im317 @ 24/7/2023 8:33

Rose played that very well. i thought i was done for when Kat could say i lied. Ahoda we thought played better then he did by not knowing what he could do, and then thinking he could do it again.

I was busy that day so didn't have time to re-read but that round went so fast lol I was like bitch @ shadow for claiming my kill the next round haha
Every time I used my role, I used it on someone scum tho lol I protected shadow n1 since it was his first game in a while and then Jamie n3 because his posts are what I agreed with the most. Anyway great job Mafia! You guys did good. Thanks Nav for the game.

I literally only played cuz I thought it was a marvel mafia and was confused when I saw no marvel roles. lol
glad I played tho!!!!

I misread it myself. I thought I was coming in as Tobey Maguire or Stan Lee making a cameo.

From Nav's commentary thread:

Nav

Alright Mafia officially chose Shadow - Godjanitor Sami - Governor Herm - Redirector Brian - Disguiser JJ - Ninja/Strongman Pretty strong combo. Governor is actually stacked and is the best role they have. Redirector is a bit luck based in picking correctly. Disguiser as well isn't THAT useful mostly because there aren't that many traditional info gathering roles with the town. GodJanitor and Ninja/Strongman both solid picks. Overall a very souped up Mafia team both with the roles and the players. My setups do tend to be scum favored since I feel like its just way too hard to be scum on FE. That being said, so Town has a few roles that actually can't be straight up killed at night. Stargate - Suicide bomber Rose - Soul steal Ahoda - Beguiler Jed - Nexus And they have Kat to kill/protect, Farlig to get very strong information if he goes deep enough, Masons in play, a Cop variant. I'll stay optimistic for now and hope for a hotly contested game but at any rate, I'm happy with my setup. Very excited to see the fuckery that goes on at night with all these weird roles that can interact with each other.

I'm a huge fan of giving the mafia role choices and letting us pick who was who. I wanted the Governor role but I was being nice lol. Very sad we never got to use that role.

It's pretty funny that we ended up with the 4 townies you listed here - the ones that are hardest to kill.

Re your comments about the disguiser role, I don't think we knew we could just send Brian for the kill with the disguiser role - I think I interpreted it as a role you couldn't use with a kill since it didn't specifically talk about killing. I'm not sure if anyone else on our team knew but we probably should have asked. whoops! Would that have counted as a target, though?

Forgot to tell Shadow how amazing it was that he claimed the Kat kill! I forgot about Shadow's fake claim (Curtis's role) but that was so perfect!

I was so worried when I thought mafia was going to kill Rose because I figured she was lying about what she did/didn't have left but thought Ahoda had probably used all his actions, so was very happy to see them just kill Stargate.

Glad Shadow came up with the 3P claim so it could all just end lol.

Nav, do you have a spreadsheet where you keep track of all your past roles/fake claims? How many did you have to leave out?

Fun read, fun game. Thanks Nav!

JJ @ 23/7/2023 20:53

From Nav's commentary thread: Spoiler + Nav Alright Mafia officially chose Shadow - Godjanitor Sami - Governor Herm - Redirector Brian - Disguiser JJ - Ninja/Strongman Pretty strong combo. Governor is actually stacked and is the best role they have. Redirector is a bit luck based in picking correctly. Disguiser as well isn't THAT useful mostly because there aren't that many traditional info gathering roles with the town. GodJanitor and Ninja/Strongman both solid picks. Overall a very souped up Mafia team both with the roles and the players. My setups do tend to be scum favored since I feel like its just way too hard to be scum on FE. That being said, so Town has a few roles that actually can't be straight up killed at night. Stargate - Suicide bomber Rose - Soul steal Ahoda - Beguiler Jed - Nexus And they have Kat to kill/protect, Farlig to get very strong information if he goes deep enough, Masons in play, a Cop variant. I'll stay optimistic for now and hope for a hotly contested game but at any rate, I'm happy with my setup. Very excited to see the fuckery that goes on at night with all these weird roles that can interact with each other. I'm a huge fan of giving the mafia role choices and letting us pick who was who. I wanted the Governor role but I was being nice lol. Very sad we never got to use that role. It's pretty funny that we ended up with the 4 townies you listed here - the ones that are hardest to kill. Re your comments about the disguiser role, I don't think we knew we could just send Brian for the kill with the disguiser role - I think I interpreted it as a role you couldn't use with a kill since it didn't specifically talk about killing. I'm not sure if anyone else on our team knew but we probably should have asked. whoops! Would that have counted as a target, though? Forgot to tell Shadow how amazing it was that he claimed the Kat kill! I forgot about Shadow's fake claim (Curtis's role) but that was so perfect! I was so worried when I thought mafia was going to kill Rose because I figured she was lying about what she did/didn't have left but thought Ahoda had probably used all his actions, so was very happy to see them just kill Stargate. Glad Shadow came up with the 3P claim so it could all just end lol. Nav, do you have a spreadsheet where you keep track of all your past roles/fake claims? How many did you have to leave out? Fun read, fun game. Thanks Nav!

i was thinking about how to resolve the Disguiser vs the Forensic investigator and I was leaning towards having the disguiser's target show up in the results list but hadn't totally decided yet. i would have looked up the role and checked if there was any useful info about it

yes i do track my mafia games. apparently ive played 88. i had to leave a LOT out yes, one of my ideas was actually give each townie a choice between two roles and have them pick which one they wanted. but that was a logistical issue and it would have been even harder to balance and i didnt want to see some of my key roles being unpicked.

Congrats Mafia! Great job! You were all so obvious in your face mafia except IM and still won so well done!

Great game Nav!

Grumpy Old Man @ 23/7/2023 18:02

Jamie I want answer on why you recruited rodney!

🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️ I wanted someone slightly scummy that could help me strategize. His and Farligs roles could have really hurt me so I stand by my recruitments on them

cult4lyfe

well done mafia, you guys ran that game, thanks nav!

Guys Jamie farlig and rodney have an alliance for next game let’s d1 them

Then n1 badger as is tradition

Rude to take out Badger n1 in b2b games.

itsbrianyay @ 24/7/2023 15:45

Guys Jamie farlig and rodney have an alliance for next game let’s d1 them Then n1 badger as is tradition

do you want in? we are voting Nav

Sold

jamie @ 24/7/2023 17:52

itsbrianyay @ 24/7/2023 15:45 Guys Jamie farlig and rodney have an alliance for next game let’s d1 them Then n1 badger as is tradition do you want in? we are voting Nav

Can I get in in this?

Grumpy Old Man @ 24/7/2023 19:43

jamie @ 24/7/2023 17:52 itsbrianyay @ 24/7/2023 15:45 Guys Jamie farlig and rodney have an alliance for next game let’s d1 them Then n1 badger as is tradition do you want in? we are voting Nav Can I get in in this?

That means you can’t D1 me…

So, can you?

Absolutely not. I'm getting 2 votes