Dylan @ 10/9/2012 10:29

Guys did Helios ever say anything about a shard.

He posted on the last page.

Helios Garabandia @ 10/9/2012 6:27

Ari @ 10/9/2012 4:35 Small question to Helios: Did you get passed the note from Rob? I can confirm that I was passed one additional shard. HOWEVER, both Rob AND Wikey have claimed to have passed me a shard. Thus, someone is lying.

Curtis @ 10/9/2012 15:06

Been very busy with my first week back at school

What a loser

:peroy:

Sorry, haven't been here because of family issues last night, so i've missed whatever happened at the end of the last phase. Can anybody catch me up, please?

As for this phase currently I'm going to stand by the decision of not splitting up. At least so far it doesn't seem like a good idea to me.

I'll re-read this topic once more now though, I've missed some posts and I think i need clarification on some issues.

I feel like we should go left. Definitely not splitting up though.

Helios Garabandia @ 10/9/2012 4:27

Ari @ 10/9/2012 4:35 Small question to Helios: Did you get passed the note from Rob? I can confirm that I was passed one additional shard. HOWEVER, both Rob AND Wikey have claimed to have passed me a shard. Thus, someone is lying.

Wouldn't it just be the smartest thing to be "silenced" as to not be suspected as Mafia?

Can you use items and pass them when you're silenced?

Roth @ 9/9/2012 20:14

Just to clarify, Tayvie was modkilled for inactivity.

And Ari, who knows when you will die, but no sense using it now. Better to use it when we kind of get more of an idea of who Mafia is. For all we know we're on the right track and you'd waste your ability.

Splitting up is dumb because we don't really have an objective or something to find, so there is no need for a drastic split, that just makes us vulnerable.

What was it that put suspicion on me Phase 1? I'm honestly just curious. I don't have anything to hide but I know I was a little extra forceful trying to get discussion going that round.

I unfortunately keep missing the phase ends, so my notes are currently nonexistent and admittedly my memory's not the best thing to work off of. Do you still have your list you posted last round, Natalie? Of the task you had with the gun? I remember there being a few people mentioned in the flavor as being attacked by the shadow things (thus having their votes cancelled out?) , though the only people I can remember seeing attacked were I think Curtis and Wikey. If I'm wrong or someone saw someone else, please mention it. It's important that we know if our votes are counting in the final judgement or not and for which rounds.

My personal list for phase 1 and 2 are exactly identical (mainly because I missed the transition between 2 and 3), and I had Rob at the very top. I didn't bother putting the genuine inactives ala Tayvie at the top because I assume modkills won't factor into the final judgement.

The reason I put Rob at the top was mainly because of his posts. I think I actually have a few of those saved (via copy pasting to Paul and :| ing hard at them. It was the "Meh. Might as well give Ari busdriver *bandwagons*, Meh I don't know who I'd trust with the gun Meh fine natalie's good, meh,btw I'm definitely totally not scum and can be trusted with the gun. I sucked in Lab 2 as a bad guy so even if I was a bad guy you'd know like right away."

The quote about not being scum based on Lab 2 performance was the worst one for me, because while Rob was calling out various people based on metagaming, he sold himself incredibly short. He may have been awful scum in Lab2, but he did a fairly good job in Mini Sausage as the usurper Randy and is generally a good player in most respects in other games.


I can't vote or use my role this round due to the block, but I agree it's time we start discussing our lists.

As for splitting, I really need to reread the flavor for this phase a little closer before I say yes on that, but splitting up don't seem incredibly smart to me and will make our task of building up our list much more difficult. I assume we would meet back up within a phase or two, but that's not something I wanna take a bet on.

Wha direction we going? Left? I likely won't be on for the next 12 hours so unless someone says otherwise I'm gonna go left.

Ari @ 10/9/2012 9:05

Why have Tayvie at the top? We have no read on him :D Shouldnt we put people at the top we think are acting like scum? Captain Canada was acting fishy on phase 1 and didnt say much phase 2..... I only suggested splitting up if we need to find something. Like in lab you have to find the key so its better to split up to cover more ground. If we arnt looking for anything then I dont think we should split up

True, and so far it doesn't seem we're 'searching' for anything specific... I do really think we should all keep together. It's safer that way.

Ari @ 10/9/2012 9:25

Bryce, Waka and Dylan have been giving me some vibes.

*turns vibrator batteries off*
But really, what?

The best way to discuss the lists would probably be to start with who we find the least suspicious, and work our way up.

I will get to work on a proposed list. Everyone else should too.

Also, @ Curtis: I gave my shard of code to Helios because I couldn't read it

Left it is, please don't abandon me y'all

Bryce @ 10/9/2012 15:52

Helios Garabandia @ 10/9/2012 4:27 Ari @ 10/9/2012 4:35 Small question to Helios: Did you get passed the note from Rob? I can confirm that I was passed one additional shard. HOWEVER, both Rob AND Wikey have claimed to have passed me a shard. Thus, someone is lying. Wouldn't it just be the smartest thing to be "silenced" as to not be suspected as Mafia? Can you use items and pass them when you're silenced?

Yes. It was explicitly stated in the notice that I got about the silencing that I was still allowed to vote and do actions in my journal. I passed Helios my N, about two hours or so after they were dispersed.