Herm @ 12/10/2015 11:28

Angi @ 12/10/2015 17:47 With Buffy, Brian and Curtis all seeming scummy, why were they killed is my question. This is all weird. It seems that maybe Buffy's claim during her kidnapping might be what killed her though. I assume the jailer killed her over Timmah because she sounded more town, from what it sounds like.

Yes, because I came out today and told you all that. I actually tried to taunt the jailer into killing me instead.

I think that there were good reasons for beöieving the gun was rigged lol.

That being said, I have been all over the place with my suspicions but the alternative is me not saying or lynching anything or anyone. Day 2 was kind of a bad day since I was extremly confused during the latter half. People have to stop arguing.

Redster @ 12/10/2015 11:23

Timmah @ 12/10/2015 9:14 Also, I really wanted to lynch/have Curtis shoot redster yesterday. Why, because it would have been very helpful for scum hunting purposes. There were several people who clearly wanted him protected, as evidenced by the diversion of the lynch elsewhere. There were several people who clearly wanted him lynched, but NOT shot. There were 1 or 2 of us who wanted him shot first because it gave us more info. That's 3 set's of data that can be analyzed, yet we got none of it. Further, if it was a vig that targeted him, having shot him yesterday would likely have answered some of the questions and perhaps let the vig (if that's who it was) target someone else... When I flip townie all it is going to fucking tell you is that all the people pushing so hard for my lynch are probably the dirty fucking scum bastards responsible for attacking me and they want me out of the way since their night attacks keep failing. Hey, that kinda describes you, don't it?

Yep, and I'm fine with it. You see, as town, I care more about information that is beneficial to the town as a whole than I do about my own standing in this game.

Herm @ 12/10/2015 11:39

I think that there were good reasons for beöieving the gun was rigged lol. That being said, I have been all over the place with my suspicions but the alternative is me not saying or lynching anything or anyone. Day 2 was kind of a bad day since I was extremly confused during the latter half. People have to stop arguing.

What reasons are those? There were literally no reasons for believing the gun was rigged, and reasons that he told us about (50% if done privately, 100% if done publicly) that suggest it was NOT rigged...

FREE CANDY @ 12/10/2015 8:54

Redster @ 12/10/2015 8:39 FREE CANDY @ 12/10/2015 6:26 Redster should of been lynched yesterday. However let's get rid of this monster, ##lynch beaver. What do you have on beaver? You have infos? i thought beaver's posts on day 2, post 11, 19 and 248, were interesting. if you go back and read post 214, i wanted to see if i could draw out beaver with a response, but nothing. I decided to RB beaver, but it failed. remember, a kidnap happens prior to most everything else in night action resolution. i think beaver is part of the kidnapping and deciding to kill one or the other.

Oh, noticed this after I posted that. I haven't gone back and looked at those specific posts yet, but I'll get around to it in a bit once Im at my desktop.

For the record I do believe that you tried to roleblock me because my role specifies that I can't be roleblocked. But you are wrong about me being jailer, I have a town role and I can reveal more if you guys insist on me claiming but I don't think it's a good idea unless absolutely necessary.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 12/10/2015 18:35

Whoa whoa whoa. Is there a reason that there is a random lynch train developing on me? Because that seems random as fuck (and somewhat coordinated). I can see why Lamps would want to because I've made it very clear that I suspect him of being scum. I have no idea what Free Candy and Timmah are trying to accomplish though.

If that were my reason to vote you, then that would have been almost as bad a reason as yours yesterday.

In the interests of getting all of the info I have on the table, here is what the jailer did last night:

(1) mentioned "delicious morsels" to describe us;
(2) asked us if we were town;
(3) told us that whichever one of us admitted to be scum would be eaten;
(4) asked us to claim and said the scummiest claim would be eaten;

He then ate Buffy when she hinted at her role, despite me taunting him to see if he'd kill me instead and not giving him jack squat for info. So, I'd say that it's pretty clear that this jailer is not a town player.

The likelihood of Curtis receiving a rigged gun Night 1 is pretty likely, seeing as he's always such a threat.

Daniel @ 12/10/2015 11:44

BadgerMcBeaver @ 12/10/2015 18:35 Whoa whoa whoa. Is there a reason that there is a random lynch train developing on me? Because that seems random as fuck (and somewhat coordinated). I can see why Lamps would want to because I've made it very clear that I suspect him of being scum. I have no idea what Free Candy and Timmah are trying to accomplish though. If that were my reason to vote you, then that would have been almost as bad a reason as yours yesterday.

My reason for voting you yesterday involved you calling Curtis definite scum over and over again with no real rationale for doing so (surprise, he flipped town). And because your behavior with Buffy seemed off to me after you FOS'd her (who also flipped town). That and you never added anything of value to the conversation yesterday, which appears to be the approach you are taking to today as well. You were acting scummy, so I voted to lynch you.

I'll admit though that the speculation about you being Jailer was pretty dumb to post in hindsight and that I probably should have kept that to myself.

[QUOTE=FREE CANDY@12/10/2015 8:54][QUOTE=Redster@12/10/2015 8:39]

FREE CANDY @ 12/10/2015 6:26

if you go back and read post 214, i wanted to see if i could draw out beaver with a response, but nothing.

How in any way does this post you alluded to attempt to 'draw me out with a response'?

Quote

Also, do you find it odd that we will hear "a couple of screams and see two people being dragged off to a cave" prior to N1, in the D1 write up. I'm assuming could possibly be a SK that is unblockable? SK picks the two victims then chooses which dies N1?

There is nothing there that refers to me or my role at all.

Apparently I suck at quoting sorry.

Ari @ 12/10/2015 8:49

I am always an advocate of lynching those not speaking much. Always scum hiding there... Shadow, Boc, im317, Canuck, DR all have less than 10 posts in total. Not really losing much here by lynching any of them...

Not really sure what to make of this given that you have the least posts of everyone (3 including this one).

Timmah @ 12/10/2015 9:39

Herm @ 12/10/2015 11:28 Angi @ 12/10/2015 17:47 With Buffy, Brian and Curtis all seeming scummy, why were they killed is my question. This is all weird. It seems that maybe Buffy's claim during her kidnapping might be what killed her though. I assume the jailer killed her over Timmah because she sounded more town, from what it sounds like. Yes, because I came out today and told you all that. I actually tried to taunt the jailer into killing me instead.

Why did you want the jailer to kill you over buffy? You said earlier you didn't see her roleclaim anything, so why try to protect her?

Redster @ 12/10/2015 12:08

Timmah @ 12/10/2015 9:39 Herm @ 12/10/2015 11:28 Angi @ 12/10/2015 17:47 With Buffy, Brian and Curtis all seeming scummy, why were they killed is my question. This is all weird. It seems that maybe Buffy's claim during her kidnapping might be what killed her though. I assume the jailer killed her over Timmah because she sounded more town, from what it sounds like. Yes, because I came out today and told you all that. I actually tried to taunt the jailer into killing me instead. Why did you want the jailer to kill you over buffy? You said earlier you didn't see her roleclaim anything, so why try to protect her?

Well now, Mr. Role Fisherman. Wondering whether you made the wrong call in killing Buffy?

BadgerMcBeaver @ 12/10/2015 12:07

Ari @ 12/10/2015 8:49 I am always an advocate of lynching those not speaking much. Always scum hiding there... Shadow, Boc, im317, Canuck, DR all have less than 10 posts in total. Not really losing much here by lynching any of them... Not really sure what to make of this given that you have the least posts of everyone (3 including this one).

Oops didn't include your other posts from today in the total, which would change the total to 6.