Christian @ 29/11/2018 13:07

Herm, it's a fake claim, it could very well be a fake name as well.

It really does disappoint me to see that you think I can't come up with a better fake claim than this.

Sebclops @ 29/11/2018 16:27

Christian @ 29/11/2018 13:26 Nav, why were you lynching yourself? Out of frustration.

I can understand the frustration, but it still isn't a good excuse if you're Town and want to help Town win.

Like what role do you think I am that I would directly counter claim your role

Mafia role cop works but he already died and wouldn’t know the details. And TBH “healer” sounds more like doc than pseudo-BP so I’d be even less likely to correctly fake claim

I am town healer. If lynched or killed I have a chance to survive (I DO know the percent chance but don’t want to say). That’s it

Curtis @ 29/11/2018 16:28

itsbrianyay @ 29/11/2018 16:25 Curtis @ 29/11/2018 15:19 Brian what would your theory be if I told you I had the exact same role as you but worded slightly differently Wouldn’t that be a little odd Sure yes that would be odd So do you think Mafia had timmah AND someone else who can scan roles??? How does that equate to me being scum no that's silly I've thought this through over and over but I wanna hear your theory on why both our roles would exist as Town. Or if you have a theory about me being third party or anything Have you not questioned my role whatsoever when I was basically countering?

that's a good point.

itsbrianyay @ 29/11/2018 16:26

Tbh timmah flip should essentially clear me of being Mafia. Why would I randomly directly CC you

This is exactly why I didn't go all in on you back then, Nav's failing to grasp it. It makes zero sense. Even if you somehow figured out my role via the title via Timmah it makes no sense for you to decide to just claim it as your own. Why counter someone...who can't be lynched. It'd be so stupid. That's why I've been at such a loss when approaching it

Sebclops @ 29/11/2018 16:30

Christian @ 29/11/2018 13:07 Herm, it's a fake claim, it could very well be a fake name as well. It really does disappoint me to see that you think I can't come up with a better fake claim than this.

I'm sorry you feel that way. :P

Christian @ 29/11/2018 13:30

Sebclops @ 29/11/2018 16:27 Christian @ 29/11/2018 13:26 Nav, why were you lynching yourself? Out of frustration. I can understand the frustration, but it still isn't a good excuse if you're Town and want to help Town win.

I also explained this. Proving my role for the sake of proving my role would be way more detrimental to Town than y'all just lynching me and maybe finally opening your eyes.

An interesting shape, looks more like an ostrich than a human.

What even is that Herm

Sebclops @ 29/11/2018 16:30

Christian @ 29/11/2018 13:07 Herm, it's a fake claim, it could very well be a fake name as well. It really does disappoint me to see that you think I can't come up with a better fake claim than this.

It disappoints the rest of us that you couldn't

Right now I have no reason to disbelieve us both as town. I don’t think as scum either one of us would openly counterclaim so early, especially in a closed role game.

In terms of why there would be 2 of the same, I can’t REALLY consider that without diving into a gray area rule-wise. Maybe there’s just 2 because Shadow thought it would be funny

Herm @ 29/11/2018 16:32

An interesting shape, looks more like an ostrich than a human.

that's not helpful in any way. :P

so ##Lynch Lamps

I have volunteered to be nav’d and helios’d to solve the case of my existence so that we don’t have to waste time focusing on me

Lynch Tally

Lamps (4/8): Curtis, Zersch, JJ, Herm, Spider, Primate, Christian
Nav (1/8): Curtis, Nav, Primate
Spider (1/8): Ahoda
Herm (1/8): Kat
Kat (0/8): Herm