Specifically I made a list of male SNL hosts from 2010 onward, haven't applied any other clues to them to narrow it down. I tried to leave out duplicates but stopped double checking at times because it was slowing me down.

Spoiler

+

Jon Hamm Robert De Niro Paul Rudd Jeff Bridges Jim Carrey Dana Carvey Zach Galifianakis Elton John Justin Timberlake Alec Baldwin Ben Stiller Steve Buscemi Jimmy Fallon Charles Barkley Jonah Hill Josh Brolin Eli Manning Will Ferrell Mick Jagger Joseph Gordon Levitt Daniel Craig Bruno Mars Louis C.K. Jamie Foxx Martin Short Adam Levine Justin Bieber Kevin Hart Vince Vaughn Ben Affleck Bruce Willis John Goodman Drake Seth Rogen Bill Hader Chris Rock Woody Harrelson James Franco Blake Shelton Chris Hemsworth Dwayne Johnson Michael Keaton Tracy Morgan Donald Trump Matthew McConaughey Ryan Gosling Adam Driver Larry David Jonah Hill Drake Fred Armison Lin Manuel Miranda Tom Hanks Benedict Cumberbatch Dave Chappelle John Cena Aziz Ansari Alex Baldwin Kumail Nanjiani Chance the Rapper Will Ferrell Charles Barkley Sterling K Brown Chadwick Boseman John Mulaney Donald Glover Steve Carell Jason Mamoa Matt Damon Don Cheadle Idris Elba Woody Harrelson Harry Styles Eddie Murphy JJ Watt RuPaul - Jason Bateman Timothee Chalamet Rege-Jean Page Nick Jonas Daniel Kaluuya Elon Musk Keegan-Michael Key Rami Malek Jonathan Majors Simu Liu Oscar Isaac Jerrod Carmichael Jake Gyllenhaal Jack Harlow Steve Martin & Martin Short Michael B Jordan Pedro Pascal Woody Harrelson Travis Kelce Bad Bunny Stricken: Musicians, minorities (I'm sure I missed some), wrestlers, athletes. Short list of one time hosts as I find them: David Harbour Miles Teller Bryan Cranston Sam Rockwell Seth MacFarlane Austin Butler Willem Dafoe Dan Levy Pete Davidson Edward Norton Nate Bargatze Casey Affleck John Krasinski Brendan Gleeson Josh Hutcherson Will Forte Jim Parsons Kieran Culkin Jason Sudeikis Charlie Day J.K. Simmons Jason Segel Christoph Waltz Ed Helms Owen Wilson Jesse Eisenberg Daniel Radcliffe Bill Burr Andrew Garfield Russell Brand Peter Dinklage Seth Meyers Martin Freeman Russell Crowe Andy Samberg Liev Schreiber Jeremy Renner Channing Tatum Chris Pine Adam Sandler James McAvoy Kit Harrington Chris Pratt

Curtis @ 15/11/2023 8:49

Are they at least 35 years old?

12. Yes!

I think this is our shortlist with everything taken into consideration.

Spoiler

+

David Harbour Miles Teller Sam Rockwell Willem Dafoe Dan Levy Edward Norton Nate Bargatze Casey Affleck John Krasinski Brendan Gleeson Will Forte Kieran Culkin Jason Sudeikis Charlie Day J.K. Simmons Jason Segel Ed Helms Owen Wilson Jesse Eisenberg Andrew Garfield Russell Brand Peter Dinklage Seth Meyers Martin Freeman Andy Samberg Liev Schreiber Jeremy Renner Channing Tatum Chris Pine James McAvoy Kit Harrington

Did this person first become famous because of a television show instead of a movie?

Zersch @ 15/11/2023 17:42

I think this is our shortlist with everything taken into consideration. Spoiler + David Harbour Miles Teller Bryan Cranston Sam Rockwell Seth MacFarlane Willem Dafoe Dan Levy Edward Norton Nate Bargatze Casey Affleck John Krasinski Brendan Gleeson Will Forte Jim Parsons Kieran Culkin Jason Sudeikis Charlie Day J.K. Simmons Jason Segel Christoph Waltz Ed Helms Owen Wilson Jesse Eisenberg Daniel Radcliffe Bill Burr Andrew Garfield Russell Brand Peter Dinklage Seth Meyers Martin Freeman Russell Crowe Andy Samberg Liev Schreiber Jeremy Renner Channing Tatum Chris Pine Adam Sandler James McAvoy Kit Harrington Chris Pratt Did this person first become famous because of a television show instead of a movie?

13. Yes!

Has this person been in an MCU movie?

Herm @ 16/11/2023 13:47

Has this person been in an MCU movie?

14. No

(haven't given that list a good proper look, but that probably knocks a few of them out of the running)

believe this is the shortlist after those last two questions:

Dan Levy
Will Forte
Kieran Culkin
Jason Sudeikis
Charlie Day
Jason Segel
Ed Helms
Seth Meyers
Andy Samberg

was this person a cast member on SNL at one point?

Boc @ 16/11/2023 21:33

was this person a cast member on SNL at one point?

15. You bet!

Is the person one of the stars of this skit?

Zersch @ 16/11/2023 22:51

Is the person one of the stars of this skit?

16. Yes lol

Is this person.....Jason Sudeikis

Curtis @ 17/11/2023 18:49

Is this person.....Jason Sudeikis

17. It sure is!

Originally it was going to be Ted Lasso (the character) because I just recently watched Ted Lasso (the series). I wasn't sure I'd be able to answer that many questions about a fictional character lol

Anyone wanna take my turn since I just went?

Giving Herm a chance to see this and accept/decline before I take a turn again.

This was a lie.