on the train lol.

Cody @ 10/8/2019 15:45

I think I believe Cavin? But it’s so hard to tell. I kind of think lynching Cavin gives us the most info though. If he’s town then we surely know there’s a redirector. And then that nav is scum :) If he’s scum then. We know there ISNT a redirector.

Lynch the chicken to know it lays eggs.

lmfao

Timmah @ 10/8/2019 15:46

Except we haven’t seen any evidence of a redirector have we? We saw the nexus get used, and some unsuccessful actions. None of that says redirector. Now you’re seen at the scene of the crime and suddenly there’s a redirector instead of the more likely explanation that you’re scum?

I mean, this is evidence of a redirector to me. Obviously I have information that you dont have which is what I've been fighting against all day.

Herm @ 10/8/2019 15:49

Cavin @ 10/8/2019 22:38 Herm @ 10/8/2019 14:35 Cavin @ 10/8/2019 21:33 I dont really understand Herm unvoting if he thinks Josh is scum? If people think I'm scum, they are going to hesitate to be on the same lynch train as me lol. To me it just reads as you wanted credit for being on the josh train without actually voting him towards a lynch. If a join a lynch, then no one else will jump on. The disadvantage of being read as scum by most of the players is that your lynch vote becomes very ineffective lol. It probably reads a certain way, but we can't get Josh lynched with me on the train lol.

So, you're just not going to lynch people then? To gain town cred you need to lynch scum.

Cody @ 10/8/2019 21:45

I think I believe Cavin? But it’s so hard to tell. I kind of think lynching Cavin gives us the most info though. If he’s town then we surely know there’s a redirector. And then that nav is scum :) If he’s scum then. We know there ISNT a redirector.

Well we should not be lynching for the most info. We should lynch scum, which in right in front of everyone with TIB but ppl usually feel that it is lazy/too easy to lynch inactives past D2, even if it is 100% their scum tell.