Malion 🌟 @ 8/9/2020 19:56

jamie @ 8/9/2020 20:52 ty for those who gave lists, mine would be the same from earlier but reaper feels more scum and mal would probably lean more scum at this point It was only a matter of time before the dominos fell. I'm not really a reads guy tbf. Like my whole thing yesterday was I got a really strong feeling zersch was town (and that was just extreme wifoming on my part) so I went with the opposite train. I didn't even know if that was going to work out it just ended up working out.

You have to have some baseline reads here like I'm not asking you to pinpoint exactly who you think is scum and town beyond a shadow of a doubt Just who you've felt good/bad about at different times in the game.

Town:
Timmah
Rodney
Im317
Jamie

Probably maybe town
Zersch

Probably not mafia
Spin

Not sure
Farlig
Tib

The back and forth group
Mal
Perry
Matt

Seems scum but role checks out
Kyle
Cody

Probably scum
Zach

Timmah @ 8/9/2020 20:02

Town: Timmah Rodney Im317 Jamie Probably maybe town Zersch Probably not mafia Spin Not sure Farlig Tib The back and forth group Mal Perry Matt Seems scum but role checks out Kyle Cody Probably scum Zach

And Reaper?

Timmah you forgot about Reaper!

Poor reaper

Anyone whose name is at the bottom who doesn't submit a list is getting spanked.

The Goose @ 8/9/2020 21:08

Anyone whose name is at the bottom who doesn't submit a list is getting spanked.

my name is at the bottom.

The Goose @ 9/9/2020 1:08

Anyone whose name is at the bottom who doesn't submit a list is getting spanked.

Don’t threaten people with a good time

Timmah @ 8/9/2020 19:53

Spin @ 8/9/2020 19:41 Timmah @ 8/9/2020 19:01 Yeah. Reaper has worked his way back nearish the top of my scum list. Though I’ve felt better about Matt Perry and Mal I could still see one of them being scum. Spin isn’t likely mafia. SK maybe? I was blocked N1 by the box, couldn't take an action N2 because of Herm, and I was roleblocked (I believe) last night. If I'm the SK, then we have another kill to try to figure out. Did you say you were blocked? I thought you just said punched and later added that you may have been blocked or something? N2, how would we know that you weren’t one of the 2 kills? I must’ve missed your being blocked last night.

The box I opened N1 had a glove on a spring in it, and it knocked me out for the night, preventing me from taking an action.

I said right at the beginning of the day today (when I checked in at least), that I was likely blocked last night. The flavor was something along the lines of I couldn't get out of my chair or something (I don't want to direct quote), so making a simple assumption, I was blocked.

N2, I guess you'll just have to take my word for it.

The Goose @ 8/9/2020 21:01

Malion 🌟 @ 8/9/2020 19:56 jamie @ 8/9/2020 20:52 ty for those who gave lists, mine would be the same from earlier but reaper feels more scum and mal would probably lean more scum at this point It was only a matter of time before the dominos fell. I'm not really a reads guy tbf. Like my whole thing yesterday was I got a really strong feeling zersch was town (and that was just extreme wifoming on my part) so I went with the opposite train. I didn't even know if that was going to work out it just ended up working out. You have to have some baseline reads here like I'm not asking you to pinpoint exactly who you think is scum and town beyond a shadow of a doubt Just who you've felt good/bad about at different times in the game.

Ok you're right I'll make a little top to bottom list

I feel good about
Zersch (for stated reasons And because he's cool)
Im (for coming in hot early with the role that can easily be cc and has not been)
Perry (I just can't lynch perry anyway so I have to trust him)
Rodney (I like his energy I think he's for sure a Good Cop)

Everyone is saying Jamie but I don't think I've payed enough attention to him to say either way.

Zach is bad
Cody is probably bad
Kyle?... Hmm kyle might be bad but I want to give him the benefit.
Reaper I think for sure is bad for his inactivity and because he doesn't like Hamilton

I thought Brian was here is he dead? I should check

Oh Brian was bad I called that yesterday but tbf thats usually obvious

Honestly, I've probably not paid enough attention to have a full reads list, but whatever, here goes nothing:

Definitely Town
21. Spin

Probably Town
9. Rodney - it was his interaction with Penner solely that puts him here for me
10. im317 - unless he's a dgaf SK, he's not mafia
4. Zersch - starting the train on Jackie makes me lean Town JOAT instead of Scum

Probably scum
12. Zach
23. Cody

Everyone else - there is definitely scum in here, I just have absolutely no idea whom
2. Mal
13. Farlig
17. Timmah
18. Kyle
19. TIB
20. Jamie
22. Matt
25. Reaper
27. Perry

Town Feel - Would not lynch
17. Timmah
20. Jamie
27. Perry
These 3 i put in my town category based on feel and reading their posts. Feel all 3 come across town and have been trying to direct town in a helpful way.

Town i wouldn't lynch but questions remain
10. im317 - I really want IM to be a bad guy and that day 2 missed kill be an incredible gambit
4. Zersch - I was on his lynch train yesterday, and as i said questions remain. But wouldn't be a top choice today. I'm ok with his Maddie shot.
18. Kyle - TBH you could tell me he's mafia and I prob wouldn't lynch him. Didn't have to own up to the Penner kill but did.

I'd probably lynch just cause
9. Rodney

Still trying to get a read on
13. Farlig - I mean, i dunno
19. TIB - I love him but sometimes he's such a whiny beatch that i just wanna get rid of him. I dunno.

I forgot him but he seems like his normal self. Not high on my lynch list
21. Spin

Would lynch and sleep soundly
2. Mal
12. Zach
22. Matt
23. Cody
25. Reaper

Cody and Zach obviously the flavor of the day. One will get resolved. Mal and Matt I flat out don't trust. Reaper hasn't been involved enough and i could have slot him into any category really.

I’d probably move spin down my town list into more of a split. I feel you are active enough have more of a read list than that, sorry

I like how Mal left off like 5 or 6 alive people but mentions Dead Brian