Snowflake poker @ 4/1/2018 21:10

Since we know DS was blocked and rose was saved I can only see maddie being a mafia JOAT or using a scum buddies role (mafia doctor?) to support her claim if rose isn’t the other godfather. The surviving a kill while jailed is a bit odds. Going to go read how that part of the role normally works.

Was rose saved or is she the godfather?

Btw I breadcrumbed my role D2 with a Green Mile quote.

I'm town, so I should be least likely scum out of the turn tables.

Primate @ 4/1/2018 23:11

Spin trying to flip the lynch to literally anyone else looked a little bad too

I’d agree, except Bryce flipped survivor so it doesn’t come off like Spin was trying to save him.

Helios Garabandia @ 4/1/2018 22:06

Jamie: Why Bryce over 317 yesterday?

would always pick someone trying over someone not trying, we had a claim from 317 which I could see and nothing from bryce. I thought bryce was scum

Farlig, I don't understand why you're making an either Rose/Maddie claim.

If they are both town, then?

Mads @ 4/1/2018 21:49

Primate @ 4/1/2018 22:48 Why would you protect the scummy looking inactive? I was protecting the inactive, I was RBing the inactive. I was thinking scum might be likely to send one of the inactives out for the kill.

Forgive me if this was said already and I missed it, but....

1) Your Jailkeeper lets you choose to protect or roleblock, not both?
2) You only blocked Rose, not protected her?

Primate @ 4/1/2018 22:12

Snowflake poker @ 4/1/2018 21:10 Since we know DS was blocked and rose was saved I can only see maddie being a mafia JOAT or using a scum buddies role (mafia doctor?) to support her claim if rose isn’t the other godfather. The surviving a kill while jailed is a bit odds. Going to go read how that part of the role normally works. Was rose saved or is she the godfather?

TBD

But found this:

Note, however, that it's fairly common for Mafia to claim to be a Jailkeeper when they're actually a Roleblocker; this is hard to disprove without a Role Cop and makes the role sound more townsided.

We need more from you today, Jamie.

Not a claim, just something to grab onto.

if rose was a gf on the kids table she would survive the same way tib did

Herm @ 4/1/2018 22:17

We need more from you today, Jamie. Not a claim, just something to grab onto.

okay hermm hold my hand

Herm @ 4/1/2018 22:15

Farlig, I don't understand why you're making an either Rose/Maddie claim. If they are both town, then?

Please explain how I am making the claimed jailkeeper (maddie) claim.

Snowflake poker @ 4/1/2018 23:17

Primate @ 4/1/2018 22:12 Snowflake poker @ 4/1/2018 21:10 Since we know DS was blocked and rose was saved I can only see maddie being a mafia JOAT or using a scum buddies role (mafia doctor?) to support her claim if rose isn’t the other godfather. The surviving a kill while jailed is a bit odds. Going to go read how that part of the role normally works. Was rose saved or is she the godfather? TBD But found this: Note, however, that it's fairly common for Mafia to claim to be a Jailkeeper when they're actually a Roleblocker; this is hard to disprove without a Role Cop and makes the role sound more townsided.

COOL


But mods aren’t using typical roleblocking language in this game, at least not according to everyone I’ve jailed.

If Maddie and rose shared a pf, I could see Maddie jumping all over the "I know why rose lived" thing out of the gate.

Or one or both could both be town. Idk?

Herm @ 4/1/2018 22:15

Farlig, I don't understand why you're making an either Rose/Maddie claim. If they are both town, then?

And where am I saying rose should claim? And why are you defending an active so aggressively?