Town:

Herm
Christian???

I'm not really confident about the rest of you.

If we lynch the right person out of the 3 then at least we have 2 guaranteed town, which at this point is more valuable than anything IMO.

##lynch Curtis

Cult:
Jay

Town:
Ari

People I dont want to lynch right now:
Herm
Boc
Christian
Chris
Lamps
Timmah

People I wouldnt mind lynching:
Curtis
Vladykins
Sabataged
Wikey
thisisbad
Patrick
Zero
Vernon

This is what I am thinking right now. Lists are in no particular order.

We know there is scum on the list. Why are some of you lynching people not on the list?

Hermsworth @ 10/4/2016 15:34

I'm suspicious of people ignoring everything but the list. I understand that 1 of the 3 are scum, but at least be a little concerned about town as a whole town since we're completely screwed if there are 3-4 mafia left in each of the two teams.

Theres a lot of people we need more input from, mostly those I mentioned two days ago but nearly everyone ignored me when I asked about other suspects. My thought process is that if they are ignoring that they are probably scum. Cant see a reason for a townie not to post their thoughts.

Lamps @ 10/4/2016 6:00

Christian @ 10/4/2016 4:05 Good question. Unless both Mafias decided to take out Mal last night. Lamps said he was blocked (pretty convenient :P ) though, which is another strike against him. And why didn't he try to investigate Eben a second time when he had the chance? Things like these make me think you are scum. You didn't think of that possibility until after Curtis asked if I could scan the same person on back to back nights, did you? You didn't give any suggestions when I asked when now you claim that was the obvious thing to do. I didn't realize it, you didn't either I think - but now you use that as a strike against me? Also convenient to count another strike against me when the blocking may have been another attempt to make me look bad lol.

Of course I thought of it, in fact I almost asked you when I asked if you had any useful information.

Hermsworth @ 9/4/2016 22:53

Christian Hey Herm, I'm suspicious of him too, but why Wikey over one of the 3 of us or Lamps? Because town is losing by only going after the list. Especially if we get it wrong. Wikey is acting very suspicious to me. That being said, my vote is mostly for pressure and if we go down the list path I won't fight it.

We've been going after the list and have nailed 2 of the 3 already. I would hardly call that losing.

Patrick was voting Curtis yesterday over Eben, but today is torn about what to do?

Ari, you have Lamps down as someone you wouldn't want to lynch right now. Why is that when all these weird events appears to be keep painting him in a negative light?

Chris, figure out what you're going to do when I'm no longer here.

The fact that Vernon is still alive makes me feel like he's Town. :P I think his scumbuds would have been willing to throw him under the bus on Day 1.

I feel good about Sab being Town I think. And obviously Boc.

and I lean more Town on Ari than not.

Christian @ 10/4/2016 16:42

Patrick was voting Curtis yesterday over Eben, but today is torn about what to do? Ari, you have Lamps down as someone you wouldn't want to lynch right now. Why is that when all these weird events appears to be keep painting him in a negative light?

Im thinking Lamps' scan got bussed from Eben onto someone else. I cant see the reason for Lamps to lie about that, no gain at all and only puts him in worse light.

Cant see any reason for Lamps to lie about being poisoned either. Maybe mafia had like a fake poison to scare someone? That would lead most people to claim and put all of their info out there. Maybe we have someone who can save someone who is poisoned?

I see no reason to believe Jay, who has already admitted to have lied. Even if Jay is telling the truth, Lamps could have been bussed with scum and that got Brian killed.

Lamps is contributing and appears, to me at least, to be genuine. I would much rather keep him around than some of the dead weight we still have alive.

So I have been completely shit this game, sorry guys. It's got away from me this past couple of days and I just haven't found the time to get back into it.

I'm going to claim, as that might offer some small amount of help in narrowing down who the last scum are for you guys.

I will also try and update myself on what has happened thus far but can't make any promises!

I am a vanilla townie.

Screw it, I'm going to catch up.

All of the Vanilla claims is the reason I had believed Lamps in the first place. Now we've got another one (Wikey).

But when the day ended yesterday, I thought maybe Lamps lied about being poisoned as an attempt to survive the lynch. When lynching Lamps was brought up yesterday, there were people that shut that down pretty quick.

But for him to know that there was a poisoner in the game to be able to lie about it (if that's what did indeed happen), then he'd either have to be the Poisoner or be on the same team as the Poisoner.

During the day, I thought that Zilla was an odd choice for poison since he was barely around, and that Lamps would make a good choice for someone who might have been suspicious of him. The fact that an inactive person like Zilla was targeted led me to believe that whoever poisoned someone had to be Town, because what harm was Zilla?

If I understood why Lamps didn't die, I'd feel better about him being Town. Maybe it's a hidden part of the Poisoner role that one of them would die and one wouldn't?

Lamps, when you were told you were poisoned, can you paraphrase what you were told?

Yall gonna have to bear with me cause I am still catching up, but am I right in saying this is how Zook's lynch train looks in relation to Canuck's sensor results:

Zook (10/14) - Zook, Herm, Redster, Eben, Boc, Curtis, Angi, Christian, drr, Canuck, Dadd

So we have two of the three scum that were on Zook's train. There is one more among the following:

Boc
Curtis
Christian

Should we rule out Herm? He unvoted but technically he was on the train at one point. I am not sure how a sensor usually works in this regard. If Herm doesn't count, then it is one of the above three. And the other two are town.

...I see now why I got so many negative comments for calling all three scum yesterday (:

Okay, this ain't actually easy, I feel you could make a pretty decent case against each of them, but given we know that two of them must be town, that makes things difficult!