Mittens @ 10/8/2019 10:38

I’ve never been good at picking up role hints, so consider me completely lost as to what Nav is. Penner is clearly town imo, but I still kinda believe Cavin. Also I believe Cody. So, yeah, that’s where I stand. My role was successful last night fwiw. No “unsuccessful” bs

And did you not read all the times Cavin backtracked on his role and how his statements contradict stuff he said in prior days?

Penner @ 10/8/2019 9:43

Mittens @ 10/8/2019 10:38 I’ve never been good at picking up role hints, so consider me completely lost as to what Nav is. Penner is clearly town imo, but I still kinda believe Cavin. Also I believe Cody. So, yeah, that’s where I stand. My role was successful last night fwiw. No “unsuccessful” bs And did you not read all the times Cavin backtracked on his role and how his statements contradict stuff he said in prior days?

I read everything. I didn’t really see it through that lense, but could easily be wrong.

There’s been enough weird results in the game so far to give me pause.

Also, I’m headed to my cabin in a few hours so will be very hit and miss the rest of the day.

My top two scum reads into the night we’re TIB and Cavin.

I agree now with others that Josh looks stanky.

I’d feel a lot better if Nav claimed, because it sounds like we could piece more of the game together. But I’m fine with him keeping it to himself for now.

Primate is a dumbass.

Im317, any thoughts?

im here now. will start reading right away

Prince Navneeta @ 9/8/2019 20:25

wikeyb9m3bek @ 9/8/2019 16:24 Prince Navneeta @ 9/8/2019 19:22 wikeyb9m3bek @ 9/8/2019 16:21 Prince Navneeta @ 9/8/2019 19:19 wikeyb9m3bek @ 9/8/2019 16:18 Nav could be SK Why I don't know. Perhaps you could answer some questions for me. To start with, did you kill anyone last night? No. I don't have the ability to kill. Unfortunately So if I said that I had been lying about my vanilla role and that I saw you visiting someone who died last night, what would you say? That you have bad information. I have a visiting role but I did not visit Ahoda last night

quick to jump to not visiting Ahoda when all he said was you visited someone who died, not which person. even thought he was just messing with us i still think its noteworthy.

wikeyb9m3bek @ 9/8/2019 20:28

Maybe I'm dense but I didn't notice Ahoda drop any obvious hints of his role, so either scum have a role cop or they got lucky last night. Assuming they targeted Ahoda and not Rodney/Spin of course.

Brian had a role cop as one of his actions. just as a refresher he could use 3 out of 5 of these

Role Cop: Choose a target at night and learn the name of their role.
Protect: Choose a target to protect from attacks during that night phase.
Track: Choose a player and see where they go that night.
Strongman: If you are performing the factional kill, you can make it an unstoppable one, which will bypass all forms of protective or disruptive actions.
Steal vote: Choose a player and they will not be able to cast a lynch vote during the following day phase.

Prince Navneeta @ 9/8/2019 22:13

Also if I'm reading correctly, both garlic and Primate are claiming to be poisoned?

motivator?

Cavin @ 9/8/2019 22:31

Penner didn't track me to Rodney.

help me out. with that mess of claims day 3 did we end up finding out that there was not a re-director (other then Lamps) in play?

Primate @ 9/8/2019 22:32

Cody @ 9/8/2019 20:31 Primate @ 9/8/2019 19:30 Damnit cody. You gave nag a fantastic accidental nickname yesterday and you aren't even using it. Get ur shit together, man. my shit is NEVER together lmfaoooo Ur talking to the guy who forgot to hit send, fucked himself and guzzled some poison.

not the first time you have taken poison either, would only be more fun if you self ingested again.

anyways 200 posts down, will read more now.

Prince Navneeta @ 10/8/2019 5:39

Lamps @ 10/8/2019 1:20 Cavin as SK doesn’t make much sense btw since we had 2 kills N1 with Ahoda blocked, and he said he was unsuccessful (which may be a lie, but doesn’t really look like one). So then do all of you voters think he is mafia? This is a decent point. We also have the info of Penner tracking Calvin to nowhere on N1. Hmmm. This would fit with Wikey's theory of an SK team though. If Calvin is the even night SK and someone else is the Odd night SK. Or if they share a forum and can decide who goes when but just can't go back to back? And N2 was considered a failed action so Calvin got to go out on N3? The only problem with this is Calvin wasn't seen at Lamps' So in this scenario SK(s) chose to No Kill on N2 Is there a reason we ruled out Cody as SK?

You came to the correct conclusion here. Penner didn't see me go anywhere n1 so my unsuccessful is a confirmed thing

Prince Navneeta @ 10/8/2019 5:50

The one thing I can think of that would explain Penner having incorrect results is a Master of Disguise. Someone pretended to be Calvin at night and so Penner got that result. I don't really buy a redirect on Penner tbh

I mean it was pretty clear yesterday that Penner was a likely investigative role of some sort because Farlig outted as doc

wikeyb9m3bek @ 10/8/2019 5:54

Cody @ 10/8/2019 5:53 I just think Cavin is lying tbh. That quote from D2 of him getting weird results or whatever just doesn’t make full sense. You shouldn’t really get back results or whatever with a BG so lol. I will say tho, that cavin is hella convincing. I want Cavin to address that post and explain exactly what he meant. After that I'll consider whether I want to lynch him or not.

I was told that I could use my power on n2 and when I asked if it was because I was blocked and he said no but that my action was unsuccessful. If you read back on my posts from yesterday that's why I didn't believe buffy because I wasn't originally told outright that my action was unsuccessful like she was claiming

Cody @ 9/8/2019 23:12

Primate @ 9/8/2019 20:11 I honestly don't know if bg covers poisonings? I dont think so. When I had a poison mechanic in Carmen Sandiego mini mafia, I think it bypassed it, iirc

well yeah its bodyguard not food tester or cupbearer.

just want to point out that the hider did not die by hiding behind scum. now on to post 351

wikeyb9m3bek @ 10/8/2019 6:03

I really hope there is an antidote role. There must be.

Farlig said something about a day kill role yesterday so kinda want him to address if he can save himself or not

farlig @ 10/8/2019 6:37

Farlig can confirm: I’m the doctor. My role uses attacks. I have the ability to save either primate or I today.

Okay yup this is what I thought

Cavin @ 9/8/2019 22:07

Penner @ 9/8/2019 22:05 If Cavin bodyguarded farlig last night, wouldn’t Cavin get the poison? Farlig wasn't technically attacked.

farlig @ 10/8/2019 7:21

Primate @ 10/8/2019 7:17 farlig @ 10/8/2019 5:37 Farlig can confirm: I’m the doctor. My role uses attacks. I have the ability to save either primate or I today. What do you mean uses attacks. Are the sex clone robot attacks?Because My role says I stop attacks.

Bingo, this is exactly what my role says too and I mentioned this earlier