Brian could be scum, he hasn't really been that suspicious. He had doubts about me, but wasn't sure whether if it was because he thought I was scum or if it because I had no filter lol. He's worth looking into.

I still think Ari based on gut more than anything

Herm @ 15/4/2014 0:02

Brian could be scum, he hasn't really been that suspicious.

It's things like this that make me so suspicious of you. Every time you state some sort of suspicion of someone, there's some sort of clause that you can use as an out if you're incorrect. Every time.

"They are suspicious of me" is not a valid reason to suspect someone, and I feel like you're just reaching for suspects by using it on Boc/Shadow. Town will inevitably suspect town. You don't suspect someone for suspecting you. You prove them wrong by being less fucking scummy, and every post you made Day 2 was VERY scummy. I had a town read on you Day 1 but that changed very quickly. Hot Cocoa's voting pattern and the rushed lynch on Malion are, if anything, the nail in your coffin, and I am nearly certain you are scum You want to change my mind? Scumhunt. Not having solid suspicions is scummy because, as mafia, you know the people you're "suspecting" are town and therefore it's more difficult to drive a wagon without getting your hands dirty and taking the risk of being suspicious.

I agree with you Tricks. Herm's post was crap.

I don't really like the way Buffy was so quick to brush Hot Cocoa's post under the rug (: I guess she's just been that defensive all game tho

And I do find Greenday's a role a bit iffy now. Maybe he was banking on the Mentor/Mentee being a normal cult that he could fake a claim on? It's risky, but it's a good claim. It just seems odd that there'd be TWO recruiting factions in this game. That seems a bit much for a 25ish person game

Boc @ 15/4/2014 1:33

I don't really like the way Buffy was so quick to brush Hot Cocoa's post under the rug (: I guess she's just been that defensive all game tho

Well, you'll most likely call this defensive but here goes. :P I feel like anytime I respond to anything you call me defensive. I don't see why I wouldn't respond to that and I also don't see how responding to it's "brushing it under the rug."

Brian hasn't said anything that makes him suspicious though, nor has he been

I do agree that I look suspicious, but I think I'll look suspicious no matter what I say. At least at this point. I'm not certain who is or isn't scum, I just feel that it'd be flawed of me to not consider both options when suspecting someone. Especially when I'm only 50% sure whoever I'm being suspicious of is scum.

And yeah lol, I know that I'm suspicious of them because they're being suspicious of me is the worst possibly theory to go on. I only truly know my own alignment and can only trust in the people I think are town and go with my gut feeling. I just have a feeling that scum are keeping me around at this point, because they probably hope that I'll get lynched instead of one of their own.

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 1:38

Boc @ 15/4/2014 1:33 I don't really like the way Buffy was so quick to brush Hot Cocoa's post under the rug (: I guess she's just been that defensive all game tho Well, you'll most likely call this defensive but here goes. :P I feel like anytime I respond to anything you call me defensive. I don't see why I wouldn't respond to that and I also don't see how responding to it's "brushing it under the rug."

It was just that Curtis wasn't even really saying it was evidence against you, he wasn't FOSing you over it or anything, but you still lept right away to clear your name. I dunno, I don't think the ACT of being defensive is necessarily scummy, it's just how/when

OMG fucking ops, I forgot to finish my Brian thought. Here it is again lol.

Brian hasn't said anything that makes him suspicious though, nor has he been really vocal about anyone in particular. This is why I suspect he might be scum.

Herm @ 15/4/2014 1:45

Brian hasn't said anything that makes him suspicious though, nor has he been I do agree that I look suspicious, but I think I'll look suspicious no matter what I say. At least at this point. I'm not certain who is or isn't scum, I just feel that it'd be flawed of me to not consider both options when suspecting someone. Especially when I'm only 50% sure whoever I'm being suspicious of is scum. And yeah lol, I know that I'm suspicious of them because they're being suspicious of me is the worst possibly theory to go on. I only truly know my own alignment and can only trust in the people I think are town and go with my gut feeling. I just have a feeling that scum are keeping me around at this point, because they probably hope that I'll get lynched instead of one of their own.

If scum are doing that, I think it's far more likely they'd let town go after you rather than get their hands dirty. That's pretty much the entire reason for mafia to keep suspicious people alive

Vernon of 2014 @ 15/4/2014 8:30

I agree with you Tricks. Herm's post was crap.

Come on, now that's just insulting. At least the others are calling me suspicious.

Boc @ 15/4/2014 1:46

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 1:38 Boc @ 15/4/2014 1:33 I don't really like the way Buffy was so quick to brush Hot Cocoa's post under the rug (: I guess she's just been that defensive all game tho Well, you'll most likely call this defensive but here goes. :P I feel like anytime I respond to anything you call me defensive. I don't see why I wouldn't respond to that and I also don't see how responding to it's "brushing it under the rug." It was just that Curtis wasn't even really saying it was evidence against you, he wasn't FOSing you over it or anything, but you still lept right away to clear your name. I dunno, I don't think the ACT of being defensive is necessarily scummy, it's just how/when

I don't know if he was or wasn't but it was put out there and I had an opinion about it. I'm sorry if you don't like me responding, or the timing or whatever, but I guess it's just my nature to give my opinion. I'm really trying to understand what you're saying but I honestly don't think if someone posts something about me it's bad that I respond. I don't know, I feel like I'm saying the same things over and over now so I guess I'll just keep saying what I think and you can think what you want.

Boc @ 15/4/2014 8:47

Herm @ 15/4/2014 1:45 And yeah lol, I know that I'm suspicious of them because they're being suspicious of me is the worst possibly theory to go on. I only truly know my own alignment and can only trust in the people I think are town and go with my gut feeling. I just have a feeling that scum are keeping me around at this point, because they probably hope that I'll get lynched instead of one of their own. If scum are doing that, I think it's far more likely they'd let town go after you rather than get their hands dirty. That's pretty much the entire reason for mafia to keep suspicious people alive

The majority of those who are suspicious are most likely town so you're probably correct. I do try to make serious observations of who would be best to lynch though and I can't believe that so many people find me so suspicious. There must be at least 1 or 2 scum being suspicious of me.

If I tried to be less suspicious would that even help me prove I'm town at this point lol?

*the majority of those who are suspicious of me*

I'm finding you more and more suspicious with each post.