itsbrianyay @ 19/12/2023 23:50

Rodney @ 19/12/2023 22:24 Brian Jamie Sami Star In that order. Brian is almost certainly scum and Jamie probably is too Can you explain this please?

Just process of elimination. The entire mafia team pretty much has to be within this list, and I ordered it from most to least likely from my perspective

Thisisbourbon @ 20/12/2023 0:51

Tattooed Tooth @ 19/12/2023 21:57 Oh btw I got a letter. I think Farlig wrote it. Did spin do what I asked him to?

If you asked him to do anything besides delivering the message, then no.
If it makes you feel better, I didn't tip him.

Tattooed Tooth @ 20/12/2023 6:38

Thisisbourbon @ 20/12/2023 0:51 Tattooed Tooth @ 19/12/2023 21:57 Oh btw I got a letter. I think Farlig wrote it. Did spin do what I asked him to? If you asked him to do anything besides delivering the message, then no. If it makes you feel better, I didn't tip him.

I asked him to tattoo it on your forehead.

With nav being scum we can’t buy stargate claim without pause. Nav is notorious for early fake claim planning and plausible ones at that.

In that case mafia had 2 kills last night because nobody else has claimed tib

Why would anyone, town or scum, come out and claim the kill?

Because it would be immediately obvious to them that Stargate is lying and mafia if they killed tib and weren't mafia

Maybe they are trying or will try to take the non-Ahoda approach to things.

Who wants to step on the cats tail and see if we can get them to show up and talk?

Jamie is here to negotiate

fwiw I would have been down to vote nav if i was around, I had a feeling he was scum even if it was for meta reasons (and they turned out to be true). I’ve been hesitant on voting because if I’m on a town train and that person is lynched, votes are anonymous the next day. If i’m on a non-town train, nothing happens as far as I know. I didn’t want to vote for someone and then not be around to unlynch if that train took off and I wasn’t feeling good about them being scum. I can prove my role but i’d rather not? unless we want to lynch town to prove it 🙃

Oh good news they're all just town

So far we’ve seen pretty basic role flips including several VT. Why are all the non standard ones still alive?

My sus list is probably

Sami & Brian (for both being mysteries in terms of roles but Brian probably below sami)
Rodney - if nav is telling the truth and he’s 3p arsodney
Z - if mafia doesn’t have a JOAT, could be mafia JOAT and that’s how Nav knew there was an arsonist and is either framing rodney or took a guess and figured it out?
TT - I believe he’s a survivor but if the people above all die and no arsonist is flipped, TT could be the arsonist
Farlig - messenger role is normally town but i’ve seen it as a mafia role before aka kat fooled me with it before when she was scum
stargate - vig type role is generally town

am I forgetting anyone?

Star