Rose FOS's her own post.

Helios is generally against no lynches by policy, so it's something he's always going to complain about. I'd argue it came off as a bit of an ARGUMENT CRUTCH yesterday, where we had a mechanic introduced to us that made a no lynch more useful

Buffy @ 5/1/2019 21:02

Rose FOS's her own post.

i went to reread what i said and shriveled up a little inside

scamdar pinging bright red, even though i know exactly what i am and its not scum

Jestdrrr @ 5/1/2019 20:04

Helios is generally against no lynches by policy, so it's something he's always going to complain about. I'd argue it came off as a bit of an ARGUMENT CRUTCH yesterday, where we had a mechanic introduced to us that made a no lynch more useful

Ah, okay. Yesterday was my first time learning about the no lynch thing. I need to go back over the day to see if anything stands out to me cus I felt that the day was spent mostly shitposting and talking about the no lynch.

Jestdrrr @ 5/1/2019 20:57

Christian @ 5/1/2019 20:16 I agreed with Spin about the Helios tradition of voting the third voter. It gives no information to look back on, no matter how Helios or the third voter eventually flip. I only agreed with Helios' stance on the no-lynch yesterday. Hopefully Rose will have more time for us today, and brings any leftover birthday cake. hello i have more time but not that much because its the weekend

and the cake?

I still find it funny Helios doesn't understand how his 3rd-vote thing contradicts his absolutely-not-no-lynch thing.

That, plus Ahoda was sort of his counter-train, is what gives me slight scum vibes. Guess we wait to see what he says when he shows up.

Christian @ 5/1/2019 18:49

Yikes. Josh lost Shawn Mendes already....

I'm sure Josh has plenty of Shawn Mendes. Hell, he can have all of mine. Might make listening to the radio a tad bit more tolerable.

Spin @ 5/1/2019 21:12

I still find it funny Helios doesn't understand how his 3rd-vote thing contradicts his absolutely-not-no-lynch thing. That, plus Ahoda was sort of his counter-train, is what gives me slight scum vibes. Guess we wait to see what he says when he shows up.

The only way it's different is that you get the third voter's role information if they're lynched on Day 1, as opposed to no information at all with a no-lynch.

Christian @ 5/1/2019 20:19

Spin @ 5/1/2019 21:12 I still find it funny Helios doesn't understand how his 3rd-vote thing contradicts his absolutely-not-no-lynch thing. That, plus Ahoda was sort of his counter-train, is what gives me slight scum vibes. Guess we wait to see what he says when he shows up. The only way it's different is that you get the third voter's role information if they're lynched on Day 1, as opposed to no information at all with a no-lynch.

While this is true, that wasn't his argument. He said that if you no-lynch, you can't do vote analysis later in the game. That contradicts his 3rd voter strategy.

Christian @ 5/1/2019 18:19

Spin @ 5/1/2019 21:12 I still find it funny Helios doesn't understand how his 3rd-vote thing contradicts his absolutely-not-no-lynch thing. That, plus Ahoda was sort of his counter-train, is what gives me slight scum vibes. Guess we wait to see what he says when he shows up. The only way it's different is that you get the third voter's role information if they're lynched on Day 1, as opposed to no information at all with a no-lynch.

See and this is why i am genuinely SO confused to why a no-lynch would have been bad. Given the assumption there were NO roles to start... how does 'putting pressure' on someone help with this specific format?

The keeping track of votes thing I get but idk. Maybe people are just so used to a no-lynch in general being terrible for town, but Rose i think even said it could have been helpful with this set up?

Christian @ 5/1/2019 21:10

Jestdrrr @ 5/1/2019 20:57 Christian @ 5/1/2019 20:16 I agreed with Spin about the Helios tradition of voting the third voter. It gives no information to look back on, no matter how Helios or the third voter eventually flip. I only agreed with Helios' stance on the no-lynch yesterday. Hopefully Rose will have more time for us today, and brings any leftover birthday cake. hello i have more time but not that much because its the weekend and the cake?

i have brought you all the cake you could ever want, assuming that is one slice

So I went thru D1 again. Other than the great shitposting bu Primate and the no lynch discussion, there wasn't much to dissect for me personally.

Since Nav was killed last night, I focused more on his posts. His last scum reads were Buffy, Brian, Rose, and Rodney (which i believe has already been brought up today). Although he did tell Buffy not to kill him before the day ended, I feel like that's something Nav usually says during the days to Buffy just to troll (I remember him doing it during X-Men).

So I could see Nav being killed and scum hoping the attention shifts to Buffy. Buffy said she's scum. Don't have much to disclaim that now, so I'll take her word for it for now.

The only one I feel suspicious towards right now is Brian. But it's more of a vibe right now. And he was one of Nav's scum reads.

Buffy said she's not* scum

I was honestly feeling Primate was scum day1, even tho my lynch vote on him WAS for lolz.

I found it odd Nav said something about Primate being the lowest poster, and something about he shit posts MORE when hes mafai? And then all of a sudden he started posting like mad. It felt weird to me but idk. It did make me think maybe Nav/Primate were both scum but with Nav being dead im second guessing my gut vibes on Primate

Nav was an easy decision for mafia to kill as it left 4 scapegoats. That's just as likey the scenario as its one of us being offended scum. The only difference is, only the former makes sense. Read into it if you want but it's a clear set up to me so my eyes are on anyone making a mountain out of it.
Easy for me to say as one of the four isn't it?