Also, we're down to 6 so, if im317 is not scum and one other non scum person lynches him, we could lose. Why are you lynching so fast?

Buffy @ 25/8/2017 19:23

Also, we're down to 6 so, if im317 is not scum and one other non scum person lynches him, we could lose. Why are you lynching so fast?

Because he's scum. And not scum like David was scum, but real scum.

Buffy @ 25/8/2017 19:21

spindoctor02 @ 25/8/2017 20:14 Buffy @ 25/8/2017 18:54 Zersch @ 25/8/2017 19:22 But then again I guess the Mafia would want to keep that gun for themselves. Supposedly it was supposed to go to Spin but we don't know that for sure. I don't really know why 317 was making it so obvious in the beginning but, then again, he didn't either, did he? But I think he revealed D2 and then DS apparently blocked the kill N3, from the info we have at least. I did wonder why DS wouldn't have had to block the GF to stop a kill but every host is different. That's not how it works. Read: http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=5780 What? Read the poll? I don't gaf about the poll. It makes more sense to have to block the GF since he's the one "sending" the person out. And I've played numerous games where it has worked that way. It's up to the host. I'm not criticizing these hosts, just saying it can differ game to game. Also, all I was pointing out was that it was apparently Ben who was blocked and that apparently stopped the kill.

Read the posts in the poll thread. Even if it has been done before, that doesn't mean its right. You block the guy with the action (i.e. the killer, not the don) if you want to block the kill action. Doing it any other way is just dumb.

spindoctor02 @ 25/8/2017 20:26

Buffy @ 25/8/2017 19:21 spindoctor02 @ 25/8/2017 20:14 Buffy @ 25/8/2017 18:54 Zersch @ 25/8/2017 19:22 But then again I guess the Mafia would want to keep that gun for themselves. Supposedly it was supposed to go to Spin but we don't know that for sure. I don't really know why 317 was making it so obvious in the beginning but, then again, he didn't either, did he? But I think he revealed D2 and then DS apparently blocked the kill N3, from the info we have at least. I did wonder why DS wouldn't have had to block the GF to stop a kill but every host is different. That's not how it works. Read: http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=5780 What? Read the poll? I don't gaf about the poll. It makes more sense to have to block the GF since he's the one "sending" the person out. And I've played numerous games where it has worked that way. It's up to the host. I'm not criticizing these hosts, just saying it can differ game to game. Also, all I was pointing out was that it was apparently Ben who was blocked and that apparently stopped the kill. Read the posts in the poll thread. Even if it has been done before, that doesn't mean its right. You block the guy with the action (i.e. the killer, not the don) if you want to block the kill action. Doing it any other way is just dumb.

I've read it and I've voted in it. I disagree with you. It has nothing to do with this game, though, so let's actually talk about this game.

I miss you Rose. I miss Curtis too, actually.

Guys, we can't all post at once. You'll have to each take turns.

If spin wasn't a mason id swear he's scum

Okay topic. Discuss lynch train and events lead up to it D7:


Mason/Town
Mafia
SK Team
3rd Party Survivors

D7

As of Lamps' death
im317 (3/8): Curtis, Spin, Zersch, Primate
David (1/8): Mittens
Timmah (1/8): JJ

End of D7
Timmah (4/7): Mittens, Primate, Brian, TiB, Zersch, JJ, Angi, DR
David (2/7): Mittens, Spin, Timmah, TiB
Im317 (1/7): Curtis, Zersch, JJ, Angi*


(courtesy of Spin)

*Added Angi's lynches/unlynches on im317 as it wasn't shown in final lynch count D7

Zersch & TIB both ended up lynching Timmah but im317 didn't, and he was shown online in the thread at the time. Zersch also unlynched after I lynched and lynched again, I am thinking to be on the end in case Timmah was a bomb (that was my thought at the time).

It makes 317 look bad for not joining lynch, but Angi was pushing to lynch 317 - hard to tell if she was distancing though.
Zersch looks good for being on the train, unless he was mafia and knew Timmah was town, and felt secure enough that Timmah wouldn't take him out over others. Still risky, though, if he is scum.


I'm leaning 317 right now but I still want to talk about this more.

I also meant to add it makes TIB look good, too, which makes Curtis look bad since one has to be GF.

wow you guys didn't get much done well i was out. JJ i was trying to be funny in that post but not disrespectful, im sorry if it came across otherwise.

so some of you still think im scum, and i understand why. i do question why blocking Dadd makes Zersch town, i mean Dadd did turn out to be town after all. in fact didn't he flip as the person who could redirect roles? maybe im on to something with TIB setting up a fake hated claim and Jamie had scanned Dadd? a mafia jack blocking a possible re-director would make a lot of sense.

im317 @ 25/8/2017 22:47

wow you guys didn't get much done well i was out. JJ i was trying to be funny in that post but not disrespectful, im sorry if it came across otherwise. so some of you still think im scum, and i understand why. i do question why blocking Dadd makes Zersch town, i mean Dadd did turn out to be town after all. in fact didn't he flip as the person who could redirect roles? maybe im on to something with TIB setting up a fake hated claim and Jamie had scanned Dadd? a mafia jack blocking a possible re-director would make a lot of sense.

I actually meant that Zersch hadn't proven he had an "active" role because all we knew was that he said he scanned Maddie N1. The fact he blocked Dadd means he does have an active role, so I was just saying I don't think he could be GF.

Buffy @ 25/8/2017 22:51

im317 @ 25/8/2017 22:47 wow you guys didn't get much done well i was out. JJ i was trying to be funny in that post but not disrespectful, im sorry if it came across otherwise. so some of you still think im scum, and i understand why. i do question why blocking Dadd makes Zersch town, i mean Dadd did turn out to be town after all. in fact didn't he flip as the person who could redirect roles? maybe im on to something with TIB setting up a fake hated claim and Jamie had scanned Dadd? a mafia jack blocking a possible re-director would make a lot of sense. I actually meant that Zersch hadn't proven he had an "active" role because all we knew was that he said he scanned Maddie N1. The fact he blocked Dadd means he does have an active role, so I was just saying I don't think he could be GF.

oh yeah that makes sense. i never pictured him as godfather tbh. the more i think about it the more i think its TIB as godfather with Zersch as mafia jack.

on the other hand that would be an awful lot of long cons for 1 game. so maybe Zersch is the long con and its actually Curtis who is the godfather. his claim was incredibly convenient.

So, what do you think is going on with Curtis today?

thisisbad @ 25/8/2017 21:34

If spin wasn't a mason id swear he's scum

So would I.