It's between Samm and DD. Samm is difficult to read but he tossed some suspicion out for Matt early in the game and was pushing hard for a lynch. I could buy that the werewolves figured out Matt's role, but no way he'd have survived as long as he did were that the case so I dunno, I feel like Samm isn't the way to go.

I have to lean towards DD.

Of the two I would be more comfortable with DD. I understand what you're saying about Jamie being a non-threat, but they could still be submitting actions

I don't think Jamie has even been around since the game started. Has anybody seen him/her viewing the thread? Feels like a waste of a lynch to me.

I don't think so unless Jamie has figured out anonymous browsing.

they said hi on day 3

Patrick just looked up Jamie's profile. What did you find?

Nofo ☭ @ 25/1/2015 20:41

Patrick just looked up Jamie's profile. What did you find?

Day 3 Hi

Haven't logged on FE in a week.

DD also falls into the category of players who dip in and don't lynch at all but toss around a lot of suspicions. He also did this "sorry guys I'm here now!" thing one of the days which rubs me up the wrong way, I find it to be a common scum-tell.

Makes it kind of hard to tell one way or another when people do this. I'm comfortable with going this way, but figure he should at least have a chance to claim.

I really think there's no harm in everybody claiming now.

So, a non-entity. Not one of our two unknown killers.

If Jamie is the mastermind scum behind this whole operation, I swear to god.

I definitely agree with going for DD.

I think the other killer is either Samm or Patrick but I'd lean to Samm.

I don't think Samm would go on like this if he wasn't town though:

http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=3738&postsby=431
Seems a bit overkill when Matt would only be a threat to the werewolves (and they'd just have taken him out sooner if they knew)

PORL @ 25/1/2015 21:48

I don't think Samm would go on like this if he wasn't town though: http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=3738&postsby=431 Seems a bit overkill when Matt would only be a threat to the werewolves (and they'd just have taken him out sooner if they knew)

Well, ok but we still have a third killer out there. It has to be somebody.

We know Samm is a mason. What are the mason roles left

Patrick! No lynches, just tossing out suspicion. Convenient claim for a role that he knows won't be countered because everybody else is all claimed up or inactive.