BadgerMcBeaver @ 10/8/2023 11:23

I've been saying that we don't know much about your role Rose, but I haven't been pressuring you to claim or complaining about the fact that you haven't. I prefer games that are slower with claims. They are more fun. But I don't feel the need to rehash this conversation because I know others don't see eye to eye with me on this.

btw when whoever kills me play close attention to my passive, i think the implications are very interesting

Whoops I was trying to remove quoting the wrong post. But I’ll always care when someone is wrong on me especially when I feel they’re wrong on many other reads. Clearly Rose doesn’t care about evidence and just does what they feel. Many people are liking the posts to support that type of anti-town behavior which is very unfortunate.

Not caring about people who lynched mafia is what got Town RB murdered by lazy Vig

alright, whats the accepted take on the lamps voters today?

the lamps voters were all town and blindly voted day one for mafia and succeeded despite the odds?

or the lamps voters were all mafia throwing their comrade under the bus to look good once they realized their teammate was inactive?

its not worth putting that much weight on, especially in this game

Anyone who assumes that all the Lamps voters were good is disregarding the fact that we know at least 1 evil person was on that train (Steph was converted the following night).

TT wouldn't have been my target if I were vig but I don't blame Jamie for trusting his read over a day 1 vote.

I’m not saying to assume all the Lamps voters are good, but there’s no reason to kill any of them early on without probable cause

Penner @ 10/8/2023 11:41

I’m not saying to assume all the Lamps voters are good, but there’s no reason to kill any of them early on without probable cause

who has dared advocate for this

And all Lamps voters should be at worst viewed neutrally

d1 votes mean nothing and i think we should throw that logic out the window

We're an ensemble cast there is no main character except me and Rose

drrlig @ 10/8/2023 11:42

Penner @ 10/8/2023 11:41 I’m not saying to assume all the Lamps voters are good, but there’s no reason to kill any of them early on without probable cause who has dared advocate for this

Well you said you’d put me in your “bad” tier implying you wouldn’t mind me getting lynched

FFS people will suspect whoever they feel they should suspect. People will have different views about what is and isn't scummy, and that's fine.

I'm on like 75% of the scum lists in this game and you don't see me bitching about it.

Penner @ 10/8/2023 8:02

I guess the things to think about and hear more from Spin are: 1) How was Spin informed it didn’t happen? Like would it be a RB or just a failed attempt due to head’s restrictions 2) Could it be something where the head can’t be given to someone attempting a kill that night? Idk

I'm still catching up, but figured I'd respond to this quick.

I was informed that my attempt to give him the head was unsuccessful. That was all of it. I have no idea if someone tried to block me, if Ahoda somehow can't receive the head, or what else was going on.

Penner @ 10/8/2023 11:31

Whoops I was trying to remove quoting the wrong post. But I’ll always care when someone is wrong on me especially when I feel they’re wrong on many other reads. Clearly Rose doesn’t care about evidence and just does what they feel. Many people are liking the posts to support that type of anti-town behavior which is very unfortunate.

It’s d3 and one townie has died lol. I think we can afford to have fun