Part of my read on mittens is that all he did for a number of days in a row is “compile data” without giving any actual thoughts. He “advocated” for either Brian or Buffy’s lynch (maybe both) without actually voting to lynch them. And he came to Cavin’s defense yesterday like he knew Cavin wasn’t going to flip mafia and wanted town cred in case Cavin was not lying about his BG role.

For im317 to be mafia, he would have to have been pissed about rolling mafia early in the game and instructed his scummates to throw him under the bus. Because that’s what Curtis did basically, and they had no way to predict Curtis would die that early.

Because let’s think about this. Buffy was sent out for the kill N2. Right?

So. We have to assume the other mafia memeber used roles that night otherwise why did Buffy do the kill.

So. We have nav with an unsuccessful that night. Josh with an unsuccessful (confirmed scum of some kind)

So I think this probabaly clears 317 and Wikey to an extent.

Meaning TiB Timmah Mittens Nav. 2/4 have to be scum. If we had 5 Maf and 2 third party roles.

I forget who exactly claimed they had unsuccessfuls that night. Mittens did too right? Timmah? TiB didn’t. And wouldn’t if he’s actually vengeful.

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 15:10

Cody @ 12/8/2019 14:40 Are 3 VTs in a game this size believable? I basically asked this earlier, and no one answered.

Think for yourself bro

None of us know the setup, so what's the point of this angle

If it isn't im317, it would make sense to string up TIB.

Herm @ 12/8/2019 13:20

If it isn't im317, it would make sense to string up TIB.

What. Were. Your. Night. Actions.

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 15:13

Part of my read on mittens is that all he did for a number of days in a row is “compile data” without giving any actual thoughts. He “advocated” for either Brian or Buffy’s lynch (maybe both) without actually voting to lynch them. And he came to Cavin’s defense yesterday like he knew Cavin wasn’t going to flip mafia and wanted town cred in case Cavin was not lying about his BG role.

Ya, I was trying to figure out the mechanics of all the goofy shit. Brian and Buffy were both slam dunks eventually, and there was no point in lynching them early. Try again.

I was right that Cavin wasn't mafia lol

i am town. i have not been as active this game and this day in particularly because i have spent the majority of my free time playing the new Fire Emblem game. i have read part of this day now and i have to say i dont like the way Mittens is tunneling on Timmah

I'll claim if Timmah does first.

I have not had a single “unsuccessful” night action in this game. Nor have I performed a single “successful” night action.

Mittens @ 12/8/2019 15:21

I'll claim if Timmah does first.

That’s a really shady position to take considering everyone else has already claimed and you have vowed to WOW us with your towniness upon your claim.

Cody @ 12/8/2019 12:17

Because let’s think about this. Buffy was sent out for the kill N2. Right? So. We have to assume the other mafia memeber used roles that night otherwise why did Buffy do the kill. So. We have nav with an unsuccessful that night. Josh with an unsuccessful (confirmed scum of some kind) So I think this probabaly clears 317 and Wikey to an extent. Meaning TiB Timmah Mittens Nav. 2/4 have to be scum. If we had 5 Maf and 2 third party roles. I forget who exactly claimed they had unsuccessfuls that night. Mittens did too right? Timmah? TiB didn’t. And wouldn’t if he’s actually vengeful.

This is one of the worst theories I've read all game.

Ok so Timmah isn't what I thought he was.

He shoots to the top of my scum list then. That was easy.

##unlynch
##lynch Timmah

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 15:23

Mittens @ 12/8/2019 15:21 I'll claim if Timmah does first. That’s a really shady position to take considering everyone else has already claimed and you have vowed to WOW us with your towniness upon your claim.

Is it? What are you, the 4th VT?

Cody @ 12/8/2019 15:17

Because let’s think about this. Buffy was sent out for the kill N2. Right? So. We have to assume the other mafia memeber used roles that night otherwise why did Buffy do the kill. So. We have nav with an unsuccessful that night. Josh with an unsuccessful (confirmed scum of some kind) So I think this probabaly clears 317 and Wikey to an extent. Meaning TiB Timmah Mittens Nav. 2/4 have to be scum. If we had 5 Maf and 2 third party roles. I forget who exactly claimed they had unsuccessfuls that night. Mittens did too right? Timmah? TiB didn’t. And wouldn’t if he’s actually vengeful.

Nav was unsuccessful, which would fit with the bus director since he needs to target 2 people. I think Mittens did say that he was unsuccessful that night, but cannot remember exactly.