Hern @ 29/5/2017 1:41

Kiwi @ 29/5/2017 9:03 Who left hasn't claimed on Herm's list? You, Merc, Brian, Timmah. Unless I missed it.

I claimed on like D3 or something without straight out saying what I am.

##Lynch: Primate

pls

I was hinting at my role, and confirming my promise from the mafia forum in the last game that I will not claim under any circumstances. If you think there are more than 1 mafia and definitely a third party left, would it not make more sense to focus outside Herm's scans?

There are 13 left:

1. Herm has claimed cop
2. TIB swapped a kill to a mafia member - could still be third party

There are 4 clears from Herm's scans: (1 could be GF)
3. Brian
4. Kiwi
5. Merc
6. Timmah

7. Miko claimed a watcher or tracker or something way back and handed us a mafia member (right?) - could still be third party.
8. Primate claimed commuter, and the inability to act on him has been proven twice by suspected town
9. Badger lynched Zach when he didn't have to - could still be third party
10. Vlady lynched Zach when he didn't have to - could still be third party

11. Angi claimed inventor days ago - honestly she could still be mafia or third party

12. Stephen is a complete and total question mark in this list
13. Boc has been inactive, made a random post that he had info for us and then disappeared.

Also, the hinting at my role and saying I was not going to claim was a response to Kiwi asking who hadn't claimed out of a list of about 4 that I am on.

I feel like I am pulling a DS here and over posting so i'm going to pretend to log out for a bit while really i'll be sitting here refreshing the thread and hoping other people post.

I'll leave my list again

Town:
12. Badger -
15. Angi
11. TIB
16. Vlady
18. Hern
18. Herm

Feel good about:
26. Timmah
25. Miko -
5. Merc - Both feel good about and bad about same time.

Lean 3rd party maybe not Mafia
14. Primate

Mafia GF:
22. Kiwi - based on being cleared and voting pattern and going back and reading his comments, this is where my guess would be

Need research:
20. Stephen - I'll spend my exile reading all his comments. Try to see what others are seeing.

Umm:
13. 'N'Brian -

17. Boc - Claimed info then was banished apparantly.


I do think there is another Chaos person of course, and i realize it could be someone on my town list. I was going to include more notes, but decided against it

## lynch Boc

thisisbad @ 29/5/2017 12:03

I feel like I am pulling a DS here and over posting so i'm going to pretend to log out for a bit while really i'll be sitting here refreshing the thread and hoping other people post. I'll leave my list again Town: 12. Badger - 15. Angi 11. TIB 16. Vlady 18. Hern 18. Herm Feel good about: 26. Timmah 25. Miko - 5. Merc - Both feel good about and bad about same time. Lean 3rd party maybe not Mafia 14. Primate Mafia GF: 22. Kiwi - based on being cleared and voting pattern and going back and reading his comments, this is where my guess would be Need research: 20. Stephen - I'll spend my exile reading all his comments. Try to see what others are seeing. Umm: 13. 'N'Brian - 17. Boc - Claimed info then was banished apparantly. I do think there is another Chaos person of course, and i realize it could be someone on my town list. I was going to include more notes, but decided against it

We have a cop clear of both Kiwi and Brian, so one of them is town...

##lynch Boc

It makes sense based on the list I compiled. I could easily go for Stephen instead, though.

Timmah @ 29/5/2017 11:11

thisisbad @ 29/5/2017 12:03 I feel like I am pulling a DS here and over posting so i'm going to pretend to log out for a bit while really i'll be sitting here refreshing the thread and hoping other people post. I'll leave my list again Town: 12. Badger - 15. Angi 11. TIB 16. Vlady 18. Hern 18. Herm Feel good about: 26. Timmah 25. Miko - 5. Merc - Both feel good about and bad about same time. Lean 3rd party maybe not Mafia 14. Primate Mafia GF: 22. Kiwi - based on being cleared and voting pattern and going back and reading his comments, this is where my guess would be Need research: 20. Stephen - I'll spend my exile reading all his comments. Try to see what others are seeing. Umm: 13. 'N'Brian - 17. Boc - Claimed info then was banished apparantly. I do think there is another Chaos person of course, and i realize it could be someone on my town list. I was going to include more notes, but decided against it We have a cop clear of both Kiwi and Brian, so one of them is town...

I put one of them as Gf and the other on a list where it's clear i just don't even know if he's playing or not so.........

Timmah @ 29/5/2017 13:01

11. Angi claimed inventor days ago - honestly she could still be mafia or third party

Seriously Timmah? Third party maybe (I'm not) but it should be fucking obvious I'm not Mafia

Timmah still wants me to be mafia/bad guy so don't take it personally

Timmah @ 29/5/2017 13:01

I was hinting at my role, and confirming my promise from the mafia forum in the last game that I will not claim under any circumstances. If you think there are more than 1 mafia and definitely a third party left, would it not make more sense to focus outside Herm's scans?

It's likely there is a third party left, but it's also possible that Curtis was third party so it's not a guarantee.

Either way, I don't think we should be focusing outside of Herm's reads, though that would be convenient for you I suppose. First of all, that's lazy game play. But also, town's scumdar has been very good this game.

Gonna admit that this is meta, but I find this argument slightly odd coming from you, as you are someone who has vocally been against playing 'process of elimination' instead of mafia. I have a hard time seeing you make this type of argument if you were town.

Interesting that you are saying people could still be third party without actually looking at the third party's train that has flipped. I was pretty vocal about believing DS, and saying that we should lynch Spin because his reaction was off, yet I'm on your list for possible third party. Primate isn't listed as potential third party by you, yet he was the only other person than you who is still alive who was on the DS train day 1 (the one train that could have saved Spin). You pretty much ignored the only evidence related to third party and threw shade on everyone else.

Town
Badger
Angi
Tib
Vlady

Likely Town
Herm - Almost sure he's town, but not quite 100% yet.
Miko - See Herm
Stephen - Just based on my general impression. I don't see why people think he's scummy, and the amount of shit he's received about VOTING CORRECTLY Day 2 makes me think scum are pushing that narritive.
Merc - I think this is the Herm scan I trust the most. If Merc was GF, I do not see him playing this way.

Probably a few Scum in here
'N'Brian - No read on him. Not gonna clear him on Herm's read alone.
Kiwi - Has been around just enough not to die for inactivity, but I don't think he's been a productive town member at all.
Boc - Popped in to say he had info yesterday and never came back. Maybe scum was concerned about an inactivity lynch hassled about it on their private forum?
Timmah - Definitely lost a lot of credibility when he asked for a free pass due to Herm's scan of him. Voting record is pretty terrible. Hasn't really been scum hunting that hard, just tunneling on Stephen from what I can recall.
Primate - Been on the wrong side of pretty much every lynch. Spewed out a bunch of logic that doesn't make sense. Heavily targeted a lot of townies.

Oops, I was refering to Stephen's day 4 vote (on Zach), not his day 2 vote.

People are quiet today.