BadgerMcBeaver @ 28/1/2016 22:50

Not gonna try and defend any of my decisions or reads in this game. It was by far the worst that I've ever done in a mafia game and I was just getting frustrated/embarrassed by the end (definitely raged to Christian in a few PMs). Sorry town! Good job to the mafia, you certainly had me fooled.

Oh, please share those rage PMs. :)

Herm @ 29/1/2016 1:14

Lynching Jay over Wikey was a bit of a blunder actually. Hard to say how things could've turned out if one or two things had gone differently.

Letting you live as a "Town Miller" was the single biggest mistake the entire game imo. Even if it was true and you were a town miller, you should have been lynched early just to remove the confusion that it creates in looking for scum. I know that if I truly was a Town Miller I'd self vote day one and remove myself from the game for I think that'd be the town thing to do.

Ben @ 29/1/2016 16:09

Herm @ 29/1/2016 1:14 Lynching Jay over Wikey was a bit of a blunder actually. Hard to say how things could've turned out if one or two things had gone differently. Letting you live as a "Town Miller" was the single biggest mistake the entire game imo. Even if it was true and you were a town miller, you should have been lynched early just to remove the confusion that it creates in looking for scum. I know that if I truly was a Town Miller I'd self vote day one and remove myself from the game for I think that'd be the town thing to do.

When should Herm have been lynched? (apart from the obvious answer, day 9!)

Yeah. In fairness scum was lynched everyday that Herm wasn't except D9

Ari @ 29/1/2016 14:12

Ben @ 29/1/2016 16:09 Herm @ 29/1/2016 1:14 Lynching Jay over Wikey was a bit of a blunder actually. Hard to say how things could've turned out if one or two things had gone differently. Letting you live as a "Town Miller" was the single biggest mistake the entire game imo. Even if it was true and you were a town miller, you should have been lynched early just to remove the confusion that it creates in looking for scum. I know that if I truly was a Town Miller I'd self vote day one and remove myself from the game for I think that'd be the town thing to do. When should Herm have been lynched? (apart from the obvious answer, day 9!)

How about when Patrick said that he was scum?

Or after Patrick was killed and confirmed scum?

Any town role that scans as mafia doesn't help the town if they are indeed scanned and it's know.

Vic @ 29/1/2016 14:14

Yeah. In fairness scum was lynched everyday that Herm wasn't except D9

I understand that, but I think things play out much differently if Herm is lynched Day 3, cause you'd have a different fake claim to evaluate and make a decision at the end. Not that it would have made any difference in who won.

I actually felt more confident in all of the lynches from Day 3 to Day 8 than lynching Herm.

3: Miko was obviously saved by mafia
4: Dadd was obviously trying to save Miko
5: Jay was very suspect, I was also happy with Wikey here
6: Wikey had a very small post count and looked bad
7: Brian was lying
8: im317 looked like he was ready to lynch pretty much everyone and was scrambling big time to survived. Seemed pretty scummy to me!

Pretty sure this

24. Merc - Town Sibling (Killed Day 4)
29. Rob - Town Sibling (Killed Day 4)
12. Chris25 - Town Friendly Neighbour (Killed Day 4)
5. Primate - Town Blacksmith (Killed Night 3)
13. Ben - Town Bodyguard (Killed Night 3)
18. Miko - Mafia Roleblocker (Lynched Day 3)
31. Nofo - Town Vanilla (Killed Day 3)
25. Canuck - Town Roleblocker (Killed Night 2)
10. dr - Town Motion Detector (Killed Night 2)
20. JJ/Buffy - Town Doctor (Killed Day 2)
22. Titan - Town Vengeful (Lynched Day 2)
27. redster - Town Vanilla (Killed Night 1)
17. Ryan Grant - Town Vanilla (Lynched Day 1)
30. wait, wat? - Back-up Town Vigilante (Modkilled Day 1)

lost it for town.

And not because Herm wasnt lynched.

Agreed, each successful lynch made a bit more sense at the time

Town deserves a little more credit tbh. That was one of the most successful lynch streaks we've ever had here, if not the most. The one D9 mislynch is only being focused on and was only costly because of the huge mistakes of several townies who died early on

It felt like Obama inheriting the shitty Town following the Bush administration and then getting all the blame. NOT FAIR MAN!

Town can have some credit for the successful lynches, but Mafia helped a lot there as well. lol

Christian @ 29/1/2016 9:29

Town can have some credit for the successful lynches, but Mafia helped a lot there as well. lol

Yeah Vic and Herm pushed several of those lynches out there. Town can't really take any credit for them.

Primate @ 29/1/2016 10:38

Christian @ 29/1/2016 9:29 Town can have some credit for the successful lynches, but Mafia helped a lot there as well. lol Yeah Vic and Herm pushed several of those lynches out there. Town can't really take any credit for them.

lol any? How so

Herm added one vote to some of the trains yes but he didn't exactly catch any of the Mafia. And Vic hounded Jay but everyone that Vic went for were already under fire by the rest of us anyway. Miko, Dadd, Wikey, and Jay all made themselves look bad through their actions or inactions and everyone was calling them out for it

In fact a lot of what made Herm look suspicious and tipped me off that he was scum was his lack of pushing for Mafia lynches and attempt to distract

Ari @ 29/1/2016 14:59

I actually felt more confident in all of the lynches from Day 3 to Day 8 than lynching Herm. 3: Miko was obviously saved by mafia 4: Dadd was obviously trying to save Miko 5: Jay was very suspect, I was also happy with Wikey here 6: Wikey had a very small post count and looked bad 7: Brian was lying 8: im317 looked like he was ready to lynch pretty much everyone and was scrambling big time to survived. Seemed pretty scummy to me!

I don't disagree, my point is that a miller claim even if true is going to be a distraction and not good for town. Patrick God love him exposed Herm as scum, and he was never lynched for it. That doesn't make sense to me. But you are right town was fucked from the start and at a disadvantage by Robb and DMF.

But this aides to my belief that Herm is always scummy. ;)