I'm only a month late on this, but here goes, simply from memory, so I'm sure I'll screw it all up.
HALL OF FAME
Nav -- Had very good town reads, including listing all four mafia members in his scum list on D2.
Ahoda -- Found scum Josh on N1 and drew the scum block on N2. Played a pretty good under-the-radar town cop.
Other town -- Steamrolled over the mafia. Only had one mislynch (D1).
HALL OF MOD MISTAKES
Spin -- Making im317's priming of people roleblockable was a mistake, and he should have been able to prime anyone he wanted without impunity. It's hard enough to win as a SK/Arsonist.
HALL OF LAME
im317 -- He was the best town cop out there, priming (or attempting) mafia both N1 and N2. However, taking out the mafia is never the best strategy for what's essentially a fancy survivor.
Town on D3 -- simply for lynching an unsuspecting SK/Arsonist for no reason at all, taking out one of my favorite twists too early.
Mafia in general -- maybe it was bad luck, or it was scummy play (I honestly don't remember), but your four members were investigated (N1), primed (N1 and should have been N2), killed (N2 and D3), and lynched (D2, D4). Town steamrolled over you, which was totally against the setup ;)
HALL OF DS
DS -- Killed Spider N2 (good), but also killed dr N3 (very bad). Also led the lynch train on the asteroid, claiming im317 was scum (bad). | 
