I wanted to pick my scum role but if I passed on a role with the word "cop" I was day 1 lynched

I was tempted to see reactions to me dropping SK

I liked how drastically different my two choices were. Town Hero or Serial Killer

I didn't mind being FBI agent though. I love getting good roles no matter what. But I'm rarely scum of any sort, so I really like to dig in and enjoy myself when I am. I think I've only gotten mafia, none of the other faction stuff for sure. Hope we get another game like this again some day.

There were many cops in this game.

Herm @ 29/1/2015 5:52

I promised you guys to be less vocal in future games.

Hm, vocal players is what makes the game and it's an important aspect of Mafia and bouncing ideas back and forth is really fun. So bad suggestion.

There were many points in this game when over half the cast were quiet with only 2-3 vocal people talking. I think everyone should be vocal in games, if you're quiet because other people criticizes your opinion, speak anyways. It's better than not saying anything at all. Although I don't think we have to take any leadership positions for town lol.

Angi @ 29/1/2015 15:05

I didn't mind being FBI agent though. I love getting good roles no matter what. But I'm rarely scum of any sort, so I really like to dig in and enjoy myself when I am. I think I've only gotten mafia, none of the other faction stuff for sure. Hope we get another game like this again some day.

Subtly setting yourself up as town for the next game. :P

I'm Town Bomb next game lol.

Herm @ 29/1/2015 15:57

Herm @ 29/1/2015 5:52 I promised you guys to be less vocal in future games. Hm, vocal players is what makes the game and it's an important aspect of Mafia and bouncing ideas back and forth is really fun. So bad suggestion. There were many points in this game when over half the cast were quiet with only 2-3 vocal people talking. I think everyone should be vocal in games, if you're quiet because other people criticizes your opinion, speak anyways. It's better than not saying anything at all. Although I don't think we have to take any leadership positions for town lol.

It's pretty hard to talk with bullies around, though, Herm!

Herm @ 29/1/2015 21:57

Herm @ 29/1/2015 5:52 I promised you guys to be less vocal in future games. Hm, vocal players is what makes the game and it's an important aspect of Mafia and bouncing ideas back and forth is really fun. So bad suggestion. There were many points in this game when over half the cast were quiet with only 2-3 vocal people talking. I think everyone should be vocal in games, if you're quiet because other people criticizes your opinion, speak anyways. It's better than not saying anything at all. Although I don't think we have to take any leadership positions for town lol.

YESSS

Buffy, we can always hand out anti-bullying vests.

The back and forth is what wins stuff on the town side and is rarely harmful to scum tbh, since information can be gleaned on decent targets and so on. It's really a necessary part of what makes a good mafia game.

People shouldn't be afraid of saying something stupid and getting caught up in suspicion if they're town. It's important for suspicion to build and players to be investigated. If somebody is wrongfully lynched on the town-side, information is still taken from it moreso if the player was vocal.

That bully crap was hilarious

Guys, I'm Town Vanilla!

ahoda @ 29/1/2015 15:02

I wanted to pick my scum role but if I passed on a role with the word "cop" I was day 1 lynched

Err, I discarded Town Lover Cop and lasted a few days

I'm ready to play this game now. I was AFK