Christian @ 11/4/2016 20:32

Curtis @ 11/4/2016 20:23 Chris25 @ 11/4/2016 20:20 Curtis @ 11/4/2016 19:58 Explain Chris! You being roleblocked smells like bullshit How come? We know there's two roleblockers because there were some nights with two people blocked. We know Mafia has one because they blocked Mal when he claimed Watcher. Either each mafia has one or one does and town has the other. You don't think mafia roleblocker would block me last night to prevent me from confirming? I feel like it's a possibility that the other Mafia would block you to help discredit your claim. But if they were going to do that, why didn't they also just try to kill me last night? Get rid of two of us almost at once. Remember one Mafia has no friends on the Zook train. That's why vladykins was a strange choice for a kill, aside from the BP vest thing.

I'm sure the mafia with no one on the list has no interest in ending it soon

In a scenario where it's Boc which I believe is true:

They kill you. They block me. I get lynched today. Boc gets lynched tomorrow for being the last alive

They block me but don't kill you. I get lynched today. Then you vs. Boc stretches to the day after that and Boc can maybe get you lynched and get another night in

Wikey @ 11/4/2016 20:35

It's bullshit to suggest I defended Lamps.

Wikey @ 10/4/2016 19:52

I'm not against a Lamps lynch, though it's not impossible for there to be a vanilla cop, given the amount that have flipped.

Wikey @ 10/4/2016 19:59

Curtis @ 10/4/2016 19:59 Wikey @ 10/4/2016 19:57 Please lynch Boc everybody. It's him, I'm sure of it now. I know I said it was 100% Curtis a few pages ago but I've changed my mind, for the last time. Do it. If he is town I'll lynch myself tomorrow. YOU'RE TRYING TO DRAW VOTES WITH 3 MINUTES LEFT SO YOU CAN PUSH ME AHEAD NICE TRY I implore everybody on your lynch train to vote Boc too. Lamps is a terrible choice.

Time between those posts: 7 minutes

Cherry picking!

maybe. The one thing you have going for you Curtis is the fact that you are actually trying to discuss suspect outside of the list. Boc only named a couple peeps yesterday when I asked him to.

Speaking of Boc, did he address what his actual claim is?

Since Curtis left the rest of the quote out:

Me

I'm not against a Lamps lynch, though it's not impossible for there to be a vanilla cop, given the amount that have flipped. The poison thing is very shady though, I don't think there is any reasonable explanation for that. But I think it is really important to clear up Canuck's list ASAP. If we don't we are going to have this exact same shit tomorrow.

This is the post in it's context. I didn't want us to lynch Lamps purely because I wanted us to sort the list shit out yesterday, lest it be tabled for yet another day, which it has. I wasn't denying that he was shady. I admit that in this very post! The poison thing was shady, I said as much!

Wikey, why is it Boc?

Everyone who finds me scummy is a suspect

Herm, who is the Mafia member out of me, Curtis and Boc?

Wikey I would like the names of your cohorts immediately

Wikey @ 11/4/2016 20:44

Everyone who finds me scummy is a suspect

well I find you extremely scummy.

I think we can rule out Timmah from being Red Mafia, really anybody on Lamps' train yesterday.

Christian @ 11/4/2016 20:43

Wikey, why is it Boc?

Well I thought your reaction was pretty genuine yesterday when I pressed you, I think Curtis making the fake claim "Hermit" whilst describing a role which basically amounts to "Tree Stump" would be absolutely retarded, and Curtis isn't retarded as far as I know.

Whereas there is no defending Boc's actions. They make no sense. He knew that Zero's role was listed as "Backup Vig," yet he went ahead and outed him all the same, and ended up getting him lynched. Furthermore, Rose defended him a fair bit when he made his claims.

Granted there is something which bothers me about each of you on the list. I could very easily be misinterpreting your defensiveness towards me yesterday, and your role does sound a little convenient as a claim.

Curtis could have gone through his old posts, saw some quotes he made addressing Herm by name and may have decided to incorporate them into a fake Hermit claim, before realizing that the role he was claiming sounded more like tree stump than Hermit. I dunno...

The biggest problem with Boc lies more with the setup. The only thing making me hesitate is that there is two mafia's. It seems odd that only one Mafia team would have a traitor. But maybe the other mafia team has something else to compensate.

The trouble is it's really not easy to commit to any of you on the list. Which is why I would rather we just ignored it for now. Sure, it's frustrating to think that there is confirmed scum among you three, but at the same time, there are a bunch more scum among the other players who aren't on the list, who I reckon will be hoping we continue to focus exclusively on the list.

Wikey

Now we are back in the same place we was yesterday. One of Boc, Curtis and Christian are scum, and we are no closer to knowing which of them it is. Curtis been roleblocked was rather predictable and it's impossible to read anything into it. Which is why I personally think we should just table the issue completely for now. We can find scum by other means.

I have to disagree.

We didn't lose anyone during the night so last person that was lynched was Lamps and his flip was scum. So one scum down and no town.

Curt, you speak to me like I know what the fuck is going on.

So Jay actually said some things that were true!? Amazing!

So Curtis has to be that last mafia, right? And wikey has to be on the mafia team that lamps was on. There was just too much that reads as them working off of one another, trying to keep the focus on the list too.

Vlady survived, but Jay gave him a vest. Or did he? Jay's batting about .105 on truth telling so far. But Ari survived as well. So, maybe Jay told us 2 true things and Ari is second GF.

In reading yesterday, how did everyone just let boc off without ever claiming? We had people pushing for focus on the zook list, even for boc, without even bothering to see if he'd ever actually claimed.